Turkish Code of Obligations

Turkish Code of Obligations

Update 2026

TURKISH CODE OF OBLIGATIONS

Law No.: 6098
Date of Adoption: 11/1/2011
Official Gazette: 4/2/2011, No. 27836
Code of Laws (Düstur): Series 5, Volume 50

Publication date on our website: November 11, 2026

Turkish Code of Obligations

PART ONE

General Provisions

CHAPTER ONE

Sources of Obligations

SECTION ONE

Obligations Arising from Contract

A. Formation of the contract

I. Declaration of intent

1. In general

Article 1 – A contract is formed by the parties declaring their intentions mutually and in conformity with each other.

A declaration of intent may be express or implied.

2. Secondary points

Article 2 – If the parties have agreed on the essential points of the contract, the contract shall be deemed to have been formed even if the secondary points have not been dealt with.

If no agreement can be reached on the secondary points, the judge shall decide the dispute having regard to the nature of the transaction.

The provisions concerning the form of contracts are reserved.

II. Offer and acceptance

1. Offer with a time limit

Article 3 – A person who offers to conclude a contract and sets a time limit for acceptance is bound by his or her offer until the expiry of that time limit.

If the acceptance does not reach the offeror within that time limit, the offeror is released from being bound by the offer.

2. Offer without a time limit

a. Between persons present

Article 4 – If an offer made to a person who is present without a time limit for acceptance being set is not accepted immediately, the offeror is released from being bound by the offer.

An offer made in the course of direct communication by means capable of providing communication, such as telephone or computer, shall be deemed to have been made between persons present.

b. Between persons not present

Article 5 – An offer made to a person who is not present without a time limit for acceptance being set binds the offeror until the moment at which the arrival of a reply dispatched in due time and in the proper manner could be expected.

The offeror may assume that his or her offer arrived in due time.

If an acceptance dispatched in due time reaches the offeror late and the offeror does not wish to be bound by it, he or she is obliged to notify the acceptor of this immediately.

3. Implied acceptance

Article 6 – Where the offeror is not obliged, by law or by the nature of the transaction or the circumstances, to expect an express acceptance, the contract shall be deemed to have been formed if the offer is not rejected within a reasonable time.

4. Sending of unordered goods

Article 7 – The sending of an unordered thing shall not be deemed an offer. The person receiving such a thing is not obliged to send it back or to keep it.

5. Non-binding offer and offer to the public

Article 8 – If the offeror expressly states that he or she reserves the right not to be bound by the offer, or if it is apparent from the nature of the transaction or from the circumstances that he or she does not intend to be bound, the offer does not bind him or her.

The display of goods with an indication of their price, or the sending of tariffs, price lists or the like, shall be deemed an offer unless the contrary is clearly and easily apparent.

6. Promise of a reward by public announcement

Article 9 – A person who announces by public notice that he or she will give a reward in return for the achievement of a result is obliged to fulfil his or her promise.

If the person who has promised the reward withdraws the promise before the result is achieved, or prevents the achievement of the result, he or she is obliged to pay the expenses incurred in accordance with the rules of good faith. However, the total of the expenses to be paid to one or more persons may not exceed the value of the reward.

If the person who has promised the reward proves that those claiming payment of their expenses could not have achieved the expected result, he or she is released from the obligation to pay the expenses.

7. Revocation of the offer and of the acceptance

Article 10 – If the declaration of revocation reaches the other party before or at the same time as the offer, or, although reaching it later, comes to the knowledge of the other party before the offer, the offer shall be deemed not to have been made.

This rule also applies to the revocation of the acceptance.

III. Time at which a contract formed between persons not present takes effect

Article 11 – Contracts formed between persons not present take effect from the moment at which the acceptance is dispatched.

In cases where an express acceptance is not required, the contract takes effect from the moment at which the offer arrives.

B. Form of contracts

I. General rule

Article 12 – The validity of contracts is not subject to any form unless otherwise provided by law.

The form prescribed by law for contracts is, as a rule, a form required for validity. Contracts concluded without complying with the prescribed form produce no effect.

II. Written form

1. Statutory form

a. Scope

Article 13 – The written form must also be complied with in the amendment of a contract which the law requires to be made in writing. However, supplementary ancillary terms which do not contradict the text of the contract are excepted from this rule.

This rule also applies to forms required for validity other than the written form.

b. Elements

Article 14 – In contracts required to be made in writing, the signatures of the persons undertaking obligations must be present.

Unless otherwise provided by law, a signed letter, a telegram the original of which has been signed by the persons undertaking obligations, faxes or similar means of communication provided that they have been confirmed, or texts which can be sent and stored with a secure electronic signature, also substitute for the written form.

c. Signature

Article 15 – The signature must be affixed in the handwriting of the person undertaking the obligation. A secure electronic signature also produces all the legal consequences of a handwritten signature.

The affixing of a signature by a means other than handwriting shall be deemed sufficient only in cases accepted by custom and usage, and in particular for the signing of negotiable instruments issued in large numbers.

(Amended paragraph: 13/2/2011-6111/213 art.) At the request of visually impaired persons, a witness shall be required for their signatures. Otherwise, it shall be sufficient for visually impaired persons to affix their signatures in handwriting.

d. Marks substituting for signature

Article 16 – Persons who are unable to sign may, in place of a signature, use a fingerprint, a mark made by hand or a seal, provided that it has been duly certified.

The provisions concerning bills of exchange are reserved.

2. Form agreed by the parties

Article 17 – If the parties have agreed that a contract which is not subject to a form under the law shall be made in a particular form, a contract not made in the agreed form does not bind the parties.

If the written form has been agreed without any further specification, the provisions concerning the statutory written form apply.

C. Acknowledgement of debt

Article 18 – An acknowledgement of debt is valid even if it does not state the cause of the debt.

D. Interpretation of contracts, simulated transactions

Article 19 – In determining the type and content of a contract and in interpreting it, the true and common intention of the parties shall be taken as the basis, irrespective of the words used by them by mistake or in order to conceal their true purpose.

The debtor may not raise against a third party who has acquired the receivable in reliance on a written acknowledgement of debt the defence that the transaction is simulated.

E. Standard terms and conditions

I. In general

Article 20 – Standard terms and conditions are the contractual terms which, when a contract is concluded, the drafting party has prepared in advance and unilaterally, for the purpose of using them in a large number of similar contracts in the future, and presents to the other party. Whether these terms are contained in the text of the contract or in an annex thereto, and their scope, type of script and form, are of no significance for their characterisation.

The fact that the texts of contracts drawn up for the same purpose are not identical does not prevent the terms contained in those contracts from being deemed standard terms and conditions.

Clauses, placed in the contract containing standard terms and conditions or in a separate contract, stating that each of these terms has been negotiated and accepted, do not by themselves cause them to cease to be standard terms and conditions.

The provisions concerning standard terms and conditions also apply, irrespective of their nature, to contracts prepared by persons and organisations carrying on the services they provide under a permission granted by law or by the competent authorities.

II. Inclusion

1. Deemed not written

Article 21 – The inclusion in the contract of standard terms and conditions that are contrary to the interests of the other party is subject to the drafting party, at the time of conclusion of the contract, expressly informing the other party of the existence of those terms and giving him or her the opportunity to learn their content, and to the other party accepting those terms. Otherwise, the standard terms and conditions shall be deemed not written.

Standard terms and conditions that are alien to the nature of the contract and to the nature of the transaction shall also be deemed not written.

2. Effect on the contract of terms being deemed not written

Article 22 – The provisions of the contract other than the standard terms and conditions deemed not written remain valid. In this case, the drafting party may not claim that he or she would not have concluded the contract with the other provisions had the terms deemed not written not existed.

III. Interpretation

Article 23 – If a provision contained in standard terms and conditions is not clear and comprehensible or is capable of more than one meaning, it shall be interpreted against the drafting party and in favour of the other party.

IV. Prohibition of amendment

Article 24 – Clauses contained in a contract containing standard terms and conditions or in a separate contract which give the drafting party the power to amend unilaterally, to the detriment of the other party, a provision of the contract containing standard terms and conditions, or to introduce a new arrangement, shall be deemed not written.

V. Control of content

Article 25 – Provisions which, contrary to the rules of good faith, are to the detriment of the other party or aggravate his or her position may not be included in standard terms and conditions.

F. Content of the contract

I. Freedom of contract

Article 26 – The parties may freely determine the content of a contract within the limits prescribed by law.

II. Absolute nullity

Article 27 – Contracts which are contrary to the mandatory provisions of the law, to morality, to public order or to personality rights, or the subject matter of which is impossible, are absolutely null and void.

The nullity of some of the provisions contained in the contract does not affect the validity of the others. However, if it is clearly apparent that the contract would not have been concluded without those provisions, the entire contract becomes absolutely null and void.

III. Exploitation (laesio enormis)

Article 28 – If there is a manifest disproportion between the mutual performances under a contract and this disproportion has been brought about by exploiting the distress, inexperience or thoughtlessness of the injured party, the injured party may, depending on the circumstances of the case, either notify the other party that he or she is not bound by the contract and demand the restitution of his or her performance, or remain bound by the contract and demand that the disproportion between the performances be eliminated.

The injured party may exercise this right within one year from the date on which he or she became aware of his or her thoughtlessness or inexperience or, in the case of distress, from the date on which that situation ceased, and in any event within five years from the date on which the contract was formed.

IV. Preliminary contract

Article 29 – Contracts concerning the future conclusion of a contract are valid.

Except for the exceptions provided for in the laws, the validity of the preliminary contract is subject to the form of the contract to be concluded in the future.

G. Defects of intent

I. Error

1. Effects of error

Article 30 – A party who has fallen into a fundamental error when the contract was formed is not bound by the contract.

2. Cases of error

a. Error in declaration

Article 31 – The following cases of error in particular are fundamental:

1. Where the party in error has declared his or her intent for a contract other than the one he or she wished to conclude.

2. Where the party in error has declared his or her intent in respect of a subject matter other than the one he or she wished.

3. Where the party in error has declared his or her intent to conclude a contract to a person other than the person with whom he or she actually wished to conclude the contract.

4. Where the party in error, although having taken into account, when concluding the contract, a person with particular qualities, has declared his or her intent in respect of another person.

5. Where the party in error has declared his or her intent for a performance considerably greater than that which he or she actually wished to undertake, or for a counter-performance considerably smaller than that which he or she actually wished.

Simple errors of calculation do not affect the validity of the contract; they shall merely be corrected.

b. Error in motive

Article 32 – An error in motive shall not be deemed a fundamental error. The error shall be deemed fundamental if the party in error regarded the motive in respect of which he or she was mistaken as a basis of the contract and this is consistent with the rules of good faith applicable in business dealings. However, this circumstance must also be recognisable by the other party.

c. Error in transmission

Article 33 – The provisions on error also apply where the intention directed at the formation of the contract has been incorrectly transmitted by an intermediary, such as a messenger or interpreter, or by a device.

3. Good faith in the case of error

Article 34 – The party in error may not invoke his or her error contrary to the rules of good faith.

In particular, where the other party declares that he or she consents to the contract being formed in the sense intended by the party in error, the contract shall be deemed to have been formed in that sense.

4. Fault in the case of error

Article 35 – If the party in error is at fault for his or her error, he or she is obliged to compensate the damage arising from the invalidity of the contract. However, no compensation may be claimed if the other party knew or ought to have known of the error.

Where equity so requires, the judge may award greater compensation, provided that it does not exceed the benefit expected from performance.

II. Fraud

Article 36 – If one of the parties has concluded a contract as a result of fraud by the other, he or she is not bound by the contract even if his or her error is not fundamental.

A party who has concluded a contract as a result of fraud by a third party is not bound by the contract if, at the time the contract was concluded, the other party knew or was in a position to know of the fraud.

III. Duress

1. Effect

Article 37 – If one of the parties has concluded a contract as a result of duress by the other party or by a third party, he or she is not bound by the contract.

If the duress was exercised by a third party and the other party neither knew nor was in a position to know of the duress, the party subjected to duress who does not wish to remain bound by the contract is obliged to pay compensation to the other party if equity so requires.

2. Conditions

Article 38 – Duress shall be deemed to exist if the party subjected to duress, in view of the circumstances in which he or she was placed, was justified in believing that a serious and imminent danger of damage had arisen to the personality rights or to the assets of himself or herself or of one of his or her relatives.

Where a contract has been concluded under threat of the exercise of a right or of a power arising from the law, duress shall be held to exist if the person who declared that he or she would exercise that right or power has obtained an excessive advantage from the distress of the other party.

IV. Remedying the defect of intent

Article 39 – A party who has concluded a contract by reason of error or fraud or as a result of duress shall be deemed to have ratified the contract if, within one year from the moment at which he or she became aware of the error or fraud or at which the effect of the duress ceased, he or she does not give notice that he or she is not bound by the contract or does not reclaim what he or she has given.

The deemed ratification of a contract which is not binding by reason of fraud or duress does not extinguish the right to compensation.

H. Representation

I. Authorised representation

1. In general

a. Effect of representation

Article 40 – The consequences of a legal transaction carried out by an authorised representative in the name and on behalf of another person bind the principal directly.

If the representative does not disclose this capacity when carrying out the legal transaction, the consequences of the legal transaction accrue to the representative himself or herself. However, if the other party infers or ought to infer the existence of a relationship of representation from the circumstances, or if it makes no difference to him or her whether the legal transaction is carried out with the representative or with the principal, the consequences of the legal transaction accrue directly to the principal.

In other cases, the provisions concerning the assignment of receivables or the assumption of debt apply.

b. Content and extent of the power of representation

Article 41 – Where representation in the name and on behalf of another person arises from public law, the content and extent of the power of representation shall be determined according to the statutory provisions on that matter; where the representation arises from a legal transaction, the content and extent of the power of representation shall be determined according to that legal transaction.

If the power of representation has been notified to third parties, the content and extent of the power of representation shall be determined according to that notification.

2. Authority arising from a legal transaction

a. Restriction and revocation of authority

Article 42 – The principal may at any time restrict or revoke a power of representation arising from a legal transaction. However, rights that may arise from legal relationships between the parties, such as employment, mandate or partnership contracts, are reserved.

The principal may not waive this right in advance.

If the principal has notified third parties, expressly or indirectly, of the authority he or she has granted, he or she may not invoke the revocation of the authority against third parties acting in good faith unless he or she has notified them that he or she has revoked that authority in whole or in part.

b. Death, incapacity and other circumstances

Article 43 – Unless otherwise agreed by the parties or apparent from the nature of the transaction, a power of representation arising from a legal transaction terminates upon the death of the principal or of the representative, a declaration of his or her absence, his or her loss of capacity to act, or his or her bankruptcy.

This provision also applies in the event of the termination of a legal entity.

The mutual personal rights of the parties are reserved.

c. Return of the instrument of authority

Article 44 – If the representative has been given an instrument of authority, upon the termination of the authority the representative is obliged to return that instrument to the principal or to deposit it at a place to be determined by the judge.

If the principal or his or her successors fail to do what is necessary to have the representative return the instrument, they are obliged to compensate the damage suffered by third parties acting in good faith as a result.

d. Inability to invoke the termination of authority

Article 45 – As long as the representative is unaware that his or her authority has terminated, the principal or his or her successors are bound by the consequences of the legal transactions carried out by the representative.

This rule does not apply in cases where the third parties know that the authority has terminated.

II. Unauthorised representation

1. In the case of ratification

Article 46 – If a person who has no authority carries out a legal transaction as a representative, that transaction binds the principal only if he or she ratifies it.

The other party with whom the unauthorised representative carried out the transaction may require the principal to declare, within a reasonable time, whether or not he or she ratifies the legal transaction. If the transaction is not ratified within that time, the other party is released from being bound by the transaction.

2. In the case of non-ratification

Article 47 – Where the principal, expressly or impliedly, does not ratify the legal transaction, compensation for the damage arising from the invalidity of that transaction may be claimed from the unauthorised representative. However, if the unauthorised representative proves that, at the time the transaction was carried out, the other party knew or ought to have known that he or she had no authority, no compensation for damage may be claimed from him or her.

If equity so requires, compensation for other damage may also be claimed from an unauthorised representative who is at fault.

Rights arising from unjust enrichment are reserved.

III. Reserved provisions

Article 48 – The provisions concerning the authority of the representatives and organs of partnerships and companies and of commercial representatives are reserved.

SECTION TWO

Obligations Arising from Tort

A. Liability

I. In general

Article 49 – A person who causes damage to another by a culpable and unlawful act is obliged to compensate that damage.

Even where there is no rule of law prohibiting the harmful act, a person who intentionally causes damage to another by an act contrary to morality is also obliged to compensate that damage.

II. Proof of damage and of fault

Article 50 – The injured party bears the burden of proving his or her damage and the fault of the person who caused the damage.

If the amount of the damage suffered cannot be proved precisely, the judge shall determine the amount of the damage equitably, taking into account the ordinary course of events and the measures taken by the injured party.

III. Compensation

1. Determination

Article 51 – The judge shall determine the extent of the compensation and the manner of its payment, taking into account the circumstances of the case and, in particular, the gravity of the fault.

If payment of the compensation in the form of an annuity is ordered, the debtor is obliged to provide security.

2. Reduction

Article 52 – If the injured party consented to the act causing the damage, or contributed to the occurrence or aggravation of the damage, or aggravated the position of the person liable for compensation, the judge may reduce the compensation or dispense with it entirely.

If the person liable for compensation who caused the damage through slight fault would fall into poverty upon paying the compensation, and equity also so requires, the judge may reduce the compensation.

IV. Special cases

1. Death and bodily injury

a. Death

Article 53 – The damage suffered in the event of death consists, in particular, of the following:

1. Funeral expenses.

2. If death did not occur immediately, the costs of medical treatment and the losses arising from the reduction or loss of the capacity to work.

3. The losses suffered by persons deprived of the support of the deceased as a result thereof.

b. Bodily injury

Article 54 – Damage resulting from bodily injury consists, in particular, of the following:

1. Costs of medical treatment.

2. Loss of earnings.

3. Losses arising from the reduction or loss of the capacity to work.

4. Losses arising from the impairment of economic prospects.

c. Determination

Article 55 – Damage for loss of support and damage resulting from bodily injury shall be calculated in accordance with the provisions of this Code and the principles of the law of liability. Social security payments which cannot be recovered by way of recourse in part or in full, and payments not made for the purpose of performance, may not be taken into account in the determination of such damage; they may not be deducted from the damage or the compensation. The compensation calculated may not be increased or reduced on considerations of equity on the basis of its amount.

The provisions of this Code also apply to claims and actions relating to damage connected with the partial or total loss of bodily integrity or with the death of a person caused by any kind of administrative acts and actions and by other causes for which the administration is liable.

(Added paragraph: 16/7/2026-7589/18 art.) In respect of losses arising from the reduction or loss of the capacity to work and losses suffered by persons deprived of the support of the deceased as a result thereof, statutory interest shall run on the total amount of compensation calculated for the period in which the earnings of the injured party or of the person providing support are known from the date on which the tort or the event causing the damage occurred; and on the total amount of compensation calculated for the period in which the earnings of the injured party or of the person providing support cannot be known, from the date of the decision.

(Added paragraph: 16/7/2026-7589/18 art.) For compensation relating to losses arising from the reduction or loss of the capacity to work and losses suffered by persons deprived of the support of the deceased as a result thereof, the amount paid for the purpose of performance before the commencement of the investigation shall be set off proportionally against the amount of compensation to be determined according to the date of payment.

d. Compensation for non-pecuniary damage

Article 56 – In the event of injury to a person’s bodily integrity, the judge may, taking into account the particular circumstances of the event, order the payment to the injured party of an appropriate sum of money as compensation for non-pecuniary damage.

In the event of serious bodily injury or death, the payment of an appropriate sum of money as compensation for non-pecuniary damage may also be ordered to the relatives of the injured party or of the deceased.

2. Unfair competition

Article 57 – A person whose customers have decreased, or who faces the danger of losing them, owing to the dissemination of untrue news or the making of such announcements or to other conduct contrary to the rules of good faith, may demand that such conduct be stopped and, if there is fault, that his or her damage be compensated.

The provisions of the Turkish Commercial Code concerning unfair competition relating to commercial transactions are reserved.

3. Infringement of personality rights

Article 58 – A person who suffers damage as a result of the infringement of his or her personality rights may demand the payment of a sum of money, under the name of compensation for non-pecuniary damage, for the non-pecuniary damage suffered.

The judge may order another form of redress in place of the payment of this compensation or in addition to it; in particular, the judge may render a decision condemning the attack and order the publication of that decision.

4. Temporary loss of the capacity of discernment

Article 59 – A person who temporarily loses the capacity of discernment is obliged to compensate the damage caused during that time. However, if he or she proves that he or she was not at fault in losing the capacity of discernment, he or she is released from liability.

V. Multiplicity of grounds of liability

1. Concurrence of grounds

Article 60 – If the liability of a person may be based on more than one ground, the judge shall decide on the basis of the ground of liability which provides the best possibility of redress to the injured party, unless the injured party has requested otherwise or the law provides otherwise.

2. Joint and several liability

a. In the external relationship

Article 61 – Where several persons have jointly caused damage, or are liable for the same damage on various grounds, the provisions concerning joint and several liability apply to them.

b. In the internal relationship

Article 62 – In the apportionment of the compensation among the jointly and severally liable debtors responsible for the same damage, all the facts and circumstances shall be taken into account, in particular the gravity of the fault attributable to each of them and the intensity of the danger they created.

A person who pays more than his or her share of the compensation has a right of recourse against the other jointly and severally liable persons for the excess paid and is subrogated to the rights of the injured party.

VI. Circumstances excluding unlawfulness

1. In general

Article 63 – An act based on an authority conferred by law and remaining within the limits of that authority shall not be deemed unlawful, even if it causes damage.

An act shall also not be deemed unlawful in cases of consent of the injured party, an overriding private or public interest, the conduct of the person causing the damage constituting legitimate self-defence, a person protecting his or her right by his or her own force where the intervention of the competent public authorities could not be obtained in time, or necessity.

2. Liability

Article 64 – A person acting in legitimate self-defence may not be held liable for the damage caused to the person or property of the attacker.

The judge shall determine, according to equity, the obligation to compensate of a person who causes damage to the property of another in order to protect himself or herself or another person from an obvious or imminent danger of damage.

A person compelled to protect his or her right by his or her own force may not be held liable for the damage caused if, in the circumstances, he or she could not obtain the assistance of the law enforcement forces in time and there was no other means of preventing the loss of the right or the substantial impediment of its exercise.

B. Strict liability

I. Liability based on equity

Article 65 – If equity so requires, the judge shall order that the damage caused by a person lacking the capacity of discernment be compensated in whole or in part.

II. Liability based on duty of care

1. Liability of the employer

Article 66 – The employer is obliged to compensate the damage caused to others by the employee in the course of performing the work assigned to him or her.

The employer is not liable if he or she proves that he or she exercised the care necessary to prevent the occurrence of the damage in selecting the employee, in giving instructions relating to the work, and in supervising and monitoring.

An employer in an enterprise is obliged to compensate the damage caused through the activities of that enterprise, unless he or she proves that the organisation of the work of the enterprise was suitable for preventing the occurrence of the damage.

The employer has a right of recourse against the employee who caused the damage for the compensation paid only to the extent that the employee is personally liable.

2. Liability of the keeper of an animal

a. Obligation to compensate

Article 67 – A person who permanently or temporarily undertakes the care and control of an animal is obliged to compensate the damage caused by the animal.

The keeper of the animal is not liable if he or she proves that he or she exercised the care necessary to prevent the occurrence of that damage.

If the animal was frightened by another person or by an animal belonging to another person, the right of recourse of the keeper of the animal against those persons is reserved.

b. Right of detention

Article 68 – If a person’s animal causes damage on the immovable property of another, the possessor of the immovable property may seize the animal and detain it until the damage has been compensated; indeed, if the circumstances justify it, he or she may render the animal harmless by other means.

In this case, the possessor of the immovable property is obliged to inform the owner of the animal immediately and, if he or she does not know the owner, to take the necessary steps to find him or her.

3. Liability of the owner of a structure

a. Obligation to compensate

Article 69 – The owner of a building or other structure is obliged to compensate the damage arising from defects in its construction or deficiencies in its maintenance.

Holders of a usufruct and of a right of habitation are also jointly and severally liable together with the owner for damage arising from deficiencies in the maintenance of the building.

The right of recourse of the liable persons against other persons who are liable to them on these grounds is reserved.

b. Prevention of the danger of damage

Article 70 – A person facing the danger of suffering damage from a building or other structure belonging to another may demand from the right holders that the measures necessary to eliminate that danger be taken.

The rules of public law concerning the protection of persons and property are reserved.

III. Liability for hazardous activities and equalisation

Article 71 – Where damage arises from the activity of an enterprise presenting a significant degree of danger, the owner of the enterprise and, if any, its operator are jointly and severally liable for that damage.

An enterprise shall be considered to be an enterprise presenting a significant degree of danger if it is concluded, having regard to its nature or to the materials, equipment or forces used in its activity, that it is capable of causing frequent or serious damage even if all the care expected of a person specialised in such work is exercised. In particular, if special liability for danger has been provided for in any law for enterprises presenting similar dangers, that enterprise shall also be deemed to be an enterprise presenting a significant degree of danger.

The provisions on special liability provided for a particular situation of danger are reserved.

Even if such activity of an enterprise presenting a significant degree of danger has been permitted by the legal order, the injured persons may demand that the damage caused by the activity of that enterprise be equalised by appropriate payment.

C. Statute of limitations

I. Rule

Article 72 – A claim for compensation becomes time-barred upon the expiry of two years from the date on which the injured party became aware of the damage and of the person liable for compensation, and in any event upon the expiry of ten years from the date on which the act was committed. However, if the compensation arises from an act punishable under criminal laws for which a longer limitation period is provided, that limitation period applies.

If an obligation has arisen for the injured party by reason of the tort, the injured party may at any time refuse to perform that obligation, even if the claim for compensation arising from the tort has become time-barred.

II. In the case of a claim for recourse

Article 73 – A claim for recourse becomes time-barred upon the expiry of two years from the date on which the compensation was paid in full and the jointly liable person became known, and in any event upon the expiry of ten years from the date on which the compensation was paid in full.

A person from whom payment of compensation is demanded is obliged to notify the persons jointly liable with him or her of the situation. Otherwise, the limitation period begins to run on the date on which such notification could have been made in accordance with the rules of good faith.

D. Proceedings

I. In relation to criminal law

Article 74 – In deciding whether the person causing the damage was at fault or whether he or she had the capacity of discernment, the judge is neither bound by the provisions of criminal law concerning liability nor bound by a decision of acquittal rendered by the criminal judge.

Likewise, a decision of the criminal judge concerning the assessment of fault and the determination of damage does not bind the civil judge.

II. Amendment of the judgment on compensation

Article 75 – If the extent of bodily injury cannot be determined precisely at the time of the decision, the judge may reserve the power to amend the judgment on compensation within two years from the date on which the decision becomes final.

III. Interim payments

Article 76 – If the injured party submits convincing evidence showing the justification of his or her claim and his or her economic situation also so requires, the judge may, upon request, order the defendant to make interim payments to the injured party.

Interim payments made by the defendant shall be set off against the compensation awarded; if no compensation is awarded, the judge shall order the plaintiff to return the interim payments received, together with statutory interest.

SECTION THREE

Obligations Arising from Unjust Enrichment

A. Conditions

I. In general

Article 77 – A person who, without just cause, has been enriched from the assets or labour of another is obliged to return that enrichment.

This obligation arises in particular where the enrichment is based on a cause which is not valid, which has not materialised or which has ceased to exist.

II. Performance of an undue obligation

Article 78 – A person who voluntarily performs an obligation which he or she did not owe may reclaim it only if he or she proves that he or she performed it in the belief that he or she was the debtor.

Enrichment resulting from the performance of a time-barred debt or from the fulfilment of a moral duty may not be reclaimed.

The other statutory provisions concerning the reclaiming of a performance rendered although no debt existed are reserved.

B. Extent of restitution

I. Obligation of the enriched person

Article 79 – A person who has been unjustly enriched is obliged to return the enrichment, except for the part which he or she proves was no longer in his or her possession at the time the restitution of the enrichment was demanded.

If the enriched person parted with the enrichment other than in good faith, or ought, at the time of parting with it, to have taken into account that he or she might be obliged to return it in the future, he or she is obliged to return the enrichment in full.

II. Right to claim expenses

Article 80 – If the enriched person is in good faith, he or she may claim the necessary and useful expenses incurred by him or her from the person claiming restitution.

If the enriched person is not in good faith, he or she may claim payment of the necessary expenses and, of the useful expenses, only of the increase in value existing at the time of restitution.

The enriched person, irrespective of whether he or she is in good faith, may not claim payment of other expenses. However, if no compensation is offered to him or her, he or she may, before returning the thing, separate and remove the additions which he or she has joined to the thing and which can be separated without damage.

C. Exclusion of restitution

Article 81 – Anything given for the purpose of bringing about an unlawful or immoral result may not be reclaimed. However, in an action brought, the judge may order that the thing be forfeited to the State.

D. Statute of limitations

Article 82 – The right of claim arising from unjust enrichment becomes time-barred upon the expiry of two years from the date on which the right holder became aware that he or she had a right to reclaim, and in any event upon the expiry of ten years from the date on which the enrichment occurred.

If the enrichment occurred through the enriched person acquiring a receivable, the other party may at any time refuse to perform that obligation, even if the right of claim has become time-barred.

CHAPTER TWO

Effects of Obligations

SECTION ONE

Performance of Obligations

A. In general

I. No requirement of personal performance

Article 83 – Unless the creditor has an interest in the obligation being performed by the debtor personally, the debtor is not obliged to perform the obligation in person.

II. Subject matter of performance

1. Partial performance

Article 84 – If the entire debt is ascertained and due, the creditor may refuse partial performance.

If the creditor accepts partial performance, the debtor may not refuse to perform the part of the debt which he or she has admitted.

2. Indivisible obligation

Article 85 – If an indivisible obligation has more than one creditor, each of the creditors may demand performance of the obligation to all the creditors. The debtor is obliged to render the performance to all the creditors together.

If an indivisible obligation has more than one debtor, each of the debtors is obliged to perform the entire obligation.

Unless otherwise apparent from the circumstances, the debtor who has performed is subrogated to the creditor and may claim his or her receivable from the other debtors in proportion to their shares.

3. Generic obligation

Article 86 – In generic obligations, unless otherwise apparent from the legal relationship and the nature of the transaction, the choice of the performance belongs to the debtor. However, the performance to be chosen by the debtor may not be of lower than average quality.

4. Alternative obligation

Article 87 – In alternative obligations, unless otherwise apparent from the legal relationship and the nature of the transaction, the choice of one of the performances belongs to the debtor.

5. Interest

Article 88 – If the annual rate of interest applicable to an obligation to pay interest has not been agreed in the contract, it shall be determined according to the provisions of the legislation in force on the date on which the interest debt arose.

The annual rate of interest to be agreed by contract may not exceed by more than fifty per cent the annual rate of interest determined pursuant to the first paragraph.

B. Place of performance

Article 89 – The place of performance of an obligation shall be determined according to the express or implied intentions of the parties. In the absence of an agreement to the contrary, the following provisions apply;

1. Pecuniary debts, at the domicile of the creditor at the time of payment,

2. Obligations concerning specific things, at the place where the subject matter of the obligation was located at the time the contract was formed,

3. All other obligations, at the domicile of the debtor at the time they arose,

shall be performed.

If performance of an obligation which is to be performed at the domicile of the creditor has become substantially more difficult because the creditor changed his or her domicile after the obligation arose, the obligation may be performed at the former domicile of the creditor.

C. Time of performance

I. Obligation not subject to a time limit

Article 90 – Unless the time of performance has been agreed by the parties or is apparent from the nature of the legal relationship, every obligation falls due at the moment it arises.

II. Obligation subject to a time limit

1. Due date for time limits expressed in months

Article 91 – If the beginning or the end of a month has been specified for the performance of an obligation, this shall be understood as the first or the last day of the month; if the middle of the month has been specified, this shall be understood as the fifteenth day of the month.

If only the month has been specified for the performance of an obligation without a day being stated, this shall be understood as the last day of that month.

2. Due date for other time limits

Article 92 – If an obligation, or any duty incumbent on one of the parties, is to be performed at the end of a specified period running from the formation of the contract, the time of performance shall be determined as follows:

1. A period specified in days expires on the last day of that period, the day on which the contract was formed not being counted. A period specified as eight or fifteen days, however, means not one or two weeks but a full eight or fifteen days.

2. A period specified in weeks expires on the day of the last week corresponding by name to the day on which the contract was formed.

3. A period specified in months, or as a period comprising several months such as a year, half a year or a quarter of a year, expires on the day of the last month corresponding in number to the day of the month on which the contract was formed. If there is no corresponding day in the last month, the period shall be deemed to expire on the last day of that month.

4. Half a month shall be understood as a period of fifteen days. The day on which a period specified as one or more months and a half month expires shall be determined by adding fifteen days to the last month.

These rules also apply where the period begins to run from a moment other than the formation of the contract.

The debtor is obliged to perform an obligation which is to be performed within a specified period before the expiry of that period.

3. Holidays

Article 93 – If the time of performance or the last day of the period falls on a day recognised as a holiday by law, it shall automatically be carried over to the first following day which is not a holiday.

An agreement to the contrary is valid.

III. Performance during business hours

Article 94 – The obligation shall be performed and accepted during customary business hours.

IV. Extension of the time limit

Article 95 – If a time limit has been extended, the new time limit, unless otherwise agreed, begins on the first day following the expiry of the previous time limit.

V. Early performance

Article 96 – Unless it is apparent from the terms or the nature of the contract or from the circumstances that the parties intended otherwise, the debtor may perform before the expiry of the time limit. However, unless required by law, by the contract or by custom, the debtor may not make a deduction by reason of having performed early.

VI. In contracts imposing reciprocal obligations

1. Order of performance

Article 97 – A party demanding performance of a contract imposing reciprocal obligations must have performed his or her own obligation or have offered to perform it, unless, under the terms and nature of the contract, he or she is entitled to perform later.

2. Inability to perform

Article 98 – In a contract imposing reciprocal obligations, if the right of the other party is endangered because one of the parties has become unable to perform his or her obligation, and in particular because he or she has become bankrupt or an attachment against him or her has proved fruitless, that other party may refuse to perform his or her own performance until the counter-performance has been secured.

The party whose right is endangered may also withdraw from the contract if the security requested is not provided within a reasonable time.

D. Payment

I. In the national currency

Article 99 – A debt the subject matter of which is money shall be paid in the national currency.

If payment in a currency other than the national currency has been agreed, the debt may also be paid in the national currency at the exchange rate on the day of payment, unless the contract contains a stipulation for payment in specie or an expression to that effect.

Where the debt is expressed in a currency other than the national currency and the contract does not contain a stipulation for payment in specie or an expression to that effect, if the debt is not paid on the day of payment, the creditor may demand that the receivable be paid in specie or in the national currency at the exchange rate on the due date or on the day of actual payment.

II. Imputation

1. In the case of partial payment

Article 100 – If the debtor is not in arrears in paying interest or costs, he or she has the right to deduct a partial payment made by him or her from the principal debt. No agreement to the contrary may be made.

If the creditor has obtained suretyship, a pledge or other security for part of the receivable, the debtor does not have the right to impute a partial payment made by him or her to the secured part or to the better secured part.

2. In the case of several debts

a. According to the declaration of the debtor and of the creditor

Article 101 – A debtor who has several debts may, on the day of payment, notify the creditor which of these debts he or she wishes to pay.

If the debtor makes no such notification, the payment made shall be deemed to have been made for the debt indicated by the creditor in the receipt, unless the debtor immediately objects.

b. According to the law

Article 102 – Where no legally valid declaration has been made or the receipt contains no indication, the payment shall be deemed to have been made for the debt that is due. If several debts are due, the payment shall be deemed to have been made for the debt for which the debtor was first subjected to enforcement proceedings. If no enforcement proceedings have been brought, the payment shall be imputed to the debt which fell due first.

If several debts fell due at the same time, imputation shall be made proportionally; if none of the debts has fallen due, the payment shall be deemed to have been made for the debt with the least security.

III. Receipt and return of instruments

1. Right of the debtor

Article 103 – A debtor who pays the debt may demand a receipt and, if the debt has been paid in full, the return or cancellation of the instrument of debt relating to it.

If the debt has not been paid in full, or if the instrument of debt also confers other rights on the creditor, the debtor may only demand that a receipt be issued and that the payment be recorded on the instrument of debt.

2. Effects

Article 104 – If the creditor has issued a receipt without reservation for one of a series of periodic performances, such as interest or rent, the performances for the preceding periods shall also be deemed to have been performed.

If the creditor has issued a receipt for the entire principal, he or she shall be presumed also to have received the interest thereon.

If the instrument of debt has been returned to the debtor, the debt shall be deemed extinguished.

3. Inability to return the instrument

Article 105 – If the creditor claims to have lost the instrument of debt, he or she is obliged, upon the request of the debtor and at the time of payment of the debt, to give the debtor an officially drawn up or duly certified document showing the cancellation of the instrument of debt and the extinction of the debt.

The provisions concerning the cancellation of negotiable instruments are reserved.

E. Default of the creditor

I. Conditions

Article 106 – A creditor to whom a performance consisting of doing or giving has been duly offered is in default if, without just cause, he or she refuses to accept it or to carry out the preparatory acts incumbent on him or her to enable the debtor to perform the obligation.

If the creditor is in default vis-à-vis one of the joint and several debtors, he or she is also in default vis-à-vis the others.

II. Effects

1. In performances concerning the delivery of a thing

a. Right of deposit

Article 107 – In the event of the creditor’s default, the debtor may release himself or herself from the obligation by depositing the thing to be delivered, at the risk and expense of the creditor.

The place of deposit shall be determined by the judge at the place of performance. Nevertheless, commercial goods may also be deposited in a warehouse without a decision of the judge.

b. Right of sale

Article 108 – If the nature of the thing which is the subject matter of the contract or the nature of the transaction does not lend itself to deposit, or if the thing to be delivered is perishable or its upkeep, preservation or deposit requires considerable expense, the debtor may, with the permission of the judge and provided that he or she has given prior warning to the creditor, have it sold by public auction and deposit the proceeds.

If the thing to be delivered is quoted on an exchange or has a market price, or if its value is small in relation to the expenses to be incurred, not only is it not mandatory that the sale be made by public auction, but the judge may also authorise the sale without requiring the condition of prior warning.

c. Taking back the deposited thing

Article 109 – Unless the creditor has declared that he or she accepts the deposited thing or the deposit has resulted in the extinction of a pledge, the debtor may take back the deposited thing.

At the moment the deposited thing is taken back, the receivable continues to exist together with all its ancillary rights.

2. In other performances

Article 110 – If the subject matter of the obligation does not require the delivery of a thing, the debtor may, in the event of the creditor’s default, withdraw from the contract in accordance with the provisions concerning the default of the debtor.

F. Other impediments to performance

Article 111 – If, without fault on the part of the debtor, the obligation cannot be performed to the creditor or to his or her representative owing to uncertainty as to whom the receivable belongs or as to the identity of the creditor, or owing to another personal reason originating from the creditor, the debtor may exercise the right of deposit or of withdrawal from the contract as in the case of the creditor’s default.

SECTION TWO

Consequences of Non-Performance of Obligations

A. Non-performance of the obligation

I. Obligation to compensate

1. In general

Article 112 – If the obligation is not performed at all or is not duly performed, the debtor is obliged to compensate the creditor for the damage resulting therefrom, unless he or she proves that no fault whatsoever is attributable to him or her.

2. In obligations to do and not to do

Article 113 – If an obligation to do is not performed by the debtor, the creditor may request authorisation to have the performance carried out by himself or herself or by another person at the expense of the debtor; the right to claim compensation of any kind is reserved.

A debtor who acts in breach of an obligation not to do is obliged to compensate the damage caused by such breach.

The creditor may also demand that the situation contrary to the obligation be removed, or that he or she be authorised to remove it at the expense of the debtor.

II. Extent of liability and of the obligation to compensate

1. In general

Article 114 – The debtor is, in general, liable for any fault. The extent of the debtor’s liability shall be determined according to the particular nature of the transaction. In particular, if the transaction confers no benefit on the debtor, liability shall be assessed more leniently.

The provisions concerning liability in tort also apply by analogy to cases of breach of contract.

2. Exclusion of liability agreement

Article 115 – An agreement made in advance that the debtor shall not be liable for gross fault is absolutely null and void.

Any agreement made in advance by the debtor with the creditor that the debtor shall not be liable for any obligation arising from an employment contract is absolutely null and void.

If a service, profession or trade requiring expertise may be carried on only with a permission granted by law or by the competent authorities, an agreement made in advance that the debtor shall not be liable for slight fault is absolutely null and void.

3. Liability for the acts of auxiliary persons

Article 116 – Even if the debtor has lawfully entrusted the performance of an obligation or the exercise of a right arising from an obligation to auxiliaries, such as persons living with him or her or his or her employees, he or she is obliged to compensate the damage caused by them to the other party in the course of carrying out the work.

Liability arising from the acts of auxiliary persons may be excluded in whole or in part by an agreement made in advance.

If a service, profession or trade requiring expertise may be carried on only with a permission granted by law or by the competent authorities, an agreement that the debtor shall not be liable for the acts of auxiliary persons is absolutely null and void.

B. Default of the debtor

I. Conditions

Article 117 – The debtor of an obligation that has fallen due is put in default by the creditor’s notice.

If the day on which the obligation is to be performed has been determined jointly, or has been determined by one of the parties by means of a duly given notice on the basis of a right reserved in the contract, the debtor is in default upon the expiry of that day; in the case of a tort, on the date on which the act was committed, and in the case of unjust enrichment, on the date on which the enrichment occurred. However, where the enriched person is in good faith, notice is required for default.

II. Effects

1. In general

a. Compensation for delay

Article 118 – A debtor in default is obliged to compensate the damage suffered by the creditor as a result of the late performance of the obligation, unless he or she proves that he or she was not at fault in falling into default.

b. Liability for chance events

Article 119 – A debtor in default is liable for the damage arising from a chance event.

The debtor may be released from this liability by proving that he or she was not at fault in falling into default, or that the chance event would have damaged the thing which is the subject matter of performance even if he or she had performed the obligation in time.

2. Default interest

a. In general

Article 120 – If the annual rate of default interest to be applied has not been agreed in the contract, it shall be determined according to the provisions of the legislation in force on the date on which the interest debt arose.

The annual rate of default interest to be agreed by contract may not exceed by more than one hundred per cent the annual rate of interest determined pursuant to the first paragraph.

If a contractual rate of interest has been agreed but no default interest has been agreed in the contract, and the annual contractual rate of interest is higher than the rate of interest specified in the first paragraph, the contractual rate of interest shall apply as the rate of default interest.

b. Default interest on interest, annuities and gifts

Article 121 – A debtor who is in default in paying a debt of interest or of an annuity, or a sum of money which he or she has promised as a gift, is obliged to pay default interest from the day on which enforcement proceedings are initiated or an action is brought.

Agreements made to the contrary are subject to the provisions on penalty clauses.

Default interest may not be charged on default interest.

3. Damage exceeding default interest

Article 122 – If the creditor has suffered damage exceeding the default interest, the debtor is also obliged to compensate that damage, unless he or she proves that he or she bears no fault whatsoever.

If the amount of the damage exceeding the default interest can be determined in the pending action, the judge shall, upon the request of the plaintiff, also award the amount of that damage when deciding on the merits.

4. In contracts imposing reciprocal obligations

a. Granting of a time limit

Article 123 – In contracts imposing reciprocal obligations, if one of the parties is in default, the other party may grant a reasonable time limit for the performance of the obligation or request the judge to grant a reasonable time limit.

b. Cases in which no time limit need be granted

Article 124 – It is not necessary to grant a time limit in the following cases:

1. If it is apparent from the situation or the conduct of the debtor that granting a time limit would be ineffective.

2. If, as a result of the debtor’s default, performance of the obligation has become useless to the creditor.

3. If it is apparent from the contract that performance will no longer be accepted if the obligation is not performed at a specified time or within a specified period.

c. Optional rights

Article 125 – If the debtor in default has not performed the obligation within the time limit granted, or if a case arises in which no time limit need be granted, the creditor always has the right to demand performance of the obligation and compensation for the delay.

The creditor may, in addition, by declaring immediately that he or she waives the right to demand performance of the obligation and compensation for delay, demand compensation for the damage arising from the non-performance of the obligation or withdraw from the contract.

In the event of withdrawal from the contract, the parties are mutually released from the obligation to perform and may reclaim the performances already rendered by them. In this case, if the debtor cannot prove that he or she was not at fault in falling into default, the creditor may also demand compensation for the damage suffered as a result of the contract becoming ineffective.

d. In contracts involving continuing performance

Article 126 – In contracts involving continuing performance the performance of which has begun, in the event of the debtor’s default, the creditor may demand performance and compensation for delay, or may terminate the contract and demand compensation for the damage suffered as a result of the early termination of the contract.

SECTION THREE

Effects of Obligations on Third Parties

A. Subrogation to the creditor

Article 127 – A third party who renders performance to the creditor is subrogated to the rights of the creditor to the extent of his or her performance in the following cases:

1. Where he or she redeems from the pledge a thing pledged for the debt of another and has ownership or another right in rem in that thing.

2. Where the debtor has notified the creditor before performance that the third party rendering performance to the creditor shall be subrogated to the creditor.

The statutory provisions concerning other cases of subrogation are reserved.

B. Undertaking for the act of a third party

Article 128 – A person who undertakes towards another for the act of a third party is obliged to compensate the damage resulting from the failure of that act to take place.

In an undertaking given for a specified period, it may be agreed that the liability of the person giving the undertaking shall terminate if no written application is made to him or her to render the performance before the expiry of the period.

C. Contract for the benefit of a third party

I. In general

Article 129 – A person who concludes a contract in his or her own name and has stipulated in the contract an obligation of performance for the benefit of a third party may demand that the performance be rendered to the third party.

The third party or his or her successors may also demand performance if this is consistent with the intention of the parties or with custom and usage. In this case, once the third party or his or her successors have notified the debtor that they wish to exercise this right, the creditor may neither release the debtor nor alter the nature and extent of the obligation.

II. In liability insurance

Article 130 – If a person who employs another has taken out insurance to secure his or her civil liability towards the person employed, the rights arising from the insurance belong directly to the employee.

However, the insurance indemnity to be paid to the employee shall be deducted from the compensation payable under the general provisions.

The statutory provisions concerning other civil liability insurance are reserved.

CHAPTER THREE

Extinction of Debts and Obligations; Statute of Limitations

SECTION ONE

Grounds of Extinction

A. Extinction of rights and obligations accessory to the principal debt

Article 131 – Where the principal debt is extinguished by performance or on any other ground, the rights and obligations accessory to it, such as pledge, suretyship, interest and penalty clause, shall also be extinguished.

Where the right to claim performance of accrued interest and of the penalty clause has been reserved by contract or by a notice given up to the time of performance, or where it appears from the circumstances and conditions that it has been reserved, such interest and penalty clause may be claimed.

The special provisions relating to mortgages on immovables, negotiable instruments and composition with creditors are reserved.

B. Release

Article 132 – Even where the transaction giving rise to the debt is subject to a particular form by law or by the parties, the debt may be extinguished wholly or partly by a release agreement concluded by the parties without being subject to any form.

C. Novation

I. In general

Article 133 – The extinction of an existing debt by means of a new debt shall take place only by the express intention of the parties to that effect.

In particular, the undertaking of a bill-of-exchange obligation for an existing debt, or the issuance of a new instrument of debt or a new instrument of suretyship, shall not be deemed novation unless the parties have an express intention of novation.

II. In current accounts

Article 134 – The mere entry of various items in a current account does not mean that the debt has been novated.

However, where the account has been closed and the balance of the account has been accepted by the other party, the debt shall be novated.

Where one of the items is secured, unless otherwise agreed, the closing of the account and the acceptance of the balance shall not extinguish the security.

D. Merger

Article 135 – The debt shall be extinguished by the merger of the capacities of creditor and debtor in the same person. However, the rights of third parties previously existing over the receivable shall not be affected by the merger.

If the merger is set aside with retroactive effect, the debt shall continue to exist.

The special provisions relating to mortgages on immovables and negotiable instruments are reserved.

E. Impossibility of performance

I. In general

Article 136 – Where the performance of the debt becomes impossible for reasons for which the debtor cannot be held responsible, the debt shall be extinguished.

In contracts imposing reciprocal obligations, the debtor released from the debt by reason of impossibility shall be obliged to return the performance he or she has received from the other party in accordance with the provisions on unjust enrichment, and shall lose the right to claim the performance not yet rendered to him or her. Cases in which the risk arising before the performance of the debt has been placed on the creditor by law or by contract are excluded from this provision.

Where the debtor does not notify the creditor without delay that performance has become impossible and does not take the necessary measures to prevent the damage from increasing, he or she shall be obliged to compensate the resulting damage.

II. Partial impossibility of performance

Article 137 – Where the performance of the debt becomes partly impossible for reasons for which the debtor cannot be held responsible, the debtor shall be released only from the part of the debt that has become impossible. However, if it is clearly understood that the parties would not have concluded such a contract had this partial impossibility of performance been foreseen in advance, the debt shall be extinguished in its entirety.

In contracts imposing reciprocal obligations, where the debt of one party becomes partly impossible and the creditor consents to partial performance, the counter-performance shall also be rendered in that proportion. Where the creditor does not consent to such performance or the counter-performance is of an indivisible nature, the provisions on total impossibility shall apply.

III. Excessive difficulty of performance

Article 138 – Where an extraordinary situation, which was not foreseen by the parties at the time the contract was concluded and could not be expected to be foreseen, arises for a reason not attributable to the debtor and changes the facts existing at the time the contract was concluded to the detriment of the debtor to such an extent that demanding performance from him or her would be contrary to the rules of good faith, and the debtor has either not yet performed his or her debt or has performed it while reserving his or her rights arising from the excessive difficulty of performance, the debtor shall have the right to request the judge to adapt the contract to the new conditions and, where this is not possible, to withdraw from the contract. In contracts involving continuing performance, the debtor shall, as a rule, exercise the right of termination instead of the right of withdrawal.

The provision of this Article shall also apply to debts in foreign currency.

F. Set-off

I. Conditions

1. In general

Article 139 – Where two persons mutually owe each other a sum of money or other performances of the same kind, each of them may set off his or her receivable against his or her debt, provided that both debts are due.

Set-off may be asserted even if one of the receivables is disputed.

Set-off of a time-barred receivable may be asserted only on condition that it had not yet become time-barred at the time when it could have been set off.

2. In the case of suretyship

Article 140 – As long as the principal debtor has the right to assert set-off, the surety may also refuse to render performance to the creditor.

3. In the case of a contract for the benefit of a third party

Article 141 – A person who has undertaken an obligation for the benefit of a third party may not set off this debt against his or her receivable from the other party to the contract.

4. In the case of the debtor’s bankruptcy

Article 142 – In the event of the debtor’s bankruptcy, the creditors may set off their receivables, even if they are not due, against their debts owed to the bankrupt.

II. Effects

Article 143 – Set-off takes effect only upon the debtor notifying the creditor of his or her intention to set off. In that case, both debts shall be extinguished, as from the time at which they could have been set off, to the extent of the smaller debt.

The special commercial usages relating to current accounts are reserved.

III. Receivables that may be set off with the consent of the creditor

Article 144 – The following receivables may be set off after the rights of set-off have arisen, but only with the consent of their creditors:

1. Receivables relating to the return of deposited property or to its value.

2. Receivables relating to the return of property wrongfully taken or retained by deception, or to its value.

3. Receivables, such as maintenance and wages of employees, which are indispensable for the support of the debtor and his or her family and which, by their special nature, must be paid directly to the creditor.

IV. Waiver of set-off

Article 145 – The debtor may waive the right of set-off even in advance.

SECTION TWO

Statute of Limitations

A. Periods

I. Ten-year statute of limitations

Article 146 – Unless otherwise provided by law, every receivable shall be subject to a ten-year statute of limitations.

II. Five-year statute of limitations

Article 147 – A five-year statute of limitations shall apply to the following receivables:

1. Rents, interest on capital and other periodic performances such as wages.

2. Charges for accommodation in places such as hotels, motels, guesthouses and holiday villages, and charges for food and drink in restaurants and similar places.

3. Receivables arising from small craft work and small-scale retail sales.

4. Receivables arising from the partnership contract in a partnership, between the partners themselves or between them and the partnership; and receivables between the managers, representatives or auditors of a partnership and the partnership or the partners.

5. Receivables arising from contracts of mandate, commission and agency, and from brokerage contracts, with the exception of receivables for commercial brokerage fees.

6. Receivables arising from a contract for work, except where the contractor has failed, through his or her gross fault, to perform his or her obligations at all or properly.

III. Mandatory nature of the periods

Article 148 – The limitation periods determined in this Section may not be altered by contract.

IV. Commencement of the statute of limitations

1. In general

Article 149 – The limitation period shall begin to run when the receivable becomes due.

In cases where the receivable becoming due depends on a notice, the limitation period shall begin to run from the day on which such notice could have been given.

2. In periodic performances

Article 150 – In the case of life annuities and similar periodic performances, the limitation period for the receivable as a whole shall begin to run on the day on which the first unperformed periodic performance became due.

Where the receivable as a whole has become time-barred, the unperformed periodic performances shall also be time-barred.

V. Calculation of the periods

Article 151 – In calculating the periods, the day on which the limitation period begins shall not be counted, and the limitation shall be completed only when the last day of the period has also elapsed without the right having been exercised.

The provisions on the calculation of time limits in the performance of debts shall also apply in calculating limitation periods.

B. Limitation of accessory receivables

Article 152 – When the principal receivable becomes time-barred, the interest and other receivables accessory to it shall also become time-barred.

C. Suspension of the statute of limitations

Article 153 – In the following cases the limitation period shall not begin to run, and if it has begun, it shall be suspended:

1. For receivables of children against their mothers and fathers, during the period of parental custody.

2. For receivables of persons under guardianship against the guardian or against the State by reason of guardianship transactions, during the period of guardianship.

3. For receivables of spouses against each other, for as long as the marriage continues.

4. For receivables of domestic employees against their employers, during the period of the employment relationship.

5. For as long as the debtor holds a usufruct over the receivable.

6. For as long as there is no possibility of asserting the receivable before the Turkish courts.

7. Where the capacities of creditor and debtor have merged in the same person, in the event that the merger is subsequently set aside with retroactive effect, for the period elapsing until this situation arises.

The limitation period shall begin to run, or shall continue to run if it had begun before the suspension, at the end of the day on which the grounds suspending the limitation cease to exist.

D. Interruption of the statute of limitations

I. Grounds

Article 154 – The limitation period shall be interrupted in the following cases:

1. Where the debtor has acknowledged the debt, in particular where he or she has paid interest or made partial performance, or has given a pledge or provided a surety.

2. Where the creditor has applied to a court or to an arbitrator by way of an action or a defence, has initiated enforcement proceedings or has applied to the bankruptcy estate.

II. Effect on co-debtors

Article 155 – When the limitation period is interrupted against one of the joint and several debtors or one of the debtors of an indivisible debt, it shall also be interrupted against the others.

When the limitation period is interrupted against the principal debtor, it shall also be interrupted against the surety.

When the limitation period is interrupted against the surety, it shall not be interrupted against the principal debtor.

III. Commencement of a new period

1. In the case of acknowledgement of the debt or its determination by a decision

Article 156 – Upon interruption of the limitation period, a new period shall begin to run.

Where the debt has been acknowledged by an instrument or determined by a decision of a court or an arbitrator, the new period shall always be ten years.

2. In the case of an act of the creditor

Article 157 – A limitation period interrupted by way of an action or a defence shall, during the proceedings, begin to run anew after every procedural act of the parties or every decision of the judge.

Where the limitation period has been interrupted by enforcement proceedings, it shall begin to run anew after every act relating to the enforcement of the receivable.

Where the limitation period has been interrupted by reason of an application to the bankruptcy estate, it shall begin to run anew from the time at which the possibility of claiming the receivable again arises under the provisions on bankruptcy.

E. Additional period upon dismissal of the action

Article 158 – Where an action or a defence has been dismissed because the court lacked territorial or subject-matter jurisdiction, or because of a correctable error, or because it was brought prematurely, and the limitation period or the period of preclusion has expired in the meantime, the creditor may exercise his or her rights within an additional period of sixty days.

F. In the case of a receivable secured by a pledge of movables

Article 159 – The fact that a receivable is secured by a pledge of movables shall not prevent the limitation period from running for that receivable; however, the creditor’s power to obtain satisfaction of his or her right from the pledge shall continue.

G. Waiver of the statute of limitations

Article 160 – The statute of limitations may not be waived in advance.

A waiver by one of the joint and several debtors may not be asserted against the others.

The same rule shall apply where one of the debtors of an indivisible debt has waived.

A waiver by the principal debtor may not be asserted against the surety either.

H. Assertion

Article 161 – Unless the statute of limitations is asserted, the judge may not take it into consideration of his or her own motion.

CHAPTER FOUR

Special Situations in Obligations

SECTION ONE

Joint and Several Liability

A. Joint and several debt

I. Creation

Article 162 – Where each of several debtors declares that he or she accepts liability towards the creditor for the entire debt, joint and several debt arises.

In the absence of such a declaration, joint and several debt arises only in the cases provided for by law.

II. External relationship

1. Effects

a. Liability of the debtors

Article 163 – The creditor may, at his or her discretion, demand performance of the whole or part of the debt from all of the debtors or from only one of them.

The liability of the debtors shall continue until the entire debt has been paid.

b. Defences of the debtors

Article 164 – One of the joint and several debtors may assert against the creditor only those defences and objections arising from the personal relations between the creditor and himself or herself, or from the cause or subject matter of the joint and several debt.

Where one of the joint and several debtors fails to assert the common defences and objections, he or she shall be liable towards the others.

c. Individual conduct of the debtors

Article 165 – Unless otherwise determined by law or by contract, one of the debtors may not, by his or her own conduct, aggravate the position of the other debtors.

2. Extinction of the debt

Article 166 – Where one of the debtors has extinguished the whole or part of the debt by performance or set-off, he or she shall also have released the other debtors from the debt to that extent.

Where one of the debtors has been released from the debt without rendering performance to the creditor, the other debtors may benefit from this only to the extent permitted by the circumstances or the nature of the debt.

A release agreement concluded by the creditor with one of the debtors shall also release the other debtors from the debt in proportion to the share of the released debtor in the debt in the internal relationship.

III. Internal relationship

1. Apportionment

Article 167 – Unless otherwise agreed or unless otherwise apparent from the nature of the legal relationship between the debtors, each of the debtors shall be liable towards one another in equal shares for the performance rendered to the creditor.

A debtor who has rendered performance in excess of his or her share shall have the right to claim the excess amount paid from the other debtors. In this case, the debtor may have recourse against each debtor only in proportion to that debtor’s share.

The other debtors shall be obliged to assume in equal shares any amount that cannot be recovered from one of the debtors.

2. Subrogation to the rights of the creditor

Article 168 – Each of the debtors having a right of recourse against the others shall be subrogated to the rights of the creditor in proportion to the amount he or she has performed.

Where the creditor improves the position of one of the debtors to the detriment of the others, he or she shall bear the consequences thereof.

B. Joint and several creditorship

Article 169 – Joint and several creditorship arises where the debtor grants each of the creditors the right to claim the entire debt, or in the cases determined by law.

By rendering performance to one of the creditors, the debtor shall be released from his or her debt towards all the creditors.

Unless he or she has been notified that one of the creditors has applied for enforcement or to a court, the debtor may render performance to whichever of them he or she chooses.

Unless otherwise agreed or unless otherwise apparent from the nature of the legal relationship between the creditors, each of the creditors shall have equal rights in the performance.

A creditor who has obtained more than his or her share shall be obliged to pay the excess to the other creditors who have not received their shares.

SECTION TWO

Conditions

A. Condition precedent

I. In general

Article 170 – Where the effectiveness of a contract has been made dependent on a fact of which it is not known whether it will occur or not, the contract is subject to a condition precedent.

Unless otherwise agreed, a contract subject to a condition precedent shall take effect only from the moment at which the condition is fulfilled.

II. Situation while the condition is pending

Article 171 – Until the condition is fulfilled, the debtor shall be obliged to refrain from any conduct that would prevent the proper performance of the debt.

A creditor whose conditional right is endangered may take the measures that creditors whose receivables are not subject to a condition may resort to in order to protect their rights.

Dispositions made before the fulfilment of the condition shall be invalid to the extent that they impair the effects of the condition.

III. Benefits obtained until the condition is fulfilled

Article 172 – A creditor to whom the thing forming the subject matter of the debt has been delivered before the fulfilment of the condition shall, if the condition is fulfilled, become the owner of the benefits he or she has obtained until the fulfilment of the condition.

If the condition is not fulfilled, the creditor shall be obliged to return the benefits he or she has obtained.

B. Condition subsequent

Article 173 – A contract whose termination has been made dependent on a fact of which it is not known in advance whether it will occur or not is subject to a condition subsequent.

The effects of a contract subject to a condition subsequent shall cease at the moment the condition is fulfilled.

Unless otherwise agreed or unless otherwise apparent from the nature of the matter, the termination shall not have retroactive effect.

C. Common provisions

I. Fulfilment of the condition

Article 174 – Where the condition is not an act that must be performed personally by one of the parties, in the event of that party’s death his or her heir may take his or her place.

II. Prevention contrary to the rules of good faith

Article 175 – Where one of the parties prevents the fulfilment of the condition contrary to the rules of good faith, the condition shall be deemed to have been fulfilled.

Where one of the parties brings about the fulfilment of the condition contrary to the rules of good faith, the condition shall be deemed not to have been fulfilled.

III. Prohibited conditions

Article 176 – Where a condition has been stipulated for the purpose of bringing about an act or omission contrary to law or morality, the legal transaction subject to that condition shall be absolutely null and void.

SECTION THREE

Earnest Money, Forfeit Money and Penalty Clause

A. Earnest money

Article 177 – A sum of money given by a person upon the conclusion of a contract shall be deemed to have been given not as forfeit money but as proof that the contract has been concluded.

Unless otherwise provided by contract or local custom, the earnest money shall be deducted from the principal receivable.

B. Forfeit money

Article 178 – Where forfeit money has been agreed, each of the parties shall be deemed entitled to withdraw from the contract; in that case, if the party who gave the money withdraws, he or she shall forfeit what he or she gave; if the party who received it withdraws, he or she shall return twice what he or she received.

C. Penalty clause

I. Rights of the creditor

1. Relationship between the penalty and performance of the contract

Article 179 – Where a penalty has been agreed for the case of non-performance or improper performance of a contract, the creditor may, unless otherwise apparent from the contract, demand either performance of the debt or payment of the penalty.

Where the penalty has been agreed for the case of the debt not being performed at the specified time or place, the creditor may demand payment of the penalty together with the principal debt, unless he or she has expressly waived this right or has accepted performance without reservation.

The debtor’s right to prove that he or she is entitled to bring the contract to an end by withdrawal or termination by paying the agreed penalty is reserved.

2. Relationship between the penalty and damage

Article 180 – The agreed penalty shall be payable even if the creditor has not suffered any damage.

Where the damage suffered by the creditor exceeds the amount of the agreed penalty, the creditor may not claim the excess amount unless he or she proves that the debtor is at fault.

3. Forfeiture of partial performance

Article 181 – The provisions on penalty clauses shall also apply to contracts providing that, in the event of withdrawal, the part already performed shall remain with the creditor.

The provisions on instalment sales are reserved.

II. Amount, invalidity and reduction of the penalty

Article 182 – The parties may freely determine the amount of the penalty.

Where the principal debt is invalid for any reason or, unless otherwise agreed, has subsequently become impossible for a reason for which the debtor cannot be held responsible, payment of the penalty may not be demanded. The invalidity of the penalty clause, or its subsequently becoming impossible for a reason for which the debtor cannot be held responsible, shall not affect the validity of the principal debt.

The judge shall, of his or her own motion, reduce a penalty clause that he or she considers excessive.

CHAPTER FIVE

Changes of Parties in Obligations

SECTION ONE

Assignment of Receivables

A. Conditions

I. Voluntary assignment

1. In general

Article 183 – Unless prevented by law, contract or the nature of the matter, the creditor may assign his or her receivable to a third party without seeking the consent of the debtor.

The debtor may not assert, against a third party who has acquired the receivable in reliance on a written acknowledgement of debt containing no prohibition of assignment, the defence that it had been agreed that the receivable could not be assigned.

2. Form

Article 184 – The validity of the assignment of a receivable shall depend on its being made in writing.

A promise to assign a receivable is not subject to any form.

II. Statutory or judicial assignment and its effect

Article 185 – Where the assignment of a receivable has taken place by virtue of law or of a court decision, such assignment may be asserted against third parties without any special form and without the need for the previous creditor to declare his or her consent.

B. Effects of the assignment

I. Position of the debtor

1. Performance made in good faith

Article 186 – Where the debtor has not been notified of the assignment of the receivable by the assignor or the assignee, he or she shall be released from his or her debt by rendering performance in good faith to the previous creditor or, where the receivable has been assigned several times, to one of the previous assignees instead of the last assignee.

2. Refusal of performance and deposit

Article 187 – The debtor of a receivable whose ownership is disputed may refuse performance and shall be released from the debt by depositing the subject matter of the receivable at the place determined by the judge.

Where the debtor renders performance despite knowing that the receivable is disputed, he or she shall be liable for the resulting consequences.

Where the dispute that is the subject of an action has not yet been decided by the court and the debt is due, each of the parties may compel the debtor to deposit the performance.

3. Defences of the debtor

Article 188 – The debtor may assert against the assignee the defences he or she had against the assignor at the time he or she learnt of the assignment.

The debtor may set off against his or her debt a receivable of his or her own that was not yet due at the time he or she learnt of the assignment, on condition that it becomes due before or at the same time as the assigned receivable.

II. Transfer of preferential rights and accessory rights

Article 189 – Upon the assignment of a receivable, the preferential rights and accessory rights, except those specific to the person of the assignor, shall also pass to the assignee.

Accrued interest shall be deemed to have been assigned together with the principal receivable.

III. Delivery of instruments and documents and provision of information

Article 190 – The assignor shall be obliged to deliver to the assignee the instrument of debt and the other documents relating to proof in his or her possession, and to provide the information necessary for the assignee to assert the receivable.

IV. Warranty

1. In general

Article 191 – Where the receivable has been assigned in return for a performance, the assignor shall warrant the existence of the receivable and the solvency of the debtor at the time of the assignment.

Where the receivable has been assigned without a performance in return or has passed to another by operation of law, the assignor or the previous creditor shall not be liable for the existence of the receivable or the solvency of the debtor.

2. Assignment for the purpose of performance

Article 192 – Where the creditor has assigned his or her receivable for the purpose of performing a debt but has not specified the amount to be credited against the debt, the assignee shall be obliged to credit against his or her own receivable only the amount that he or she has received from the debtor or could have received had he or she exercised due care.

3. Scope of liability

Article 193 – The assignee may make the following claims against the assignor who is bound by the warranty:

1. Return of the counter-performance he or she has rendered, together with interest.

2. The expenses caused by the assignment.

3. The expenses caused by unsuccessful attempts made to obtain the assigned receivable from the debtor.

4. His or her other damage, unless the assignor proves that he or she is not at fault.

C. Reservation of special provisions

Article 194 – The provisions laid down by law specifically for the assignment of certain rights are reserved.

SECTION TWO

Assumption of Debt

A. Internal assumption agreement

Article 195 – A person who concludes an internal assumption agreement with the debtor undertakes the obligation to release the debtor from his or her debt either by personally performing the debt or by assuming the debt with the consent of the creditor.

As long as the debtor does not perform his or her obligations arising from the internal assumption agreement, he or she may not demand that the other party fulfil its obligation.

Where the debtor has not been released from his or her debt, he or she may demand security from the other party.

B. External assumption agreement

I. Offer and acceptance

Article 196 – The substitution of a new debtor for the debtor and the release of the debtor from his or her debt shall take place by a contract concluded between the person assuming the debt and the creditor.

The notification of the internal assumption agreement to the creditor by the assuming party, or by the debtor with the assuming party’s permission, shall constitute an offer to conclude an external assumption agreement.

The creditor’s acceptance may be express or implied. Where the creditor, without raising any reservation, accepts performance by the assuming party or consents to any other transaction carried out by him or her in the capacity of debtor, the creditor shall be deemed to have accepted the assumption of the debt.

II. Binding nature of the offer

Article 197 – The offer relating to the assumption of the debt may be accepted by the creditor at any time. However, the assuming party or the previous debtor may set a time limit for acceptance. If the creditor remains silent until the expiry of this time limit, the offer shall be deemed to have been rejected.

Where, before the offer has been accepted by the creditor, a new internal assumption agreement is concluded and an offer relating to this second assumption is made to the creditor, the person who made the first offer shall be released from being bound by his or her offer.

C. Consequences of the change of debtor

I. Accessory rights and obligations

Article 198 – Even where the debtor has changed, the creditor’s accessory rights, except those specific to the person of the debtor, shall remain reserved.

However, the liabilities of a third party who has given a pledge as security for the debt and of a surety shall continue only if they have consented in writing to the assumption of the debt.

II. Defences

Article 199 – The right to assert defences relating to the assumed debt shall pass to the new debtor.

Unless otherwise apparent from the external assumption agreement, the new debtor may not raise against the creditor the personal defences that the previous debtor could have asserted.

The new debtor may not assert against the creditor defences arising from the internal assumption agreement.

D. Invalidity of the agreement

Article 200 – Where the external assumption agreement becomes invalid, the former debt shall continue to exist together with all its accessory obligations, subject to the rights of third parties acting in good faith.

Furthermore, unless the person who assumed the debt proves that no fault can be attributed to him or her for the invalidity of the assumption agreement and for the damage suffered by the creditor, the creditor may claim from the assuming party compensation for the damage suffered as a result of the loss of previously provided security or for any other reason.

E. Accession to a debt

Article 201 – Accession to a debt is a contract concluded between the acceding party and the creditor, whereby the acceding party joins an existing debt alongside the debtor, and which results in the acceding party being liable for the debt together with the debtor.

The acceding party and the debtor shall be jointly and severally liable towards the creditor.

F. Acquisition of assets or of an enterprise

Article 202 – A person who acquires assets or an enterprise together with its assets and liabilities shall be liable towards the creditors for the debts attached to the assets or the enterprise as from the date on which he or she notifies the creditors thereof or announces it by a notice to be published, in the case of commercial enterprises, in the Trade Registry Gazette and, in other cases, in one of the newspapers distributed throughout Türkiye.

However, for a period of two years, the previous debtor shall also remain liable as a joint and several debtor together with the acquirer. This period shall begin to run, for debts that are due, from the date of the notification or announcement and, for debts that become due later, from the date on which they become due.

The consequences of the assumption of debts in this manner are identical to the consequences arising from an external assumption agreement.

Unless the obligation of notification or announcement by notice is fulfilled by the acquirer, the two-year period provided for in the second paragraph shall not begin to run.

G. Merger and change of form of enterprises

Article 203 – Where an enterprise is merged with another enterprise by way of mutual acquisition of assets and liabilities or by the absorption of one by the other, the creditors of both enterprises shall have the rights arising from the acquisition of assets and may recover all their receivables from the new enterprise.

The same rule shall also apply to the debts of an enterprise belonging to a single person which is converted into a general or limited partnership.

H. Reservation of special provisions

Article 204 – The special provisions relating to the assumption of debt in connection with the partition of an inheritance and the transfer of mortgaged immovables are reserved.

SECTION THREE

Transfer of Contract and Accession to Contract

A. Transfer of contract

Article 205 – A transfer of contract is an agreement concluded between the transferee of the contract, the transferor and the party remaining in the contract, which transfers to the transferee all the rights and obligations of the transferor arising from that contract together with the status of party.

An agreement concluded between the transferee of the contract and the transferor which is based on permission given in advance by the other party remaining in the contract, or which is subsequently approved by that party, shall also be subject to the provisions on transfer of contract.

The validity of the transfer of contract shall depend on the form of the transferred contract.

Cases of subrogation arising from law and other special provisions are reserved.

B. Accession to contract

Article 206 – Accession to a contract is an agreement concluded between the acceding party and the parties to an existing contract, whereby the acceding party joins that contract alongside one of the parties, and which results in the acceding party having, together with the party alongside whom he or she stands, that party’s rights and obligations.

Unless otherwise agreed in the agreement, the party acceding to the contract and the party alongside whom he or she stands shall be joint and several creditors and debtors towards the other party to the contract.

The validity of the accession to a contract shall depend on the form of the contract that is the subject of the accession.

PART TWO

Special Obligations

CHAPTER ONE

Contract of Sale

SECTION ONE

General Provisions

A. Definition and effects

Article 207 – A contract of sale is a contract whereby the seller undertakes the obligation to transfer possession and ownership of the thing sold to the buyer, and the buyer undertakes in return the obligation to pay a price.

Unless otherwise agreed by contract or unless there is a custom to the contrary, the seller and the buyer shall be obliged to perform their obligations simultaneously.

A price that can be determined according to the circumstances and conditions shall be treated as an agreed price.

B. Benefit and risk

Article 208 – Except for exceptional cases arising from law, from the requirements of the situation or from special conditions provided for in the contract, the benefit and risk of the thing sold shall remain with the seller until the transfer of possession in sales of movables, and until the moment of registration in sales of immovables.

In sales of movables, where the buyer is in default in taking over possession of the thing sold, the benefit and risk of the thing sold shall pass to the buyer as if the transfer of possession had taken place.

Where the seller, at the buyer’s request, dispatches the thing sold to a place other than the place of performance, the benefit and risk shall pass to the buyer at the moment the thing sold is delivered to the carrier.

SECTION TWO

Sale of Movables

A. Subject matter

Article 209 – A sale of movables is the sale of things that are not deemed immovables under the Turkish Civil Code and that are specified as movables in other laws.

The sale of integral parts whose ownership is to be transferred after they have been separated from the immovable, such as produce, the debris of a building and stones to be extracted from a quarry, is also a sale of movables.

B. Obligations of the seller

I. Transfer of possession

1. Rule

Article 210 – The seller shall be obliged to transfer possession of the thing sold to the buyer for the purpose of passing ownership of it.

2. Costs of transfer and carriage

Article 211 – Unless otherwise provided by contract or custom, the costs of transfer, such as measuring and weighing, shall be borne by the seller, and the costs incurred in taking over the thing sold and, where the thing sold must be carried from the place of performance to another place, the costs of carriage shall be borne by the buyer.

Where transfer free of costs has been agreed, the seller shall be deemed to have assumed the costs of carriage.

Where transfer free of port and customs costs has been agreed, the seller shall be deemed to have assumed export, transit and import duties; however, he or she shall not be deemed to have assumed the consumption taxes paid at the time the thing sold is taken over by the buyer.

3. Default of the seller

a. Rule and exception

Article 212 – In the event of the seller’s default, the general provisions on the debtor’s default shall apply.

In commercial sales in which a specific time limit has been set for the transfer of possession, where the seller falls into default, the buyer shall be presumed to have waived the claim for transfer and to claim compensation for the damage arising from the non-performance of the debt.

Where the buyer intends to claim the transfer of the thing sold, he or she shall be obliged to notify the seller thereof immediately upon the expiry of the specified time limit.

b. Obligation to compensate and its scope

Article 213 – A seller who does not perform his or her obligation shall be obliged to compensate the damage suffered by the buyer as a result.

Where the seller does not perform his or her obligation, the buyer may claim compensation for the damage calculated on the basis of the difference between the sale price and the price he or she has paid, in accordance with the rules of good faith, in order to purchase another thing in place of the thing sold that was not transferred to him or her.

Where the thing sold is among goods quoted on a stock exchange or having a market price, the buyer may, without being obliged to purchase another thing in its place, claim compensation for the damage calculated on the basis of the difference between the sale price and the market price on the specified day of performance.

II. Liability for eviction

1. Subject matter

Article 214 – Where the whole or part of the thing sold is taken from the buyer by a third party by virtue of a right that existed at the time the contract of sale was concluded, the seller shall be liable towards the buyer for this.

Where the buyer knew of the risk of eviction at the time the contract was concluded, the seller shall not be liable for it unless he or she has expressly undertaken to be.

Where the seller has concealed the right of the third party, an agreement made to exclude or limit his or her liability shall be absolutely null and void.

2. Procedure

a. Notification of the action

Article 215 – When a buyer faced with the risk of eviction notifies the seller of the action brought against him or her, the seller shall be obliged, according to the requirements of the situation and in accordance with the rules of procedure, either to join the action on the side of the buyer or to take the place of the buyer and pursue and defend the action against the third party.

Where the notification has been made at a time suitable for joining the action and for the defence, a judgment given against the buyer shall also have effect for the seller, unless it is proved that it was given owing to the buyer’s gross fault.

Where the action has not been notified to the seller for reasons not attributable to the buyer, the seller shall be released from liability to the extent that he or she proves that a more favourable judgment could have been obtained had the notification been made in time.

b. Surrender of the thing sold without a court decision

Article 216 – The seller’s liability for eviction shall continue in the following cases:

1. Where the buyer, without awaiting a court decision, has acknowledged the right of the third party in accordance with the rules of good faith and has surrendered the thing sold to the third party.

2. Where the buyer, without waiting for the third party to bring an action against him or her, has warned the seller without delay to resolve by way of an action the dispute concerning the claim of right over the thing sold, failing which he or she would resort to arbitration, and, having obtained no result from this, has resorted to arbitration.

The seller’s liability shall also continue where the buyer proves that he or she was obliged to surrender the thing sold to the third party.

3. Rights of the buyer

a. In the case of total eviction

Article 217 – Where the whole of the thing sold has been taken from the buyer, the contract of sale shall be deemed to have ended automatically and the buyer may make the following claims against the seller:

1. Return of the sale price he or she has paid, together with interest, after deduction of the value of the produce he or she has obtained, or neglected to obtain, from the thing sold.

2. The expenses that he or she cannot claim from the third party who took the thing sold from him or her.

3. All litigation costs and extrajudicial costs, except those that could have been avoided by notifying the seller of the action.

4. Other damage suffered by him or her as a direct result of the total eviction of the thing sold.

Unless the seller proves that no fault whatsoever can be attributed to him or her, he or she shall also be obliged to compensate the other damage suffered by the buyer as a result of the eviction of the thing sold.

b. In the case of partial eviction

Article 218 – Where part of the thing sold has been taken from the buyer, or the thing sold is encumbered with a limited real right, the buyer may only claim compensation for the damage he or she has suffered as a result.

However, where it is apparent from the circumstances and conditions that the buyer would not have purchased the thing sold had he or she known of this situation, the buyer may request the judge to rule that the contract be terminated. In that case, the buyer shall be obliged to return to the seller the part of the thing sold that has remained in his or her hands, together with the benefits he or she has obtained up to that time.

III. Liability for defects

1. Subject matter

a. In general

Article 219 – The seller shall be liable to the buyer not only for the absence in the thing sold of the qualities that he or she has declared to the buyer in any manner whatsoever, but also for the existence of material, legal or economic defects which are contrary to its quality or to the quantity affecting its quality, and which eliminate or considerably reduce its value in terms of its intended use or the benefits the buyer expects from it.

The seller shall be liable for such defects even if he or she is unaware of their existence.

b. In the sale of animals

Article 220 – In the sale of animals, the seller shall not be liable for defects unless he or she has undertaken to be so in writing or is guilty of gross fault.

2. Agreement excluding liability

Article 221 – Where the seller is guilty of gross fault in transferring the thing sold in a defective state, any agreement excluding or limiting his or her liability for defects shall be absolutely null and void.

3. Defects known to the buyer

Article 222 – The seller shall not be liable for defects known to the buyer at the time the contract of sale was concluded.

The seller shall be liable for defects that the buyer could have discovered by adequately examining the thing sold only if he or she has expressly undertaken that no such defect exists.

4. Examination and notification to the seller

a. In general

Article 223 – The buyer shall be obliged to examine the condition of the thing sold that he or she has taken over as soon as possible in the ordinary course of business and, if he or she discovers a defect in the thing sold for which the seller is liable, to notify the seller thereof within a reasonable time.

Where the buyer neglects to carry out the examination and to give notification, he or she shall be deemed to have accepted the thing sold. However, this provision shall not apply where the thing sold has a defect that cannot be revealed by an ordinary examination. If the existence of such a defect is discovered subsequently, it must be notified to the seller immediately; failing such notification, the thing sold shall be deemed to have been accepted with this defect.

b. In the sale of animals

Article 224 – In the sale of animals, where the period during which the seller is to be liable has not been determined in writing and the defect does not relate to the pregnancy of the animal, the seller shall be liable only if the defect has been notified to him or her within nine days from the day on which the transfer took place or on which the buyer’s default in taking delivery occurred and, in addition, an examination of the animal by experts has been requested from the competent authority within the same period.

5. Consequences of the seller’s gross fault

Article 225 – A seller who is guilty of gross fault may not be released from liability, even partly, by asserting that the defect in the thing sold was not notified to him or her in time.

The same rule shall apply in respect of defects that persons who have made selling their profession ought to know.

6. Dispatch of the thing sold from another place

Article 226 – A buyer who asserts that the thing sold dispatched from another place is defective shall, if the seller has no representative at the place where the buyer is located, be obliged to take provisionally the measures necessary for the preservation of the thing sold. The buyer may not return to the seller the thing sold that he or she asserts is defective without taking the measures necessary for its preservation.

The buyer shall be obliged to have the condition of the thing sold duly established without delay. If he or she fails to do so, the burden of proving that the defect he or she asserts existed at the time the thing sold reached him or her shall fall on the buyer.

Where there is a risk that the thing sold will deteriorate quickly, the buyer shall be entitled, and, where the interests of the seller so require, even obliged, to have it sold through the court of the place where it is located. Where the buyer does not notify the seller of the situation as soon as possible, he or she shall be liable for the resulting damage.

7. Elective rights of the buyer

a. In general

Article 227 – In cases where the seller is liable for the defects of the thing sold, the buyer may exercise one of the following elective rights:

1. Withdrawal from the contract, declaring that he or she is ready to return the thing sold.

2. Retaining the thing sold and claiming a reduction of the sale price in proportion to the defect.

3. Where it does not entail excessive expense, claiming that the thing sold be repaired free of charge, all expenses being borne by the seller.

4. Where possible, claiming the replacement of the thing sold with a defect-free equivalent.

The buyer’s right to claim compensation under the general provisions is reserved.

The seller may prevent the buyer from exercising his or her elective rights by immediately supplying the buyer with a defect-free equivalent of the same goods and compensating the whole of the damage he or she has suffered.

Where the buyer exercises the right to withdraw from the contract, the judge may, if the circumstances do not justify this, rule that the thing sold be repaired or that the sale price be reduced.

Where the reduction in the value of the thing sold is very close to the sale price, the buyer may exercise only one of the rights to withdraw from the contract or to claim the replacement of the thing sold with a defect-free equivalent.

b. Destruction of or serious damage to the thing sold

Article 228 – The destruction of or serious damage to the thing sold which has been transferred to the buyer in a defective state, owing to the defect, to an unforeseen event or to force majeure, shall not prevent the buyer from exercising his or her right to withdraw from the contract. In that case, the buyer shall be obliged to return whatever remains of the thing sold in his or her hands.

Where the thing sold has been destroyed for a reason attributable to the buyer, or the buyer has transferred it to another person or has altered its form, the buyer may only claim that the amount corresponding to the reduction in its value be deducted from the sale price.

8. Consequences of withdrawal

a. In general

Article 229 – A buyer who withdraws from the contract of sale shall be obliged to return the thing sold to the seller together with the benefits he or she has obtained from it. In return, the buyer may make the following claims against the seller:

1. Return of the sale price he or she has paid, together with interest.

2. Payment of the litigation costs and of the expenses he or she has incurred for the thing sold, as in the case of total eviction of the thing sold.

3. Compensation for the direct damage he or she has suffered as a result of the defective goods.

Unless the seller proves that no fault whatsoever can be attributed to him or her, he or she shall also be obliged to compensate the other damage of the buyer.

b. In the sale of several items

Article 230 – Where several items, or an item consisting of several parts, have been sold together and some of them prove to be defective, the right of withdrawal may be exercised only in respect of those that prove to be defective. However, where it is not possible to separate the defective part from the others without causing considerable damage to the buyer or the seller, the right of withdrawal must extend to the whole of the thing sold.

Withdrawal from the sale in respect of the principal thing sold shall also extend to its accessories, even if they have been sold with a separate sale price indicated; however, withdrawal in respect of the accessories shall not extend to the principal thing sold.

9. Statute of limitations

Article 231 – Unless the seller has undertaken liability for a longer period, all actions relating to liability arising from a defect in the thing sold shall become time-barred upon the expiry of two years from the transfer of the thing sold to the buyer, even if the defect in the thing sold emerges later. The buyer’s right of defence arising from a defect notified within two years from the transfer of the thing sold to him or her shall not lapse upon the expiry of this period.

Where the seller is guilty of gross fault in transferring the thing sold in a defective state, he or she may not benefit from the two-year limitation period.

C. Obligations of the buyer

I. Payment of the sale price and taking delivery of the thing sold

Article 232 – The buyer shall be obliged to pay the sale price in the manner agreed in the contract of sale and to take delivery of the thing sold tendered to him or her.

Unless there is a local custom or agreement to the contrary, the thing sold must be taken delivery of immediately.

II. Determination of the sale price

Article 233 – Where the buyer has firmly declared that he or she will purchase the goods without specifying the sale price, the sale shall be deemed to have been made at the average market price at the place and time of performance.

Where the sale price is calculated according to the weight of the thing sold, the tare shall be deducted.

The commercial usages relating, in the sale of certain commercial goods, to a deduction from the gross weight by a fixed amount or by a percentage, or to the determination of the price on the basis of the gross weight, are reserved.

III. Maturity of and interest on the sale price

Article 234 – Unless otherwise provided by contract, the sale price shall become due when the thing sold enters into the possession of the buyer.

Where there is a usage under which interest may be claimed, or where the buyer has the possibility of obtaining produce or other yields from the goods, or where default occurs upon the expiry of a fixed day, interest may be claimed on the sale price without any further formal notice being required.

IV. Default of the buyer

1. Seller’s right of withdrawal

Article 235 – In cases where the thing sold is to be transferred only after or upon payment of the sale price, if the buyer falls into default, the seller may withdraw from the sale without any further formality.

A seller wishing to exercise this right shall be obliged to notify the buyer of the situation without delay.

Where possession of the thing sold has been transferred to the buyer before payment of the sale price, the seller’s taking back of the thing sold by exercising the right of withdrawal on account of the buyer’s default shall depend on this right having been expressly reserved in the contract.

2. Calculation and compensation of the damage

Article 236 – A buyer who does not perform his or her obligation shall be obliged to compensate the damage suffered by the seller as a result.

The seller may claim from the buyer who is in default in paying the sale price compensation for the damage calculated on the basis of the difference between that price and the price obtained by the seller from selling the thing sold to another person in accordance with the rules of good faith.

Where the thing sold is among goods quoted on a stock exchange or having a market price, the seller may, without any need for such a sale, claim from the buyer compensation for the damage calculated on the basis of the difference between the sale price and the price of the goods on the specified day of payment.

SECTION THREE

Sale of Immovables and Rights Giving Rise to a Sale Relationship

A. Form

Article 237 – For a sale of immovables to be valid, the contract must be drawn up in official form.

A promise to sell an immovable, and contracts of repurchase and purchase, shall not be valid unless drawn up in official form.

The validity of a contract of pre-emption shall depend on its being made in writing.

B. Rights giving rise to a sale relationship

I. Duration and annotation

Article 238 – Rights of pre-emption, repurchase and purchase may be agreed for a period of at most ten years and may be annotated in the land register for the period determined by law.

II. Transfer and passing by inheritance

Article 239 – Unless otherwise agreed, the contractual rights of pre-emption, purchase and repurchase may not be transferred, but shall pass by inheritance.

Where it has been agreed by contract that these rights may be transferred, the act of transfer shall not be valid unless it is made in the form prescribed for the creation of the right.

III. Right of pre-emption

1. Assertion

Article 240 – The right of pre-emption may be exercised in the event of the sale of the immovable or of any transaction economically equivalent to a sale.

The right of pre-emption may not be exercised where the immovable is allotted to one of the heirs in the partition of an inheritance, is sold by way of compulsory auction, or is acquired for the purpose of carrying out public services and for similar purposes.

2. Conditions and effects

Article 241 – The seller or the buyer shall be obliged to notify the holder of the right of pre-emption, through a notary, of the conclusion and content of the contract of sale.

Where, after the right of pre-emption has been exercised, the contract of sale is set aside or is not approved for reasons arising from the person of the buyer, this may not be asserted against the holder of the right of pre-emption.

Unless otherwise provided in the contract establishing the right of pre-emption, the holder of the right of pre-emption shall acquire the immovable on the conditions of sale agreed by the seller with the third party.

The above provisions shall also apply to transactions economically equivalent to a sale.

3. Exercise and effects

Article 242 – A holder wishing to exercise a contractual right of pre-emption shall be obliged to bring an action, against the buyer if the right has been annotated and the ownership of the immovable has been registered in the name of the buyer, and otherwise against the seller, within three months from the date on which the sale or another transaction economically equivalent to a sale was notified to him or her and, in any event, within two years from the conclusion of the sale.

C. Sale of immovables

I. Conditional sale and reservation of ownership

Article 243 – In a conditional sale of an immovable, no registration in the land register may be made unless the condition is fulfilled.

A condition reserving ownership in the sale of an immovable may not be registered either.

II. Liability

Article 244 – Unless otherwise provided by contract, where the immovable sold does not have the surface area stated in the contract of sale, the seller shall be obliged to pay compensation to the buyer for the shortfall.

Where the immovable sold does not contain the surface area entered in the land register on the basis of an official survey, the seller shall not be liable for compensation unless he or she has expressly undertaken to be.

Actions arising from defects in a building shall become time-barred upon the expiry of five years from the passing of ownership and, where the seller is guilty of gross fault, upon the expiry of twenty years.

III. Benefit and risk

Article 245 – Where a period has been fixed by contract for the buyer to take delivery of the thing sold at a time after registration, the benefit and risk thereof shall pass to the buyer upon delivery. This provision shall also apply where the buyer is in default in taking delivery of the thing sold.

The validity of this contract shall be subject to its having been made in writing.

IV. Application of the rules relating to the sale of movables

Article 246 – The rules relating to the sale of movables shall also apply by analogy to the sale of immovables.

SECTION FOUR

Certain Types of Sale

A. Sale by sample

I. Definition

Article 247 – A sale by sample is a sale made by the parties agreeing that the goods forming the subject matter of the contract shall conform to a sample left with the buyer or with a third person, or to goods determined by them.

II. Burden of proof

Article 248 – In a sale by sample, the party to whom the sample was given shall not bear the burden of proving that the sample in his or her hands is the sample that was given to him or her and, even if the form of the sample has changed, the buyer’s assertion shall be deemed correct where this change is a necessary consequence of the inspection. However, the other party shall in any case have the right to prove the contrary.

Where the sample has deteriorated or been destroyed while in the hands of the buyer, the burden of proving that the thing sold does not conform to the sample shall lie with the buyer, even if he or she is not at fault.

B. Sale on approval

I. Definition

Article 249 – A sale on approval is a sale made on condition that the buyer approves the thing sold after testing or inspecting it.

II. Provisions

Article 250 – In a sale on approval, the buyer is free to accept the thing sold or to return it without giving any reason.

Even if the thing sold has passed into the possession of the buyer, ownership of the thing sold shall remain with the seller until the moment the condition of approval is fulfilled.

III. Testing or inspection

1. At the seller’s premises

Article 251 – Where the testing or inspection is to be carried out at the seller’s premises and the buyer does not declare, within the period required by the contract or by custom, whether or not he or she accepts the thing sold, the seller shall be released from being bound by the contract.

Where no such period has been fixed, the seller may, after the lapse of a reasonable period, call upon the buyer to state whether or not he or she accepts the thing sold; if no immediate reply is given to this notice, the seller shall be released from being bound by the contract.

2. At the buyer’s premises

Article 252 – Where the thing sold has been given to the buyer without having been tested or inspected, the condition of approval shall be deemed fulfilled if the buyer does not immediately give notice that he or she does not approve the thing sold, or does not return it, within the period required by the contract or by custom or, where there is no such period, upon the notice of the seller.

The condition of approval shall also be deemed fulfilled where the buyer, without expressing any reservation, pays all or part of the sale price or uses the thing sold in a manner exceeding the purpose of testing or inspection.

C. Sales with payment in instalments

I. Instalment sale

1. Definition, form and content

Article 253 – An instalment sale is a sale in which the seller undertakes to deliver the movable sold to the buyer before payment of the sale price, and the buyer undertakes to pay the sale price in parts.

An instalment sale contract shall not be valid unless made in writing.

Where the goods are sold within the scope of the seller’s commercial activity, the following matters shall be stated in the contract:

1. The names and domiciles of the parties.

2. The subject matter of the sale.

3. The cash sale price of the thing sold.

4. The additional price to be specified on account of payment in instalments.

5. The total sale price.

6. All other performances undertaken by the buyer in cash or in kind.

7. The amount and due dates of the down payment and the instalments, and the number of instalments, which shall not be less than two.

8. The right of the buyer to revoke, within seven days, his or her declaration of intent to conclude the contract.

9. Where provided for, the agreed clauses relating to retention of title or to the assignment of the claim for the sale price.

10. The interest to be paid in the event of default or of postponement of the due date, not exceeding thirty per cent above the statutory interest rate.

11. The place and date of conclusion of the contract.

2. Consent of the legal representative

Article 254 – The validity of an instalment sale contract made by a minor or a person under guardianship who has capacity of discernment shall be subject to the written consent of the legal representative. In this case, the consent must have been given at the latest at the time of conclusion of the contract.

3. Taking effect of the contract and declaration of revocation

Article 255 – An instalment sale contract shall take effect, as regards the buyer, seven days after a copy of the contract signed by the parties comes into his or her hands. The buyer may notify the seller in writing within this period that he or she revokes his or her declaration of intent. This right may not be waived in advance. It shall be sufficient for the notice of revocation to take effect that it was posted on the last day of the period.

Where the seller has transferred the goods to the buyer within the revocation period, the buyer may use the goods only to the extent required by an ordinary inspection; otherwise, the contract shall be deemed to have taken effect.

Where the buyer exercises the right of revocation, no withdrawal fee may be demanded from him or her.

4. Rights and obligations of the parties

a. Obligation to pay the down payment and duration of the contract

Article 256 – The buyer is obliged to pay at least one tenth of the cash sale price in cash at the latest at the time of delivery, and the remaining part of the sale price within three years following the conclusion of the contract.

The President may, according to the type of the thing sold, reduce the amount of the down payment and the statutory payment periods by up to one half, or increase them up to twofold.1

A seller who transfers the thing sold to the buyer without having received the full minimum down payment specified by law shall lose the right to claim the unpaid part of the down payment.

An increase in the sale price made in return for waiving the down payment shall be null and void.

b. Defences of the buyer

Article 257 – The buyer may not waive in advance the right to set off the seller’s claim arising from the instalment sale against his or her own claim against the seller.

In the event of assignment of the claim, the buyer’s defences relating to the claim for the sale price may not be limited or excluded.

c. Payment of the sale price in full

Article 258 – Unless the instalment debt has been embodied in a bill of exchange, the buyer may at any time release himself or herself from the debt by paying the remaining part of the sale price in a single sum. In this case, the portion of the price added to the cash sale price that corresponds to the unpaid instalments shall be reduced in proportion to the shortening of the payment period, but not by less than one half.

5. Default of the buyer

a. Seller’s right of election

Article 259 – Where the buyer is in default in paying the down payment, the seller may claim only the down payment or may withdraw from the contract.

Where the buyer is in default in paying the instalments, the seller may claim payment of the instalments that have fallen due or of the whole remaining sale price in a single sum, or may withdraw from the contract. The seller’s ability to claim the whole remaining sale price or to withdraw from the contract shall be subject to the seller’s having expressly reserved this right and to the buyer’s being in default in paying at least two consecutive instalments constituting at least one tenth of the agreed sale price, or one instalment constituting at least one quarter thereof, or the last instalment. However, if the amount that the seller may claim on account of withdrawal is equal to or greater than the total of the instalments paid, the seller may not withdraw from the contract.

Before exercising the rights to claim payment in full of the remaining part of the sale price or to withdraw from the contract, the seller is obliged to grant the buyer a period of at least fifteen days.

b. Withdrawal from the contract

Article 260 – Where the seller withdraws from the contract after the transfer of the thing sold to the buyer by reason of the buyer’s default in paying the instalments, each party is obliged to return what it has received. The seller may, in addition, claim an equitable fee for use and, in the event of a decrease in value due to extraordinary use of the thing sold, compensation. However, the seller may not claim more than he or she would have obtained had the contract been performed in due time.

Where the seller withdraws from the contract before the transfer of the thing sold by reason of the buyer’s default in paying the down payment, he or she may claim from the buyer only statutory interest on the unpaid down payment accruing until the date of withdrawal from the contract, and compensation for the loss of value suffered by the thing sold after the conclusion of the contract. Where a penalty clause has been agreed, it may not exceed ten per cent of the cash sale price.

c. Intervention of the judge

Article 261 – The judge may grant the buyer facilities for payment and may prohibit the seller from taking back the thing sold, on condition that the buyer in default gives security that he or she will pay his or her debts and that the seller will not suffer any loss by reason of this new arrangement.

6. Competent court and arbitration

Article 262 – A buyer whose domicile is in Türkiye may neither waive in advance the jurisdiction of the court of his or her domicile in respect of disputes arising from an instalment sale contract to which he or she is a party, nor conclude an arbitration agreement.

7. Scope of application

Article 263 – The provisions relating to instalment sales shall also apply to transactions made for the same economic purpose.

In loan contracts made for the purpose of acquiring a movable, where the seller assigns the claim for the sale price to the lender, together with or independently of a retention of title clause, or where the seller and the lender, by otherwise agreeing, arrange for the delivery of the goods on the basis that the buyer will pay the sale price later in instalments, the provisions relating to instalment sales shall apply by analogy. The loan contract must contain the matters that are mandatory in instalment sale contracts. However, instead of the cash sale price and the total sale price, the amount borrowed and the total loan amount to be paid to the lender shall be indicated.

In instalment loan contracts connected with a cash sale, the provisions relating to instalment sales shall not apply where the statutory minimum down payment has been paid to the lender and the cash sale price has been fully covered at the time of conclusion of the loan contract without any addition.

Where the buyer acts in the capacity of a merchant or the goods are purchased for the needs of a commercial enterprise or for professional purposes, only the provisions of the second paragraph of Article 259, the first paragraph of Article 260 and Article 261 among the provisions relating to instalment sales shall apply.

II. Instalment sale with prepayment

1. Definition, form and content

Article 264 – An instalment sale with prepayment is a sale in which the buyer undertakes to pay the sale price of movable goods in advance in parts, and the seller undertakes to transfer the thing sold to the buyer after the price has been paid in full.

An instalment sale contract with prepayment shall not be valid unless made in writing. The following matters shall be stated in the contract:

1. The names and domiciles of the parties.

2. The subject matter of the sale.

3. The total sale price.

4. The number, amount and due dates of the instalments and the duration of the contract.

5. The bank authorised to accept the instalments.

6. The amount of interest undertaken towards the buyer.

7. The right of the buyer to revoke, within seven days, his or her declaration of intent to conclude the contract.

8. The right of the buyer to withdraw from the contract and the withdrawal fee payable by him or her on that account.

9. The place and date of conclusion of the contract.

2. Rights and obligations of the parties

a. Securing of payments

Article 265 – In contracts whose payment period is longer than one year or indefinite, the buyer is obliged to deposit the payments into an income-generating savings or investment account to be opened in his or her name at a bank specified in the contract.

The bank is obliged to safeguard the interests of both parties. Payments may be made from the account opened with the consent of both parties. This consent may not be given in advance.

In contracts whose payment period is longer than one year or indefinite, where the buyer withdraws from the contract in accordance with Article 269 before the transfer of the thing sold, the seller shall lose all his or her rights in respect of this account.

b. Right of the buyer to demand transfer of the goods

Article 266 – After paying the whole of the sale price, the buyer may at any time demand that the goods be transferred to him or her. However, where the seller is to transfer the goods by procuring them from another person, the buyer is obliged to grant him or her a reasonable period for this.

In order for the seller to be able to transfer the goods to the buyer, the conditions relating to instalment sales must be complied with.

Where the buyer has purchased more than one thing or has reserved a right of choice, he or she may demand the transfer of the thing sold in parts only after paying the minimum down payment provided for in Article 256. This demand may not be made where the thing sold constitutes a collection of things. Where the sale price has not been paid in full, partial transfer of the thing sold may be demanded from the seller only on condition that ten per cent of the remaining part is left with the seller as security.

c. Payment of the sale price

Article 267 – In contracts whose payment period is longer than one year or indefinite, the sale price must have been paid in full at the time of transfer of the thing sold. A buyer who demands the transfer of the thing sold may release in favour of the seller, from the balance in his or her account, at most one third of the sale price. However, no undertaking to this effect may be given at the time of conclusion of the contract.

d. Determination of the sale price

Article 268 – All clauses reserving to the seller the right to claim a price in addition to the total sale price determined at the time of conclusion of the contract shall be invalid.

Where the total sale price to be paid has been determined in the contract but the things to be transferred have not been determined in advance and the right to choose these things has been granted to the buyer by the seller, the seller is obliged to comply fully with the choice to be made by the buyer, taking into account the ordinary prices in cash sales.

Agreements to the contrary shall be valid only to the extent that they are in favour of the buyer.

3. Termination of the contract

a. Right of withdrawal

Article 269 – In contracts whose payment period is longer than one year or indefinite, the buyer may withdraw from the contract at any time until the transfer of the goods.

In the event of withdrawal from the contract, the withdrawal fee provided to be paid by the buyer shall be determined having regard to the particular circumstances of the case and to the period elapsed between the conclusion of the contract and the withdrawal. However, this amount may not be less than two per cent or more than five per cent of the seller’s total claim. The buyer may demand that the part of the payments made by him or her exceeding the withdrawal fee be returned to him or her together with the returns thereon.

Where withdrawal from the contract occurs because the buyer has become unable to make the prepayments by reason of death or permanent loss of the ability to earn an income, or because the seller has not accepted the buyer’s offer to replace the contract with an instalment sale contract to be made on ordinary terms, no withdrawal fee may be demanded.

b. Duration of the contract

Article 270 – The obligation to perform the prepayments shall end upon the lapse of five years.

In contracts whose payment period is longer than one year or indefinite, where the buyer does not demand the transfer of the thing sold even though eight years have elapsed, the seller shall warn him or her and grant a period of three months. If the buyer remains indifferent within this period, the seller shall have the rights granted to the buyer in the event of withdrawal from the contract.

c. Default of the buyer

Article 271 – Where the buyer is in default in one or more prepayments, the seller may claim only the payments that have fallen due. Nevertheless, where two consecutive prepayments constituting at least one tenth of the total claim, or a single prepayment constituting at least one quarter of the total claim, or the last prepayment has fallen due, the seller shall also have the right to withdraw from the contract after the lapse of a payment period of one month to be granted to the buyer.

Where the seller withdraws from a contract whose payment period is one year or less, the provision of the second paragraph of Article 260 shall apply by analogy. In contracts whose duration exceeds one year, the seller may claim only the withdrawal fee provided for in the second paragraph of Article 269 and compensation for losses exceeding the average bank deposit interest to be paid to the buyer.

In contracts with a duration longer than one year, where the buyer in default demands the transfer of the goods, the seller may claim, together with statutory interest on the principal, compensation for decreases in the value of the goods occurring after the demand for transfer. Where a penalty clause has been provided for, its amount may not exceed ten per cent of the sale price.

In cases where the thing sold has been transferred, the provision of the first paragraph of Article 260 shall apply in respect of withdrawal.

4. Limitation of the scope of application

Article 272 – Where the buyer acts in the capacity of a merchant or the goods are purchased for the needs of a commercial enterprise or for professional purposes, Articles 264 to 271 shall not apply.

III. Common provisions

Article 273 – Those provisions relating to instalment sales which concern the consent of the legal representative, the taking effect of the contract and the declaration of revocation, the defences of the buyer, the assignment of the seller’s claim, the facilities for payment granted by the judge, and the competent court and arbitration shall also apply to instalment sales with prepayment.

In an instalment sale in which the period for transfer of the thing sold is longer than one year or indefinite, where the buyer is obliged to make payments before the transfer of the thing sold, the provisions relating to instalment sales with prepayment shall apply by analogy.

D. Sale by public auction

I. Definition

Article 274 – A sale by public auction is a sale whose place, time and conditions are determined in advance and which is made with the person offering the highest price from among those present.

II. Conclusion

Article 275 – Unless the seller has made a declaration of intent to the contrary in the conditions of the auction, in voluntary public auctions in which anyone may participate, the contract of sale shall be concluded upon the person conducting the auction knocking down the thing to the person offering the highest price.

A sale by compulsory auction shall be concluded upon the official conducting the auction knocking down the thing to the person offering the highest price.

III. Provisions

1. Moment at which the bidder is bound

a. In general

Article 276 – A person participating in the auction shall be bound by his or her bid within the framework of the conditions laid down for the sale.

Unless there is a condition to the contrary, the bidder shall cease to be bound when a higher bid is made, or, where upon a call for higher bids it becomes apparent that there is no such bid, when his or her bid is not immediately accepted.

b. In the sale of an immovable by public auction

Article 277 – In the sale of an immovable by public auction, the knocking down or the rejection must take place immediately after the auction.

A condition providing that the bidder shall remain bound after the auction is invalid. However, this rule shall not apply to compulsory auctions or to cases where the knocking down must be approved by a public official.

2. Requirement of payment in cash

Article 278 – Unless otherwise agreed in the conditions of the auction, the auction price must be paid in cash.

Where the auction price is not paid in cash or in accordance with the conditions of the auction, the seller may immediately withdraw from the sale.

3. Passing of ownership

Article 279 – A person who acquires movable goods at an auction shall acquire ownership thereof at the moment of the knocking down. Ownership of an immovable acquired at an auction shall pass to the buyer only upon registration in the land register.

The auction official shall immediately notify the land registry office of the registration in the name of the buyer of the immovable indicated in the record of sale.

The special provisions relating to the passing of ownership in sales knocked down as a result of a compulsory auction are reserved.

In voluntary private auctions, the passing of ownership shall be subject to the general provisions.

4. Liability for eviction and defects

Article 280 – The provisions relating to liability for eviction and defects shall not apply in compulsory auctions.

A person who acquires goods at an auction becomes the owner of those goods in the condition, and with the rights and burdens, determined according to the land register, the conditions of sale or the law.

In voluntary public auctions, the seller shall be liable for eviction and for defects of the thing sold. However, except in cases of fraud, the seller may be released from this liability by expressly stating and announcing it in the conditions of the auction.

IV. Annulment of the auction

Article 281 – Where the knocking down has been brought about by recourse to unlawful or immoral means, any interested party may request the court to annul the knocking down within ten days from the day on which he or she learned of the ground for annulment and, in any case, within one year following the date of the knocking down.

Special provisions concerning compulsory auctions are reserved.

CHAPTER TWO

Contract of Exchange

A. Definition

Article 282 – A contract of exchange is a contract whereby one of the parties undertakes to transfer to the other party possession and ownership of one or more things, and the other party undertakes, as counter-performance, to transfer possession and ownership of one or more other things.

B. Applicable provisions

Article 283 – The provisions relating to the contract of sale shall also apply to the contract of exchange; accordingly, each of the parties is in the position of a seller with respect to the thing that he or she undertakes to give, and in the position of a buyer with respect to the thing that is undertaken to be given to him or her.

C. Liability for eviction and defects

Article 284 – The provisions of the contract of sale relating to liability for eviction and defects shall also apply to the contract of exchange, to the extent appropriate.

CHAPTER THREE

Contract of Gift

A. Definition

Article 285 – A contract of gift is a contract whereby the donor undertakes to make, from his or her assets, a gratuitous transfer of value to the donee, to take effect inter vivos.

Waiving a right not yet acquired or renouncing an inheritance does not constitute a gift.

The fulfilment of a moral duty shall not be deemed a gift either.

B. Capacity to make a gift

I. For the donor

Article 286 – Any person having capacity to act may make a gift, subject to the limitations arising from the matrimonial property regime between spouses or from the law of succession.

Where, as a result of proceedings commenced within one year following the gift, it is decided that the donor be placed under guardianship by reason of prodigality, that gift may be annulled by the court.

II. For the donee

Article 287 – A person who lacks capacity to act may accept a gift if he or she has capacity of discernment. However, if the legal representative of the donee prohibits that person’s acceptance of the gift or orders the return of the thing given, the gift shall cease to exist.

C. Conclusion

I. Promise of a gift

Article 288 – The validity of a promise of a gift shall be subject to this contract having been made in writing.

The validity of a promise to give an immovable or a right in rem over an immovable shall be subject only to its having been made in official form.

A promise of a gift that is invalid due to non-compliance with the form shall, once fulfilled by the donor, have the effect of a manual gift. However, this provision shall not apply to gifts whose validity is subject to official form.

II. Manual gift

Article 289 – A manual gift is concluded by the donor delivering a movable to the donee.

III. Conditional gift

Article 290 – A gift may be made subject to a condition.

In the case of a gift whose fulfilment depends on the death of the donor, the provisions relating to legacies shall apply.

IV. Gift subject to a charge

Article 291 – The donor may attach charges to the gift.

The donor may demand the fulfilment of the charges accepted by the donee in accordance with the contract.

The authority to demand the fulfilment of a charge attached to a gift in the public interest shall pass, after the death of the donor, to the relevant public authority.

The donee may refuse to fulfil the charge if the value of the subject matter of the gift does not cover the costs of fulfilling the charge and the excess is not paid to him or her.

V. Gift subject to the condition of reversion to the donor

Article 292 – The donor may stipulate the condition that the subject matter of the gift shall revert to him or her in the event that the donee dies before him or her.

Where the subject matter of the gift relates to an immovable or to a right in rem over an immovable, the condition of reversion to the donor may be annotated in the land register.

VI. Revocation of the offer of a gift

Article 293 – A person who has offered to give property to another may revoke the offer of the gift until the acceptance of the donee, even if he or she has actually separated that property from his or her other property.

D. Liability of the donor

Article 294 – The donor shall not be liable to the donee for loss arising from the gift unless he or she caused that loss through gross fault.

Where the donor has additionally given a promise of warranty in respect of the thing or claim given, he or she shall be liable accordingly.

E. Cessation of the gift

I. Revocation of the gift

Article 295 – The donor may revoke a manual gift or a promise of a gift that he or she has fulfilled, and may claim the return of the subject matter of the gift to the extent of the donee’s enrichment at the date of the claim, if one of the following circumstances has occurred:

1. If the donee has committed a serious offence against the donor or one of his or her relatives.

2. If the donee has significantly breached his or her legal obligations towards the donor or a member of the donor’s family.

3. If, in the case of a gift subject to a charge, the donee has failed to fulfil the charge without just cause.

II. Revocation of the promise of a gift and refusal of performance

Article 296 – A person who has promised a gift may revoke the promise and refuse its performance in the following circumstances:

1. If one of the grounds exists on which he or she could claim the return of property given by manual gift.

2. If his or her financial situation has subsequently changed to such an extent that fulfilling the promise would be extraordinarily burdensome for him or her.

3. If, after the promise of the gift was given, new family obligations have arisen for him or her or these obligations have become considerably heavier.

Where the insolvency of the person who has promised the gift is established or his or her bankruptcy is adjudicated, the obligation of performance shall cease.

III. Period of the right of revocation and its passing to heirs

Article 297 – The donor may revoke the gift within one year from the day on which he or she learned of the ground for revocation.

If the donor dies before the expiry of the one-year period, the right of revocation shall pass to his or her heirs, and the heirs may exercise this right until the expiry of this period.

If the donor was unable to learn of the ground for revocation during his or her lifetime, his or her heirs may exercise the right to revoke the gift within one year from his or her death.

If the donee intentionally and unlawfully kills the donor or prevents him or her from exercising the right of revocation, the donor’s heirs may revoke the gift.

IV. Death of the donor

Article 298 – Unless otherwise agreed, a gift comprising periodic performances shall end upon the death of the donor.

CHAPTER FOUR

Lease Contract

SECTION ONE

General Provisions

A. Definition

Article 299 – A lease contract is a contract whereby the lessor undertakes to leave to the lessee the use of a thing, or its use together with the enjoyment of its fruits, and the lessee undertakes in return to pay the agreed rent.

B. Term of the lease

Article 300 – A lease contract may be made for a definite or an indefinite term.

A lease contract that is to end upon the expiry of the agreed term without any notice is a fixed-term contract; other lease contracts shall be deemed to have been made for an indefinite term.

C. Obligations of the lessor

I. Obligation to deliver

Article 301 – The lessor is obliged to deliver the leased property on the agreed date in a condition fit for the use intended in the contract and to maintain it in that condition throughout the term of the contract. In leases of residential and roofed business premises, this provision may not be altered to the detriment of the lessee; in other lease contracts, no arrangement contrary to this provision may be made to the detriment of the lessee by means of general terms and conditions.

II. Obligation to bear taxes and similar charges

Article 302 – Unless otherwise agreed or provided for by law, compulsory insurance, taxes and similar charges relating to the leased property shall be borne by the lessor.

III. Obligation to bear ancillary costs

Article 303 – The lessor is obliged to bear the ancillary costs incurred by himself or herself or by a third person in connection with the use of the leased property.

IV. Liability of the lessor for defects in the leased property

1. Liability for defects in the leased property at the time of delivery

Article 304 – Where the leased property is delivered with material defects, the lessee may invoke the provisions relating to default of the obligor or to the liability of the lessor arising from the leased property subsequently becoming defective.

Where the leased property is delivered with defects that are not material, the lessee may invoke the provisions relating to the liability of the lessor for defects subsequently arising in the leased property.

2. Liability for the leased property subsequently becoming defective

a. In general

Article 305 – Where the leased property subsequently becomes defective, the lessee may claim from the lessor the remedying of the defects, or a reduction of the rent proportionate to the defect, or compensation for his or her loss. However, the claim for compensation for loss shall not preclude the exercise of the other elective rights.

In the event of a material defect, the lessee’s right to terminate the contract is reserved.

b. Claim for remedying of the defect and termination

Article 306 – The lessee may claim from the lessor that the defect in the leased property be remedied within a reasonable period; if the defect is not remedied within this period, the lessee may have the defect remedied at the lessor’s expense and deduct the resulting claim from the rent, or may claim that the leased property be replaced by a similar one free of defects.

Where the defect eliminates, or significantly impedes, the fitness of the leased property for the intended use and is not remedied within the period granted, the lessee may terminate the contract.

Instead of remedying the defect in the leased property, the lessor may replace it with a similar one free of defects within a reasonable period.

The lessor may prevent the lessee from exercising his or her elective rights by immediately giving the lessee a similar item of the same goods free of defects and by compensating in full the loss suffered by him or her.

c. Reduction of the rent

Article 307 – In the event of defects affecting the use of the leased property, the lessee may claim a reduction of the rent proportionate to the defect for the period from the time the lessor learned of those defects until the defect is remedied.

d. Compensation for loss

Article 308 – Unless the lessor proves that he or she is not at fault, he or she is obliged to compensate the lessee for losses arising from the leased property being defective.

V. Liability on account of rights asserted by a third person

1. Liability for eviction

Article 309 – Where a third person asserts a right in the leased property that is incompatible with the right of the lessee, the lessor is obliged, upon notice from the lessee, to take over the conduct of the case and to compensate any loss suffered by the lessee.

2. A third person acquiring a superior right after the conclusion of the contract

a. Change of ownership of the leased property

Article 310 – Where, after the conclusion of the contract, the leased property changes hands for any reason, the new owner shall become a party to the lease contract.

The provisions relating to expropriation are reserved.

b. A third person acquiring a limited right in rem

Article 311 – Where, after the conclusion of the contract, a third person acquires a right in rem over the leased property affecting the right of the lessee, the provisions relating to the change of ownership of the leased property shall apply by analogy.

c. Annotation in the land register

Article 312 – In leases of immovables, it may be agreed by contract that the lessee’s right of tenancy be annotated in the land register.

D. Obligations of the lessee

I. Obligation to pay the rent

1. In general

Article 313 – The lessee is obliged to pay the rent.

2. Time of performance

Article 314 – Unless otherwise provided by contract or local custom, the lessee is obliged to pay the rent and, where applicable, the ancillary costs, at the end of each month and at the latest at the expiry of the term of the lease.

3. Default of the lessee

Article 315 – Where the lessee fails to perform the obligation to pay rent or ancillary costs that have fallen due after the delivery of the leased property, the lessor may grant the lessee a period in writing and give notice that he or she will terminate the contract in the event of non-performance within that period as well.

The period to be granted to the lessee shall be at least ten days and, in leases of residential and roofed business premises, at least thirty days. This period shall begin to run from the day following the date on which written notice is given to the lessee.

II. Obligation of careful use and of respect for neighbours

Article 316 – The lessee is obliged to use the leased property with care in accordance with the contract and to show due respect to the persons residing in the immovable in which the leased property is located and to the neighbours.

Where the lessee acts in breach of this obligation, the lessor, in leases of residential and roofed business premises, shall give a written warning granting a period of at least thirty days for the breach to be remedied, failing which he or she will terminate the contract. In other lease relationships, the lessor may terminate the contract immediately by written notice, without giving prior warning to the lessee.

In leases of residential and roofed business premises, where the lessee intentionally causes serious damage to the leased property, where it becomes apparent that granting a period to the lessee would be futile, or where the lessee’s conduct in breach of this obligation is unbearable for the lessor or for the persons residing in the same immovable and the neighbours, the lessor may terminate the contract immediately by written notice.

III. Obligation to pay cleaning and maintenance costs

Article 317 – The lessee is obliged to pay the cleaning and maintenance costs necessary for the ordinary use of the leased property. Local custom shall also be taken into account in this respect.

IV. Obligation to notify the lessor of defects

Article 318 – The lessee is obliged to notify the lessor without delay of defects that he or she is not obliged to remedy; otherwise, he or she shall be liable for the resulting loss.

V. Obligation to tolerate the remedying of defects and the showing of the leased property

Article 319 – The lessee is obliged to tolerate works aimed at remedying defects in the leased property or at preventing losses.

The lessee is obliged, to the extent necessary for maintenance, sale or subsequent letting, to permit the lessor and a third person designated by the lessor to visit and view the leased property.

The lessor is obliged to notify the lessee of the works and of the visits to view the leased property a reasonable time in advance and to take into account the interests of the lessee when these are carried out.

The lessee’s rights relating to the reduction of the rent and compensation for his or her loss are reserved.

E. Special cases

I. Renovations and alterations to the leased property

1. By the lessor

Article 320 – The lessor may make renovations and alterations to the leased property which do not necessitate the termination of the lease contract and which the lessee can be expected to tolerate.

When carrying out these renovations and alterations, the lessor is obliged to have regard to the interests of the lessee. The lessee’s rights relating to the reduction of the rent and compensation for his or her loss are reserved.

2. By the lessee

Article 321 – The lessee may make renovations and alterations to the leased property with the written consent of the lessor.

A lessor who has consented to renovations and alterations may not demand that the leased property be returned in its former condition unless this has been agreed in writing.

Unless there is a written agreement to the contrary, the lessee may not claim compensation for the increase in value of the leased property resulting from the renovations and alterations made by him or her with the lessor’s consent.

II. Sublease and transfer of the right of use

Article 322 – Provided that this does not give rise to a change that would cause harm to the lessor, the lessee may sublet the leased property in whole or in part to another person and may also transfer the right of use to another person.

In leases of residential and roofed business premises, the lessee may neither sublet the leased property to another person nor transfer the right of use without the written consent of the lessor.

Where the sublessee uses the leased property in a manner other than that permitted to the lessee, the lessee shall be liable to the lessor. In this case, the lessor may also exercise against the sublessee, or against the transferee of the right of use, the rights he or she has against his or her lessee.

III. Transfer of the lease relationship 2

Article 323 – The lessee may not transfer the lease relationship to another person without obtaining the written consent of the lessor. In leases of business premises, the lessor may not refuse to give this consent without just cause.

The person to whom the lease relationship has been transferred with the written consent of the lessor shall take the place of the lessee in the lease contract, and the transferring lessee shall be released from his or her obligations towards the lessor.

In leases of business premises, the transferring lessee shall be jointly and severally liable together with the transferee until the expiry of the lease contract, but for a period not exceeding two years.

IV. Non-use of the leased property

1. In general

Article 324 – As long as the leased property is kept fit for use, the lessee is obliged to pay the rent even if the leased property is not used, or is used only to a limited extent, for a reason originating from the lessee himself or herself. In this case, the expenses that the lessor has been spared shall be deducted from the rent.

2. Return of the leased property before the end of the contract

Article 325 – Where the lessee returns the leased property without complying with the term of the contract or the termination period, his or her obligations arising from the lease contract shall continue for a reasonable period within which the leased property could be let on similar terms. Where, before the lapse of this period, the lessee finds a new lessee whom the lessor can be expected to accept, who is solvent and who is prepared to take over the lease relationship, the lessee’s obligations arising from the lease contract shall end.

The lessor is obliged to deduct from the rent the expenses he or she has been spared and the benefits he or she has obtained, or has intentionally refrained from obtaining, by using the leased property in another way.

V. Prohibition of waiver of set-off

Article 326 – The lessee and the lessor may not waive in advance the right to set off their claims arising from the lease contract.

F. Termination of the contract

I. Expiry of the term

Article 327 – Where a term has been fixed expressly or tacitly, the lease contract shall end automatically at the end of this term.

Where, in this case, the parties continue the lease relationship without an express agreement, the lease contract shall become a contract of indefinite term.

II. Notice of termination in lease contracts of indefinite term

1. In general

Article 328 – In lease contracts of indefinite term, each of the parties may terminate the contract by complying with the statutory termination dates and notice periods, unless a longer notice period or another termination date has been agreed. In calculating the termination dates, the commencement date of the lease contract shall be taken as the basis.

Where the termination date or notice period specified in the contract or in the law has not been complied with, the notice shall be valid for the next termination date.

2. In leases of immovables and movable structures

Article 329 – Each of the parties may terminate a lease contract relating to an immovable or a movable structure by complying with a notice period of three months, for the end of the lease period determined by local custom or, in the absence of such custom, for the end of a six-month lease period.

3. In leases of movables

Article 330 – Each of the parties may terminate a lease contract relating to a movable at any time by complying with a notice period of three days.

The lessee of a movable which the lessor lets in the course of his or her professional activity and which serves the private use of the lessee may terminate the lease contract by notice of termination given at least one month in advance for the end of a three-month lease period. In this case, the lessor shall have no right to claim compensation for his or her loss.

III. Extraordinary termination

1. Important reasons

Article 331 – Each of the parties may at any time terminate the contract, by complying with the statutory notice period, where there are important reasons that render the continuation of the lease relationship unbearable for him or her.

The judge shall decide on the pecuniary consequences of the extraordinary notice of termination, taking into account the state of affairs and the circumstances.

2. Bankruptcy of the lessee

Article 332 – Where the lessee becomes bankrupt after the delivery of the leased property, the lessor may demand that security be given for the rent that will accrue.

The lessor shall grant the lessee and the bankruptcy estate, in writing, a reasonable period for the provision of security. If security is not provided to him or her within this period, the lessor may terminate the contract immediately without complying with any notice period.

3. Death of the lessee

Article 333 – In the event of the death of the lessee, his or her heirs may terminate the contract for the end of the nearest termination date by complying with the statutory notice period.

G. Return of the leased property

I. In general

Article 334 – The lessee is obliged, upon the expiry of the lease contract, to return the leased property in the condition in which he or she received it. However, the lessee shall not be liable for wear and deterioration of the leased property resulting from use in accordance with the contract.

Agreements whereby the lessee undertakes in advance to pay, upon termination of the contract, any compensation other than compensation for losses arising from use contrary to the contract shall be invalid.

II. Inspection of the leased property and notification to the lessee

Article 335 – The lessor is obliged, at the time of return, to inspect the condition of the leased property and to notify the lessee immediately in writing of the deficiencies and defects for which the lessee is liable. If this notification is not made, the lessee shall be released from all liability. However, in the case of deficiencies and defects that could not be identified by an ordinary examination at the time of taking delivery, the liability of the lessee shall continue. Where the lessor identifies such deficiencies and defects, he or she is obliged to notify the lessee immediately in writing.

H. Right of retention of the lessor

I. Subject matter

Article 336 – In leases of immovables, the lessor shall have, as security for the rent for one year in arrears and for the current six months, a right of retention over the movables located in the leased property which serve for furnishing or using the leased property.

The lessor’s right of retention shall also cover movables of the same nature brought into the leased property by the sublessee, up to an amount not exceeding the rent owed by the sublessee to the principal lessee.

The right of retention may not be exercised over property of the lessee that is exempt from attachment.

II. Things belonging to third persons

Article 337 – The rights of third persons over things which the lessor knew or should have known did not belong to the lessee, and over things that have been stolen, lost or otherwise removed from the owner’s hands against his or her will, shall take precedence over the lessor’s right of retention.

Where the lessor learns, during the continuance of the lease contract, that movables brought into the leased property by the lessee are not owned by the lessee, and nevertheless does not terminate the contract for the end of the nearest termination date, he or she shall lose the right of retention over those things.

III. Exercise of the right

Article 338 – Where the lessee wishes to move out or to remove the movables located in the leased property to another place, the lessor may, by decision of the judge of the civil court of peace or of the enforcement director, retain such quantity of movables as will ensure that his or her claim is secured.

Where things that are the subject of the retention decision are removed secretly or by force, they shall be brought back to the leased property with the assistance of the law enforcement forces within ten days from their removal.

SECTION TWO

Leases of Residential and Roofed Business Premises

A. Scope of application

Article 339 – The provisions relating to leases of residential and roofed business premises shall also apply to things whose use is left to the lessee together with such premises. However, these provisions shall not apply to the leasing, for six months or less, of immovables that by their nature are designated for temporary use.

These provisions shall also apply to all lease contracts made by public institutions and organisations, whatever the procedures and principles under which they are made.

B. Connected contract

Article 340 – In leases of residential and roofed business premises, where the conclusion or continuation of the contract is made conditional upon the lessee, without benefit to himself or herself, entering into an obligation having no direct connection with the use of the leased property, the contract connected with the lease shall be invalid.

C. Costs of use

Article 341 – In leases of residential and roofed business premises, unless otherwise provided in the contract or unless there is a local custom to the contrary, the lessee is obliged to bear the costs of use such as heating, lighting and water.

The party bearing the costs is obliged, upon request, to provide the other party with a copy of each of the documents evidencing those costs.

D. Provision of security by the lessee

Article 342 – In leases of residential and roofed business premises, where an obligation to provide security has been imposed on the lessee by contract, this security may not exceed three months’ rent.

Where it has been agreed that money or negotiable instruments are to be given as security, the lessee shall deposit the money in a time savings account, and the negotiable instruments with a bank, not to be withdrawn without the approval of the lessor. The bank may return the securities only with the consent of both parties, upon the enforcement proceedings becoming final, or on the basis of a final court judgment.

Where the lessor has not notified the bank in writing, within three months following the termination of the lease contract, that he or she has brought an action against the lessee relating to the lease contract or has initiated proceedings by way of enforcement or bankruptcy, the bank is obliged to return the security upon the request of the lessee.

E. Rent

I. In general

Article 343 – No change may be made to lease contracts to the detriment of the lessee, except for the determination of the rent.

II. Determination34

Article 344 – Agreements of the parties concerning the rent to be applied in renewed lease periods shall be valid provided that they do not exceed the rate of change in the twelve-month averages of the consumer price index in the previous lease year. This rule shall also apply to lease contracts with a term longer than one year.

Where the parties have not made an agreement on this matter, the rent shall be determined by the judge in accordance with equity, taking into account the condition of the leased property, provided that it does not exceed the rate of change in the twelve-month averages of the consumer price index of the previous lease year.

Irrespective of whether or not the parties have made an agreement on this matter, in lease contracts with a term longer than five years or renewed after five years, and at the end of every five years thereafter, the rent to be applied in the new lease year shall be determined by the judge in an equitable manner, taking into account the rate of change in the twelve-month averages of the consumer price index, the condition of the leased property and comparable rents. The rent thus determined for the lease year following every five years may be changed in accordance with the principles set out in the preceding paragraphs.

Where the rent has been agreed in the contract in foreign currency, without prejudice to the provisions of the Law No. 1567 on the Protection of the Value of the Turkish Currency dated 20/2/1930, no change may be made to the rent until five years have elapsed. However, the provision of Article 138 of this Law, entitled “Excessive difficulty of performance”, is reserved. In determining the rent after five years have elapsed, the provision of the third paragraph shall be applied, taking into account also the changes in the value of the foreign currency.

III. Period for bringing an action and effect of the judgment

Article 345 – An action for the determination of the rent may be brought at any time.

However, where this action is brought at a date at least thirty days before the beginning of the new period, or, provided that the lessor has given written notice to the lessee within this period that the rent will be increased, where it is brought by the end of the following new lease period, the rent to be determined by the court shall bind the lessee from the beginning of this new lease period.

Where the contract contains a provision that the rent will be increased in the new lease period, the rent to be determined by the court in an action brought by the end of the new lease period shall also be effective from the beginning of this new period.

IV. Prohibition of arrangements to the detriment of the lessee

Article 346 – No payment obligation other than the rent and ancillary costs may be imposed on the lessee. In particular, agreements providing that a contractual penalty shall be payable or that subsequent rents shall fall due in the event that the rent is not paid on time shall be invalid.

F. Termination of the contract in leases of residential and roofed business premises

I. By notice

1. In general

Article 347 – In leases of residential and roofed business premises, unless the lessee gives notice at least fifteen days before the expiry of the term of a fixed-term contract, the contract shall be deemed extended for one year on the same terms. The lessor may not terminate the contract on the ground of the expiry of the contractual term. However, at the end of a ten-year extension period, the lessor may terminate the contract without giving any reason, provided that he or she gives notice at least three months before the end of each extension year following this period.

In lease contracts of indefinite term, the lessee may terminate the contract at any time, and the lessor after ten years have elapsed from the commencement of the lease, by notice of termination in accordance with the general provisions.

In cases where the right of termination may be exercised in accordance with the general provisions, the lessor or the lessee may terminate the contract.

2. Validity of the notice

a. Form

Article 348 – In leases of residential and roofed business premises, the validity of a notice of termination is subject to its being made in writing.

b. Family residence

Article 349 – In respect of immovables leased for use as a family residence, the lessee may not terminate the lease contract without the express consent of his or her spouse.

If it is not possible to obtain such consent, or if the spouse refuses to give consent without just cause, the lessee may request the judge to render a decision on the matter.

Where the spouse who is not the lessee acquires the capacity of party to the lease contract by giving notice to the lessor, the lessor is obliged to send the notice of termination and the period for payment attached to the warning of termination separately to the lessee and to his or her spouse.

II. By way of action

1. On grounds arising from the lessor

a. Need, reconstruction and redevelopment

Article 350 – The lessor may bring the lease contract to an end,

1. If he or she is compelled to use the leased property, owing to a need for a residence or business premises, for himself or herself, his or her spouse, descendants, ascendants or other persons whom he or she is obliged by law to maintain,

2. If substantial repair, extension or alteration of the leased property is necessary for the purpose of its reconstruction or redevelopment and the use of the leased property is impossible during such works,

by an action to be brought within one month starting from the date to be determined, in contracts for a fixed term, as the end of the term and, in contracts for an indefinite term, in compliance with the termination period and the notice periods prescribed for notice of termination under the general provisions on leases.

b. Need of the new owner

Article 351 – A person who subsequently acquires the leased property may, if he or she is compelled to use it, owing to a need for a residence or business premises, for himself or herself, his or her spouse, descendants, ascendants or other persons whom he or she is obliged by law to maintain, bring the lease contract to an end by an action to be brought after six months, on condition that he or she notifies the lessee of the situation in writing within one month starting from the date of acquisition.

A person who subsequently acquires the leased property may, if he or she so wishes, also exercise the right to bring the contract to an end on grounds of need by way of an action to be brought within one month starting from the expiry of the term of the contract.

2. On grounds arising from the lessee

Article 352 – If the lessee, after the delivery of the leased property, has undertaken in writing towards the lessor to vacate the leased property on a certain date but has not vacated it, the lessor may bring the lease contract to an end, within one month starting from that date, by applying for enforcement proceedings or by bringing an action.

If the lessee, in lease contracts for a term of less than one year, within the term of the lease, and in lease contracts for a term of one year or longer, within one lease year or within a period exceeding one lease year, has caused two justified written warnings to be served on him or her for failure to pay the rent, the lessor may bring the lease contract to an end by way of action within one month starting from the expiry of the term of the lease and, in leases for a term longer than one year, from the end of the lease year in which the warnings were served.

Where the lessee or his or her spouse living with him or her has a dwelling suitable for habitation within the municipal boundaries of the same district or township, the lessor may, if he or she was not aware of this at the time of the conclusion of the lease contract, bring the contract to an end by way of action within one month starting from the expiry of the contract.

3. Extension of the period for bringing an action

Article 353 – If the lessor has notified the lessee in writing, at the latest within the period prescribed for bringing the action, that he or she will bring an action, the period for bringing the action shall be deemed extended by one lease year.

4. Limited nature of the grounds for action

Article 354 – The provisions concerning the bringing to an end of the lease contract by way of action may not be altered to the detriment of the lessee.

5. Prohibition on re-letting

Article 355 – Where the lessor has caused the leased property to be vacated on grounds of need, he or she may not, without just cause, let the leased property to anyone other than the former lessee until three years have elapsed.

Immovables caused to be vacated for the purpose of reconstruction and redevelopment may not, without just cause, be let to another person in their former state until three years have elapsed. The former lessee has a right of priority to lease the immovables whose reconstruction and redevelopment has been carried out, in their new state and at the new rent. This right must be exercised within one month following the written notice to be given by the lessor; unless this right of priority has been extinguished, the immovable may not be let to another person before three years have elapsed.

If the lessor acts contrary to these provisions, he or she is obliged to pay compensation to the former lessee in an amount not less than one year’s rent paid in the last lease year.

6. Continuation of the contract on the death of the lessee

Article 356 – The partners of the deceased lessee or those heirs of such partners who carry on the same profession or trade, and those who lived in the same dwelling together with the deceased lessee, may continue the lease contract as parties, provided that they comply with the contract and the provisions of law.

SECTION THREE

Usufructuary Lease

A. Definition

Article 357 – A usufructuary lease is a contract whereby the lessor undertakes to leave to the lessee, against consideration, the use of a fruit-bearing thing or right and the gathering of its fruits.

A share-cropping lease is a usufructuary lease in which the rent is agreed as a certain proportion of the fruits to be gathered. If this proportion has not been agreed upon by contract, it shall be determined according to local custom.

B. Application of the general provisions

Article 358 – Unless there is a special provision in this Section concerning usufructuary leases, the general provisions concerning the lease contract shall apply.

C. Drawing up of an inventory

Article 359 – If the lease contract also includes tools and equipment, animals, transferred chattels or stocked goods, the parties are obliged jointly to assess their values, record them in an inventory to be drawn up in two counterparts, sign it and deliver it to each other.

D. Obligations of the lessor

I. Obligation of delivery

Article 360 – The lessor is obliged to deliver to the lessee the leased property, including any movable things leased together with it, in a condition suitable for use and operation in accordance with the purpose of the contract, and to maintain it in that condition for the duration of the contract.

II. Substantial repairs

Article 361 – The lessor is obliged to carry out at his or her own expense, as soon as notified by the lessee, the substantial repairs that must necessarily be made during the term of the lease.

E. Obligations of the lessee

I. Obligation to pay the rent and ancillary costs

1. In general

Article 362 – Unless there is a provision to the contrary in the contract or a local custom, the lessee is obliged to pay the rent and ancillary costs at the end of each lease year and at the latest at the end of the term of the lease.

If the lessee fails to pay the rent or ancillary costs that have fallen due after the delivery of the leased property, the lessor may grant the lessee in writing a time limit of at least sixty days and notify him or her that, if payment is not made within this time limit, the contract will be terminated.

2. Reduction of rent in extraordinary circumstances

Article 363 – If the usual yield of an agricultural immovable decreases considerably as a result of an extraordinary disaster or natural events, the lessee may request that a proportionate amount be deducted from the rent.

A waiver of this right in advance shall be valid only if the possibility of such circumstances occurring was taken into account when the rent was determined or if the damage arising is covered by insurance.

II. Obligation to use and operate the leased property

Article 364 – The lessee is obliged to operate the leased property properly and in accordance with the purpose for which it is designated, and in particular to maintain it in a condition suitable for bearing fruit.

The lessee may not, without the permission of the lessor, change the mode of operation of the leased property in a manner whose effect may be felt after the expiry of the term of the lease.

III. Obligation of maintenance

Article 365 – The lessee is obliged to ensure the proper maintenance of the leased property.

The lessee is obliged, in accordance with local custom, to carry out minor repairs and to replace tools and equipment of low value that have broken down or been used up through use.

F. Prohibition of sub-lease and transfer of the right of use

Article 366 – The lessee may neither let the leased property to another person nor transfer the right of use and operation to another person without the consent of the lessor. However, the lessee may let certain premises located in the leased property, provided that this does not require a change that would cause damage to the lessor.

The rules concerning sub-lease shall apply by analogy to such lease contracts concluded by the lessee with another person.

G. Termination of the contract

I. Grounds for termination

1. Expiry of the term

Article 367 – A lease contract for a fixed term ends automatically on the expiry of the term.

However, where the parties tacitly continue the contract, the lease contract shall, unless otherwise agreed, be deemed renewed for successive periods of one year.

The renewed lease contract may be terminated for the end of each lease year by observing the statutory notice period.

2. Notice of termination

Article 368 – In a contract for an indefinite term, if the notice period for termination has not been determined by the contract or by local custom, each of the parties may terminate the contract, provided that a notice period of at least six months is observed.

Unless otherwise agreed, notice of termination may be given, in usufructuary leases of agricultural immovables, for the spring or autumn seasons applied by local custom and, in other usufructuary leases, for any time.

3. Extraordinary termination

a. Important grounds

Article 369 – Where there are important grounds rendering the continuation of the lease relationship intolerable for him or her, either party may terminate the contract at any time by observing the statutory notice period for termination.

The judge shall decide on the pecuniary consequences of the extraordinary notice of termination, taking into account the circumstances and conditions.

b. Bankruptcy of the lessee

Article 370 – In the event of the bankruptcy of the lessee, the contract ends automatically at the moment the bankruptcy is opened. However, the lessor is obliged to continue the contract until the end of the lease year if adequate security is provided for the current rent and for the chattels recorded in the inventory.

c. Death of the lessee

Article 371 – In the event of the death of the lessee, his or her heirs and the lessor may terminate the contract, provided that they observe the statutory notice periods for termination of six months.

II. Consequences of termination

1. Return

Article 372 – On the expiry of the term of the lease, the lessee is obliged to return the leased property, together with all the chattels recorded in the inventory, in the condition in which they are.

The lessee is obliged to pay compensation for decreases in value that could have been avoided by proper operation.

The lessee may not claim compensation for increases in value that have arisen within the scope of the care he or she is obliged to exercise in respect of the leased property.

2. Chattels recorded in the inventory

Article 373 – If a value was placed on the chattels recorded in the inventory when the leased property was delivered, the lessee is obliged, on the termination of the lease contract, to return them in identical kind and value or to make good the decreases in value.

The lessee may be released from the obligation to return them or to pay compensation by proving the fault of the lessor or the existence of force majeure.

The lessee may claim compensation for an increase in value arising from expenses incurred or labour performed by him or her.

3. Fruits and cultivation costs

Article 374 – The lessee of an agricultural immovable may not assert any right over fruits not yet gathered at the moment the lease contract ends.

However, the lessee may claim from the lessor, as compensation, the amount, to be determined by the judge, of the agricultural costs he or she has incurred for the growing of the fruits, and this compensation shall be deducted from the accrued rents.

4. Straw, manure and the like

Article 375 – The lessee returning the leased property is obliged to leave on the leased property the straw, animal litter, hay and manure of the last year, in the proportion required by orderly operation.

If the lessee leaves more than he or she received, he or she has the right to claim compensation for the surplus left; if he or she leaves less than he or she received, he or she is obliged to make up the shortfall or to make good the decrease in value.

H. Lease of livestock

I. Subject matter

Article 376 – In the lease of ruminant animals not connected with the lease of an agricultural immovable, unless otherwise agreed or unless there is a local custom to the contrary, all the produce of the leased animals during the term of the lease belongs to the lessee.

The lessee is obliged to feed the leased animals, to take good care of them and to pay the lessor money or a certain share of the produce obtained from the animals.

II. Liability

Article 377 – Unless otherwise agreed or unless there is a local custom to the contrary, the lessee is liable for any damage suffered by the leased animals unless he or she proves that such damage occurred despite care and diligence having been exercised in their safekeeping.

The lessee may claim compensation from the lessor for extraordinary costs of safekeeping that he or she did not cause through his or her own fault.

The lessee is obliged to notify the lessor without delay of serious accidents or illnesses.

III. Termination

Article 378 – Unless otherwise agreed or unless there is a local custom to the contrary, each of the parties may terminate a contract concluded for an indefinite term at any time he or she wishes.

However, termination may not be made contrary to the rules of good faith or at an inappropriate time.

CHAPTER FIVE

Loan Contracts

SECTION ONE

Loan for Use

A. Definition

Article 379 – A loan for use contract is a contract whereby the lender undertakes to leave to the borrower the use of a thing free of charge, and the borrower undertakes to return that thing after having used it.

B. Effects

I. Borrower’s right of use

Article 380 – The borrower may use the object of the loan only in the manner agreed in the contract or, if there is no provision in the contract, according to its nature or the purpose for which it is designated.

The borrower may not allow another person to use the object of the loan.

Where the borrower acts contrary to these provisions, he or she is also liable for damage arising from accidental events. However, he or she shall be released from liability if he or she proves that the damage would have occurred even if he or she had complied with these provisions.

II. Costs of maintenance and safekeeping

Article 381 – The borrower is obliged to bear the ordinary costs of maintenance and safekeeping of the object of the loan.

The borrower may request reimbursement of extraordinary expenses that he or she was compelled to incur in the interest of the lender.

III. Joint and several liability

Article 382 – Persons who have borrowed a thing jointly are jointly and severally liable for it.

C. Termination

I. Use for a determined purpose

Article 383 – If no specific period has been provided for the use, the contract ends when the borrower has used the object of the loan in accordance with the contract or when a period of time sufficient for such use has elapsed.

If the borrower uses the object of the loan contrary to the contract, damages it or gives it to another person for use, or if an urgent need of the lender arises owing to a circumstance not previously known, the lender may demand the return of the thing earlier.

II. Use for an undetermined purpose

Article 384 – If the object of the loan has been given without determining the period of use and the purpose for which it is to be used, the lender may demand its return at any time he or she wishes.

III. Death of the borrower

Article 385 – The loan for use contract ends automatically on the death of the borrower.

SECTION TWO

Loan for Consumption

A. Definition

Article 386 – A loan for consumption contract is a contract whereby the lender undertakes to transfer to the borrower a sum of money or a consumable thing, and the borrower undertakes to return a thing of the same kind and quantity.

B. Effects

I. Interest

1. In general

Article 387 – In a non-commercial loan for consumption contract, interest may not be claimed unless it has been agreed upon by the parties.

In a commercial loan for consumption contract, interest may be claimed even if it has not been agreed upon by the parties.

2. Special rules on interest

Article 388 – If the rate of interest has not been determined in the loan for consumption contract, the rate of interest applicable to loans of that kind at the time and place of the loan shall, as a rule, apply.

Unless there is a provision to the contrary in the contract, the interest determined shall be paid annually.

It may not be agreed that interest shall be added to the principal and that interest shall again run on them together.

II. Limitation

Article 389 – The claims of the borrower for delivery of the object of the loan and of the lender for acceptance of delivery of that thing become time-barred on the expiry of six months starting from the other party’s default in that respect.

III. Insolvency of the borrower

Article 390 – If the borrower becomes insolvent after the conclusion of the loan contract, the lender may refuse to deliver the object of the loan.

The lender has the same right if he or she learns subsequently that the borrower had become insolvent before the conclusion of the contract.

C. Things given in place of money

Article 391 – If negotiable instruments or commercial goods are given to the borrower in place of the money agreed in the contract, the amount of the debt shall be calculated on the basis of their stock exchange or market value at the time and place of delivery; any agreement to the contrary is invalid.

D. Time of return

Article 392 – If no specific day or notice period has been agreed for the return of the loan, nor has it been agreed that the debt shall fall due at the moment its return is demanded, the borrower is not obliged to return the loan until six weeks have elapsed starting from the first demand.

CHAPTER SIX

Employment Contracts

SECTION ONE

General Employment Contract

A. Definition

Article 393 – An employment contract is a contract whereby the employee undertakes to perform work in dependence on the employer for a fixed or an indefinite period, and the employer undertakes to pay him or her a wage calculated according to time or to the work performed.

Contracts whereby the employee undertakes to perform a service regularly for the employer on a part-time basis are also employment contracts.

The provisions concerning the general employment contract shall also apply by analogy to the apprenticeship contract; the provisions of special laws are reserved.

B. Formation

Article 394 – Unless there is a provision to the contrary in the law, the employment contract is not subject to any special form.

If a person performs work for a certain period which, according to the circumstances, can only be performed against a wage, and this work is accepted by the employer, an employment contract shall be deemed to have been concluded between them.

An employment contract whose invalidity is subsequently discovered produces all the effects and consequences of a valid employment contract until the employment relationship is terminated.

C. Obligations of the employee

I. Obligation to work in person

Article 395 – Unless otherwise understood from the contract or the requirements of the situation, the employee is obliged to perform in person the work he or she has undertaken.

II. Obligation of diligence and loyalty

Article 396 – The employee is obliged to perform the work he or she has undertaken with diligence and to act loyally in safeguarding the legitimate interests of the employer.

The employee is obliged to use the machinery, tools and equipment, technical systems, installations and vehicles belonging to the employer properly and to treat with care the materials entrusted to him or her for the performance of the work together with them.

For as long as the employment relationship continues, the employee may not, in breach of the duty of loyalty, perform services for a third party against remuneration and, in particular, may not enter into competition with his or her own employer.

The employee may not, for the duration of the employment relationship, use for his or her own benefit or disclose to others information learned in the course of his or her work, in particular such information as production and business secrets. To the extent necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the employer, the employee is obliged to maintain confidentiality also after the termination of the employment relationship.

III. Obligation to hand over and to render account

Article 397 – The employee is obliged to hand over to the employer immediately the things, and in particular the money, received from third parties for the employer in the course of performing the work undertaken, and to render account in respect of them.

The employee is also obliged to hand over to the employer immediately the things he or she has obtained as a result of the performance of the service.

IV. Obligation to work overtime

Article 398 – Overtime is work performed in excess of the normal working time determined in the relevant laws and with the consent of the employee. However, if it becomes necessary to perform work requiring more than the normal working time, the employee is in a position to do so and, at the same time, his or her refusal would be contrary to the rules of good faith, the employee is obliged to perform the overtime, provided that remuneration is given for it.

The provisions of special laws are reserved.

V. Obligation to comply with rules and instructions

Article 399 – The employer may lay down general rules concerning the performance of the work and the conduct of employees at the workplace and may give them specific instructions. Employees are obliged to comply with these to the extent required by the rules of good faith.

VI. Liability of the employee

Article 400 – The employee is liable for any kind of damage he or she causes to the employer through his or her fault.

In determining this liability, account shall be taken of whether the work is dangerous or not, whether it requires expertise and training or not, and of the abilities and qualities of the employee known or which ought to have been known by the employer.

D. Obligations of the employer

I. Obligation to pay the wage

1. Wage

a. In general

Article 401 – The employer is obliged to pay the employee the wage determined in the contract or in the collective labour agreement or, in cases where there is no provision in the contract, the customary wage, which shall not be less than the minimum wage.

b. Overtime pay

Article 402 – The employer is obliged to pay the employee for overtime the normal wage increased by at least fifty per cent.

The employer may, with the consent of the employee, instead of paying overtime pay, grant leave at an appropriate time in proportion to the overtime worked.

c. Share in the results of the work

Article 403 – If it has been agreed by contract that, together with the wage, the employee shall be given a certain share of the production, the turnover or the profit, this share shall be determined at the end of the accounting period, taking into account the statutory provisions or generally accepted commercial principles.

In cases where it has been agreed that the employee shall be given a certain share, if no agreement can be reached on the calculation of the share, the employer is obliged to provide information to the employee or, in his or her place, to an expert jointly agreed upon by them or appointed by the judge, and to make available for inspection the books and documents of the enterprise forming the basis of that information; if it has been agreed that a share of the profit shall be given, the employer is obliged, in addition, to give the employee, at his or her request, the year-end profit and loss statement.

d. Commission

Article 404 – If it has been agreed that the employer shall pay the employee remuneration in return for acting as an intermediary in certain transactions, the employee’s claim arises upon the valid conclusion with the third party of the transaction for which he or she acted as intermediary.

In contracts in which obligations are to be performed in instalments and in insurance contracts, it may be agreed in writing that the claim to remuneration in respect of each instalment shall arise when the obligation relating to that instalment falls due or is performed.

If the contract concluded between the employer and a third party through the intermediation of the employee is not performed by the employer without fault on his or her part, or if the third party does not perform his or her obligations, the right to claim remuneration lapses. In the case of partial performance only, the remuneration shall be reduced proportionately.

If the employee has not been obliged by contract to keep the account of the commission payable to him or her, the employer is obliged to provide the employee, for each period in which the remuneration falls due, with a written statement of account including the transactions subject to such remuneration.

If the need arises to examine the account, the employer is obliged to provide information to the employee or, in his or her place, to an expert jointly agreed upon by them or appointed by the judge, and to make available for his or her inspection the books and documents of the enterprise forming the basis of that information.

e. Bonus

Article 405 – The employer may give his or her employees a special bonus on the occasion of certain days such as religious holidays, New Year and birthdays. However, the employees’ right to claim the bonus arises if there is an agreement or a working condition to that effect or a unilateral undertaking by the employer.

If the employment contract ended before the period in which the bonus is given, the portion of the bonus corresponding to the period worked shall be paid.

2. Payment of the wage

a. Time of payment

Article 406 – Unless there is a custom to the contrary, the employee’s wage shall be paid at the end of each month. However, shorter payment periods may be determined by the employment contract or the collective labour agreement.

If no shorter payment period has been agreed or there is no custom to the contrary, commission shall be paid at the end of each month. However, if the execution of the transactions requires a period longer than six months, payment may be deferred to a later date by written agreement, where the commission has been agreed in addition to the basic wage.

In cases where it is provided that a share of the production shall be given in addition to the basic wage, the share must be determined and paid as soon as the share of production is determined and, in cases where it has been agreed that a share of the turnover or profit shall be given, at the latest within three months following the accounting period.

The employer is obliged, if the employee is in urgent need and if the employer is in a position to pay as equity requires, to grant the employee an advance in proportion to the service performed.

b. Protection of the wage

Article 407 – The President is authorised to oblige employers to pay, by depositing them into specially opened bank accounts, the wages, premiums, bonuses and all kinds of entitlements of this nature of the employees they employ which are paid within that month, taking into account the type of tax liability to which they are subject, the size of the enterprise, the number of employees they employ, the province in which the workplace is located and similar factors, and to determine whether the wages, premiums, bonuses and all kinds of entitlements of this nature to be deposited into the bank account shall be based on the gross amount or on the net amount remaining after statutory deductions. Employers made subject to the obligation to pay the wages, premiums, bonuses and all kinds of entitlements of this nature of the employees they employ through specially opened bank accounts may not pay the wages, premiums, bonuses and all kinds of entitlements of this nature of their employees other than through specially opened bank accounts. A pay slip shall be given to the employee in each payment period. Other procedures and principles concerning the payment of the wages, premiums, bonuses and all kinds of entitlements of this nature of employees by depositing them into specially opened bank accounts shall be regulated by a regulation to be issued jointly by the said ministries.5

The employer may not, without the consent of the employee, set off his or her receivables from the employee against the wage debt. However, receivables arising from damage established by a judicial decision and intentionally caused by the employee may be set off up to the amount of the attachable portion of the wage.

Agreements providing that the wage shall be used in favour of the employer are invalid.

3. Wage where performance of the work is prevented

a. In the event of the employer’s default

Article 408 – If the employer, through his or her fault, prevents the performance of the work or falls into default in accepting the performance, he or she is obliged to pay the employee his or her wage and may not require the employee to perform such work subsequently. However, the expenses the employee has saved as a result of such prevention and the benefits he or she has earned by doing other work or has deliberately refrained from earning shall be deducted from his or her wage.

b. In the event of the employee’s stoppage of work

Article 409 – In a long-term employment relationship, if the employee is unable, without fault on his or her part, to perform the work for a short period in proportion to the period he or she has worked, for reasons such as illness, military service or work arising from the law and similar reasons, the employer is obliged to pay the employee an equitable wage for that period, unless this is covered in another way.

4. Attachment, assignment and pledge of the wage claim

Article 410 – More than one quarter of the wage of employees may not be attached, assigned to another person or pledged. However, the amount to be assessed by the judge for the family members whom the employee is obliged to maintain is not included in this proportion. The rights of maintenance creditors are reserved.

The assignment or pledging of future wage claims is invalid.

5. Piecework or lump-sum work

a. Provision of work

Article 411 – If the employee has undertaken under the contract to perform only piecework or lump-sum work exclusively for one employer, the employer is obliged to provide him or her with sufficient work.

If the employer is, without fault on his or her part, unable to provide the piecework or lump-sum work provided for in the contract, or if the operating conditions temporarily so require, the employer shall pay the employee his or her wage on a time basis. In that case, if the wage payable on a time basis has not been determined in the agreement or in the employment contract or collective labour agreement, the employer is obliged to pay the employee a wage equivalent to the average wage he or she previously received on a piecework or lump-sum basis.

An employer who is unable to provide piecework, lump-sum or time-based work is obliged to pay at least the wage he or she would pay for time-based work in accordance with the provisions on default in accepting the performance of work.

b. Unit wage

Article 412 – If the employee has undertaken under the contract to work on a piecework or lump-sum basis, the employer is obliged to notify him or her, before the start of each job, of the unit wage to be paid to him or her.

An employer who fails to give such notice is obliged to pay the unit wage determined for the same or a similar job.

II. Tools and materials of work

Article 413 – Unless otherwise agreed or unless there is a local custom to the contrary, the employer is obliged to provide the employee with the tools and materials necessary for the work.

If the employee, in agreement with the employer, devotes his or her own tools or materials to the performance of the work, the employer is obliged, unless otherwise agreed or unless there is a local custom, to pay the employee appropriate compensation for this.

III. Expenses

1. In general

Article 414 – The employer is obliged to pay all kinds of expenditure required by the performance of the work and, where he or she employs the employee outside the workplace, also the expenditure necessary for his or her subsistence.

In a written employment contract or collective labour agreement, it may be provided that expenditure agreed to be borne by the employee personally shall be paid to the employee as a lump sum on a daily, weekly or monthly basis. However, this payment may not be less than the amount sufficient to cover the necessary expenditure.

Agreements providing that the necessary expenditure shall be borne partially or entirely by the employee personally are invalid.

2. Means of transport

Article 415 – If the employee, in agreement with the employer, uses a means of transport provided by the employer or by himself or herself for the performance of the work, the ordinary costs necessary for the operation and maintenance of the vehicle shall be borne by the employer to the extent that it is used for the service.

If the employee, in agreement with the employer, uses his or her own motor vehicle in the performance of the work, the employer is obliged, in addition, to pay the employee the tax relating to that vehicle, the premium for compulsory financial liability insurance and appropriate compensation for the wear and tear of the vehicle, to the extent that it is used for the service.

If the employee, in agreement with the employer, uses other means of transport and animals belonging to him or her in the performance of the service, the employer is obliged to bear the ordinary costs necessary for their use and maintenance to the extent that they are used for the service.

3. Payment of expenses

Article 416 – Unless a shorter period has been agreed or there is a local custom, the employee’s claim arising from the expenses he or she has incurred shall be paid on each occasion together with the wage.

If the employee regularly incurs expenses in order to perform his or her obligations arising from the contract, he or she shall be given an appropriate advance at regular intervals, at least once a month.

IV. Protection of the employee’s personality

1. In general

Article 417 – The employer is obliged to protect and respect the personality of the employee in the employment relationship and to ensure order at the workplace in accordance with the principles of good faith, and in particular to take the necessary measures so that employees are not subjected to psychological and sexual harassment and so that those who have been subjected to such harassment do not suffer further harm.

The employer is obliged to take all kinds of measures necessary to ensure occupational health and safety at the workplace and to keep the tools and equipment complete; employees are likewise obliged to comply with all kinds of measures taken in respect of occupational health and safety.

Compensation for damage connected with the death of the employee, injury to his or her bodily integrity or violation of his or her personal rights by reason of the employer’s conduct contrary to the law and the contract, including the provisions above, is subject to the provisions on liability arising from breach of contract.

2. In work within the household

Article 418 – If the employee lives together with the employer within the household, the employer is obliged to provide adequate food and appropriate accommodation.

If the employee is unable, without fault on his or her part, to perform the work for reasons such as illness or accident, the employer is obliged to provide for two weeks the care and treatment of an employee who has worked for up to one year and who cannot benefit from social insurance benefits. For each year of service of the employee exceeding one year, this period shall be increased by two days, not exceeding four weeks.

The employer is obliged to provide the same performances also in the event of the employee’s pregnancy and giving birth.

3. In the use of personal data

Article 419 – The employer may use personal data relating to the employee only to the extent that they relate to the employee’s suitability for the work or are necessary for the performance of the employment contract.

The provisions of special laws are reserved.

V. Penalty clause and release

Article 420 – A penalty clause stipulated in employment contracts solely to the detriment of the employee is invalid.

A release contract concerning the employee’s receivables from the employer must be in writing; at least one month must have elapsed, as at the date of release, starting from the termination of the contract; the type and amount of the receivable subject to the release must be clearly stated; and payment must be made in full in relation to the amount of the entitlement and through a bank. Release contracts or deeds of release not containing these elements are absolutely null and void.

Release contracts not stating that the entitlement has been paid in its actual amount, or other payment documents containing a declaration of release, shall have the effect of a receipt limited to the amount they contain. Even in this case, it is mandatory that the payments have been made through a bank.

The provisions of the second and third paragraphs also apply to all claims for compensation arising from the employment contract, including those which persons deprived of support and other relatives of the employee may claim.

VI. Rest days and leave

1. Weekly rest day and leave to seek employment

Article 421 – The employer is obliged to grant the employee every week one full working day of rest, as a rule on Sunday or, if the circumstances and conditions do not permit this, on another day.

In the event of termination of an employment contract for an indefinite term, the employer is obliged to grant the employee, during the notice period, leave to seek employment of two hours a day without any deduction from his or her wage.

In determining the hours and days of leave, the legitimate interests of the workplace and of the employee shall be taken into account.

2. Annual leave

a. Duration

Article 422 – The employer is obliged to grant paid annual leave of at least two weeks a year to employees who have worked for at least one year, and of at least three weeks to employees under the age of eighteen and employees over the age of fifty.

b. Reduction

Article 423 – If the employee, through his or her own fault, fails to perform the service for a total period of more than one month within one year of service, the employer may reduce the duration of paid annual leave by one day for each full month not worked.

If the employee, without fault on his or her part, is unable to perform the work for a maximum period of three months within one year of service for reasons inherent in his or her person, such as illness, accident, or the performance of a statutory obligation or public duty, the employer may not reduce the duration of paid annual leave.

The employer may not reduce the duration of paid annual leave of a female employee who is unable to perform the work for a maximum period of three months by reason of pregnancy and giving birth.

No arrangement contrary to the provisions of the second and third paragraphs may be made by employment contracts or collective labour agreements in a manner producing effects to the detriment of the employee.

c. Use

Article 424 – Paid annual leave shall, as a rule, be granted without interruption; however, it may also be used divided into two parts by agreement of the parties.

The employer shall determine the dates of paid annual leave taking into account the wishes of the employee, to the extent compatible with the interests of the workplace or of the household.

d. Pay

Article 425 – The employer is obliged to pay in advance, or to give as an advance, to each employee using his or her paid annual leave the wage for the duration of the paid annual leave before the employee concerned starts the leave.

For as long as the employment relationship continues, the employee may not waive his or her right to paid annual leave in return for money or other benefits to be received from the employer.

In the event of the termination of the employment contract for any reason, the wage for the periods of annual leave to which the employee became entitled but which he or she was unable to use shall be paid to him or her or to the persons entitled, on the basis of his or her wage on the date of the termination of the contract. The limitation period for this wage starts to run on the date of the termination of the employment contract.

VII. Certificate of service

Article 426 – The employer is obliged, at the request of the employee, to issue at any time a certificate of service stating the type and duration of the work.

If the employee expressly so requests, the certificate of service shall also state his or her skill in the performance of the work as well as his or her attitude and conduct.

An employee who suffers damage because the certificate of service was not issued in time or because the certificate contains incorrect information, or a new employer who recruits the employee, may claim compensation from the former employer.

E. Industrial and intellectual property rights

Article 427 – The provisions of special laws shall apply to the rights of the employee and of the employer in respect of service inventions, their acquisition and other industrial and intellectual property rights.

F. Transfer of the employment relationship

I. Transfer of the whole or part of the workplace

Article 428 – Where the whole or part of a workplace is transferred to another person by a legal transaction, the employment contracts existing at the workplace or in that part of it on the date of the transfer pass to the transferee together with all rights and obligations.

With respect to the employee’s rights depending on length of service, the date on which he or she started work with the transferring employer shall be taken as the basis.

In the case of a transfer in accordance with the above provisions, the transferring and the transferee employers are jointly and severally liable for the debts that arose before the transfer and that are payable on the date of the transfer. However, the liability of the transferring employer arising from these obligations is limited to two years from the date of the transfer.

II. Transfer of the contract

Article 429 – The employment contract may be transferred permanently to another employer only with the written consent of the employee.

By the transfer, the transferee becomes the employer party to the employment contract together with all rights and obligations. In this case, with respect to the employee’s rights depending on length of service, the date on which he or she started work with the transferring employer shall be taken as the basis.

G. Termination of the contract

I. In a contract for a fixed term

Article 430 – Unless otherwise agreed, an employment contract for a fixed term ends automatically on the expiry of the term without any need for a notice of termination.

If a contract for a fixed term is tacitly continued after the expiry of its term, it is converted into a contract for an indefinite term. However, where there is an essential reason, successive employment contracts for a fixed term may be concluded.

Either party may terminate an employment contract concluded for a term of more than ten years after ten years have elapsed, by observing a notice period of six months. The termination takes effect only at the beginning of the month following this period.

If it has been agreed that the contract shall end by notice of termination and neither party has given notice of termination, the contract is converted into a contract for an indefinite term.

II. In a contract for an indefinite term

1. Right of termination in general

Article 431 – Each party has the right to terminate a contract for an indefinite term by observing the notice periods.

2. Notice period

a. In general

Article 432 – Before the termination of employment contracts for an indefinite term, the situation must be notified to the other party.

The employment contract ends, starting from the notice reaching the other party, after two weeks for an employee whose service has lasted up to one year; after four weeks for an employee whose service has lasted from one year to five years; and after six weeks for an employee whose service has lasted more than five years.

These periods may not be shortened; however, they may be increased by contract.

The employer may terminate the employment contract by paying in advance the wage for the notice period.

The notice periods must be the same for both parties; if different periods have been provided for in the contract, the longest notice period shall apply to both parties.

In cases where the employment contract has been suspended, the notice periods do not run.

b. During the probationary period

Article 433 – The parties may stipulate a probationary period in the employment contract, provided that it does not exceed two months. If a probationary period has been stipulated, the parties may terminate the employment contract during this period without compensation, without being obliged to observe the notice period.

The employee’s wage and other rights for the days he or she has worked are reserved.

III. Protection against termination

Article 434 – In cases where the employment contract has been brought to an end through abuse of the right of termination, the employer is obliged to pay the employee compensation amounting to three times the wage for the notice period.

IV. Immediate termination

1. Conditions

a. Just causes

Article 435 – Each party may terminate the contract immediately for just cause. The party terminating the contract is obliged to notify the ground for termination in writing.

All circumstances and conditions in which the party terminating the contract cannot be expected, according to the rules of good faith, to continue the employment relationship shall be deemed just cause.

b. Insolvency of the employer

Article 436 – In the event of the insolvency of the employer, the employee may terminate the contract immediately if the rights arising from the contract are not secured by the employer within an appropriate period.

2. Consequences

a. In termination for just cause

Article 437 – If the just causes for termination have arisen from one party’s failure to comply with the contract, that party is obliged to make good in full the damage he or she has caused, taking into account all the rights based on the employment relationship.

In other cases, the judge shall freely assess the pecuniary consequences of termination for just cause, taking into account all the circumstances and conditions.

b. In termination not based on just cause

Article 438 – If the employer terminates the employment contract immediately without just cause, the employee may claim as compensation the amount he or she could have earned had the notice period, in contracts for an indefinite term, or the term of the contract, in contracts for a fixed term, been observed, where these periods have not been observed.

In an employment contract for a fixed term, the amount the employee has saved by reason of the termination of the employment contract and the income he or she has earned from other work or has deliberately refrained from earning shall be deducted from the compensation.

The judge may, taking into account all the circumstances and conditions, also decide that compensation, the amount of which he or she shall freely determine, be paid to the employee; however, the amount of compensation to be determined may not exceed six months’ wages of the employee.

c. Unjustified failure of the employee to take up work or abandonment of work

Article 439 – If the employee fails to take up work or suddenly abandons work without just cause, the employer has the right to claim compensation equal to one quarter of the monthly wage. The employer also has the right to claim compensation for additional damage.

If the employer has suffered no damage or if the damage suffered is less than one quarter of the employee’s monthly wage, the judge may reduce the compensation.

If the right to claim compensation has not been extinguished by set-off, the employer must exercise this right by way of action or enforcement proceedings within thirty days starting from the employee’s failure to take up work or abandonment of work. Otherwise, the right to claim compensation lapses.

V. Death of the employee or of the employer

1. Death of the employee

Article 440 – The contract ends automatically on the death of the employee. The employer is obliged to make a payment to the surviving spouse and minor children of the employee or, in their absence, to the persons whom the employee was obliged to maintain, in an amount equal to one month’s wage starting from the day of death or, if the employment relationship has lasted for more than five years, two months’ wages.

2. Death of the employer

Article 441 – In the event of the death of the employer, his or her heirs take his or her place. In this case, the provisions concerning the transfer of the employment relationship effected through the transfer of the whole or part of the workplace shall apply by analogy.

If the employment contract was concluded predominantly with regard to the person of the employer, it ends automatically on his or her death. However, the employee may claim equitable compensation from the heirs for the damage he or she has suffered owing to the premature termination of the contract.

VI. Consequences of the termination of the contract

1. Debts falling due

Article 442 – Upon the termination of the contract, all debts arising from the contract fall due.

The moment of falling due may be postponed by written agreement, in legal relationships established through the intermediation of the employee, for up to six months if the obligation undertaken by the third party is to be performed wholly or partly after the termination of the employment contract; for up to one year in relationships involving periodic performances; and for up to two years in insurance contracts or in transactions whose performance extends over a period of more than six months.

In cases where it is provided that a share of the production shall be given, the share falls due as soon as the share of production is determined and, in cases where it has been agreed that a share of the turnover or profit shall be given, the share falls due at the latest at the end of three months following the accounting period.

2. Obligation of return

Article 443 – In the event of the termination of the contract, each party is obliged to return the things he or she has received from the other party, or from a third party on behalf of the other party, in connection with the service.

The employee is obliged, in particular, to return motor vehicles and traffic permit documents and advances on wages and expenses to the extent that they exceed his or her receivables.

The rights of retention of the parties are reserved.

VII. Non-competition

1. Conditions

Article 444 – An employee having capacity to act may undertake in writing towards the employer to refrain, after the termination of the contract, from competing with the employer in any manner, in particular from opening a competing enterprise on his or her own account, from working in another competing enterprise or, apart from these, from entering into any other kind of relationship of interest with a competing enterprise.

A non-competition clause is valid only if the employment relationship gives the employee the possibility of acquiring knowledge of the clientele or of production secrets or of the business carried on by the employer, and if at the same time the use of such knowledge is of such a nature as to cause significant damage to the employer.

2. Restriction

Article 445 – A non-competition clause may not contain inappropriate restrictions as to place, time and type of business that would inequitably endanger the economic future of the employee, and its duration may not exceed two years except in special circumstances and conditions.

The judge may restrict an excessive non-competition clause as to its scope or duration by freely assessing all the circumstances and conditions and taking into account equitably any counter-performance the employer may have undertaken.

3. Consequences of breach

Article 446 – An employee who acts in breach of the non-competition clause is obliged to make good all the damage suffered by the employer as a result.

If the breach of the prohibition has been made subject to a penalty clause and there is no provision to the contrary in the contract, the employee may be released from his or her obligation under the non-competition clause by paying the stipulated amount; however, the employee is obliged to make good any damage exceeding that amount.

The employer may, in addition to payment of the contractual penalty and of any additional damage that may arise, also demand that the conduct in breach of the prohibition be brought to an end, provided that he or she has expressly reserved this right in writing in the contract and that the importance of his or her interests that have been violated or threatened and the conduct of the employee justify it.

4. Termination

Article 447 – The non-competition clause ends if it is established that the employer has no real interest in its continuation.

If the contract is terminated by the employer without just cause or by the employee for a reason attributable to the employer, the non-competition clause ends.

SECTION TWO

Commercial Travelling Agent’s Contract

A. Definition and formation

I. Definition

Article 448 – A commercial travelling agent’s contract is a contract whereby the commercial travelling agent undertakes, on a permanent basis, on behalf of an employer who is the owner of a commercial enterprise and outside his or her enterprise, to act as an intermediary in the conclusion of all kinds of transactions or, if there is a written agreement, to conclude the transactions specified in that agreement, and the employer who is the owner of the enterprise undertakes in return to pay a wage.

II. Formation

Article 449 – The commercial travelling agent’s contract shall contain the duration of the contract, its termination, the powers of the commercial travelling agent, how the wage and expenses are to be paid and, if the domicile of one of the parties is in a foreign country, which law is to apply and which court is to have jurisdiction.

If the matters required to be included in the contract under the above paragraph have not been determined by the parties, the provisions of law and the customary conditions of service shall apply.

B. Obligations and powers of the commercial travelling agent

I. Obligations

Article 450 – The commercial travelling agent is obliged to visit customers in accordance with the instructions given to him or her, unless there is just cause making it necessary not to comply with the instructions; he or she may not, without the permission of the employer, conclude transactions or act as an intermediary on his or her own account or on behalf of third parties.

If the commercial travelling agent is authorised to conclude transactions, he or she is obliged to comply with the prices and other terms of transaction provided for in the instructions; he or she may not alter them unless the employer consents.

The commercial travelling agent is obliged to provide detailed information regularly concerning the marketing activities, to forward the orders received to the employer immediately and to report important events concerning the clientele.

II. Guarantee

Article 451 – Agreements providing that the commercial travelling agent shall be liable for customers’ failure to pay or failure to perform their other obligations, or that he or she shall bear wholly or partly the expenses to be incurred for the collection of receivables, are absolutely null and void.

If the commercial travelling agent concludes transactions with his or her own clientele, he or she may undertake in writing, provided that an appropriate additional commission is agreed, to cover, in the event that customers fail to perform their obligations, the damage the employer suffers in each transaction, not exceeding one quarter thereof.

Commercial travelling agents acting as intermediaries in insurance contracts may undertake in writing to bear at most half of the expenses to be incurred where recourse is had to an action or enforcement proceedings for the collection of a premium owing to the non-payment of the whole or part of that premium.

III. Powers

Article 452 – Unless otherwise agreed in writing, the commercial travelling agent is authorised only to act as an intermediary in transactions.

If the commercial travelling agent has been authorised to conclude transactions, his or her authority covers all ordinary legal transactions and acts required for the execution of such business; unless special authority has been given, he or she may not collect payments from customers or change the payment dates.

C. Special obligations of the employer

I. Area of activity

Article 453 – If the commercial travelling agent has been given authority to operate in a specific marketing area or with a specific clientele and no written agreement to the contrary has been made, the employer may not authorise others to operate in the same area or clientele; however, he or she may himself or herself conclude transactions with third parties.

If there is a reason requiring an amendment of the provision of the contract concerning the marketing area or clientele, the employer may unilaterally amend that provision without observing the notice period, even if a notice period for termination has been provided for in the contract; however, in this case, the commercial travelling agent’s right to compensation and to bring the employment contract to an end for just cause is reserved.

II. Wage

1. In general

Article 454 – The employer is obliged to pay the commercial travelling agent a wage consisting solely of a fixed amount or of such an amount together with a commission.

A written agreement providing that the whole or a substantial part of the wage shall consist of commission is valid, provided that the agreed commission constitutes appropriate remuneration for the activity of the commercial travelling agent.

The wage to be paid for the probationary period may be freely agreed. However, the probationary period may not exceed two months.

2. Commission

Article 455 – If the authority to operate in a specific marketing area or with a specific clientele has been given exclusively to the commercial travelling agent, he or she may claim payment of the agreed or customary commission on all transactions concluded by him or her or by the employer in that area or clientele.

If the authority to operate in a specific marketing area or with a specific clientele has also been given to others together with the commercial travelling agent, the commercial travelling agent shall be paid commission only for the transactions in which he or she has acted as an intermediary or which he or she has concluded personally.

If, at the moment the commission falls due, the value of the transaction concluded cannot yet be definitively determined, the commission shall be paid first on the basis of the customary minimum value, and the remainder at the latest upon the performance of the transaction.

3. Prevention of the marketing activity

Article 456 – If it becomes impossible for the commercial travelling agent to carry on the marketing business without fault on his or her part and, by virtue of the contract or the law, he or she must be paid a wage even in this case, the wage shall be determined according to the fixed wage and the appropriate compensation that may be paid for the loss of commission. However, if the commission is less than one fifth of the wage, it may be agreed in writing that no compensation shall be paid for the loss of commission.

If the commercial travelling agent has received his or her full wage despite having been unable, without fault on his or her part, to carry on the marketing business, he or she is obliged, at the request of the employer, to perform in the employer’s enterprise such work as he or she is able to perform and as may be expected of him or her.

III. Expenditure

Article 457 – If the commercial travelling agent operates on behalf of more than one employer at the same time, each employer is obliged to contribute equally to the commercial travelling agent’s expenditure, unless otherwise agreed in writing.

Agreements providing that expenditure shall be included wholly or partly in the fixed wage or in the commission are absolutely null and void.

IV. Right of retention

Article 458 – In order to secure receivables arising from the commercial travelling agency relationship that have fallen due and, in the event of the employer’s insolvency, receivables that have not yet fallen due, the commercial travelling agent has a right of retention over movables, negotiable instruments and money he or she has received from customers on the basis of his or her authority to collect.

The commercial travelling agent may not retain vehicles and transport documents, price lists, records relating to customers and other documents.

D. Termination

I. Special notice period

Article 459 – If the commission constitutes at least one fifth of the fixed wage and is subject to significant seasonal fluctuations, the employer may terminate the contract of a commercial travelling agent who has continued to work for him or her since the end of the preceding season, during the new season, by observing a notice period of two months.

Under the same conditions, the commercial travelling agent may also terminate the contract, in respect of an employer who has employed him or her until the end of the preceding season and continues to employ him or her thereafter, during the period until the beginning of the following season, by observing a notice period of two months.

II. Special consequences

Article 460 – In the event of the termination of the contract, commission shall be paid on all transactions concluded personally by the commercial travelling agent or concluded through his or her intermediation, and on all orders forwarded to the employer until the termination of the contract, irrespective of the time of their acceptance and performance.

In the event of the termination of the contract, the commercial travelling agent is obliged to return to the employer the samples and models, price lists, records relating to customers and other documents given to him or her for carrying out the commercial travelling agency activity. However, the commercial travelling agent’s right of retention is reserved.

SECTION THREE

Contract of Homework

A. Definition and working conditions

I. Definition

Article 461 – A contract of homework is a contract whereby the worker undertakes to perform, in return for remuneration, the work given by the employer, personally or together with members of his or her family, in his or her own home or at another place which he or she determines.

II. Notification of working conditions

Article 462 – Each time the employer gives work to the worker, the employer shall notify the worker of the particular features specific to that work which fall outside the general working conditions; where necessary, the employer shall also notify the worker in writing of the materials to be provided by the worker, the amount the employer will pay the worker for the provision of those materials and the remuneration that will be paid for the work.

If the price to be paid for the materials and the remuneration to be paid for the work have not been notified in writing before the work is given, the customary price and remuneration applied in such work shall be paid.

III. Special obligations of the worker

1. Performance of the work

Article 463 – The worker is obliged to commence the work in good time, to complete the work by the agreed time and to deliver the result of the work to the employer.

If the work has been performed defectively through the fault of the worker, the worker is obliged to remedy, at his or her own expense, those defects which are capable of being remedied.

2. Materials and tools of work

Article 464 – If the materials and tools of work have been provided by the employer, the worker is obliged to use them with due care, to account for them and also to return the remaining materials and the tools of work to the employer.

If, while performing the work, the worker establishes that the materials or tools of work delivered to him or her are defective, he or she shall immediately notify the employer of the situation and shall await the employer’s instructions before continuing the work.

If the worker, through his or her own fault, renders unusable the materials or tools of work delivered to him or her, he or she shall be liable to the employer up to their current market value on the day on which they became unusable.

IV. Special obligations of the employer

1. Acceptance of the product

Article 465 – The employer shall examine the product produced and delivered by the worker and shall notify the worker of any defects found within one week from delivery. If notification is not made in time, the product shall be deemed to have been accepted in its existing condition.

2. Remuneration

a. Payment

Article 466 – The remuneration for the work done shall be paid, where the worker is employed by the employer without interruption, every fifteen days or, with the worker’s consent, once a month; where the worker is employed intermittently, upon each delivery of the product.

On each payment of remuneration, the worker shall be given a statement of account. The statement of account shall also show the amount of and reason for any deductions.

b. Where work is prevented

Article 467 – An employer who employs the worker without interruption is obliged to pay the worker his or her remuneration in accordance with the provisions on payment of remuneration in the event of prevention of the service performance, where the employer falls into default in accepting the product, or where work is prevented for reasons arising from the person of the worker and without his or her fault. In other cases, the employer is not obliged to pay remuneration under these provisions.

V. Termination

Article 468 – If work has been given to the worker for the purpose of trial, the contract shall, unless otherwise agreed, be deemed to have been concluded for the trial period.

Where the worker is employed by the employer without interruption, the contract shall, unless otherwise agreed, be deemed to have been concluded for an indefinite term; in other cases, the contract shall be deemed to have been concluded for a definite term.

B. Application of the general provisions

Article 469 – In cases for which there is no provision relating to the commercial traveller’s contract and the contract of homework, the general provisions of the contract of service shall apply.

CHAPTER SEVEN

Contract for Work

A. Definition

Article 470 – A contract for work is a contract whereby the contractor undertakes to produce a work and the employer undertakes to pay a price in return.

B. Provisions

I. Obligations of the contractor

1. In general

Article 471 – The contractor is obliged to perform the obligations he or she has undertaken loyally and with care, having regard to the legitimate interests of the employer.

In determining the contractor’s liability arising from the duty of care, the conduct in conformity with professional and technical rules which a prudent contractor undertaking work in a similar field would be expected to observe shall be taken as the basis.

The contractor is obliged to produce the work personally or to have it produced under his or her own management. However, if the personal qualities of the contractor are not of importance for the production of the work, he or she may also have the work performed by another person.

Unless there is a custom or agreement to the contrary, the contractor is obliged to provide himself or herself the tools and equipment to be used for producing the work.

2. As regards materials

Article 472 – If the materials have been provided by the contractor, the contractor shall be liable to the employer like a seller for the defectiveness of those materials.

If the materials have been provided by the employer, the contractor is obliged to use them with due care, to account for them and to return any surplus.

If, while the work is being produced, it becomes apparent that the materials provided by the employer or the site designated by him or her for the performance of the work are defective, or any other circumstance arises which jeopardises the proper or timely production of the work, the contractor is obliged to notify the employer of this situation immediately; if the contractor fails to do so, he or she shall be liable for the consequences arising therefrom.

3. Commencement and execution of the work

Article 473 – If the contractor does not commence the work in good time, or delays the work contrary to the terms of the contract, or if, owing to a delay arising for a reason not attributable to the employer, it becomes clearly apparent that according to all expectations the contractor will be unable to complete the work by the agreed time, the employer may withdraw from the contract without being obliged to wait for the day fixed for delivery.

If, during its production, it is clearly evident that the work will be produced defectively or in breach of the contract through the fault of the contractor, the employer may, in order to prevent this, serve a warning on the contractor to remedy the defect or the non-conformity within an appropriate time limit which the employer grants or causes to be granted, failing which the repair or the continuation of the work will be entrusted to a third party at the contractor’s risk and expense.

4. Liability for defects

a. Ascertainment of defects

Article 474 – After delivery of the work, the employer is obliged to examine the work as soon as he or she has the opportunity to do so in the ordinary course of business and, if there are any defects, to notify the contractor thereof within an appropriate time.

Each of the parties may, at his or her own expense, request that the work be examined by an expert and that the result be recorded in a report.

b. Optional rights of the employer

Article 475 – In cases where the contractor is liable on account of a defect in the work, the employer may exercise one of the following optional rights:

1. Withdrawal from the contract, if the work is so defective that the employer cannot use it or cannot in equity be compelled to accept it, or deviates from the terms of the contract to the same extent.

2. Retaining the work and claiming a reduction in the price in proportion to the defect.

3. Claiming repair of the work free of charge, with all costs borne by the contractor, provided that this does not require excessive expense.

The employer’s right to claim compensation under the general provisions is reserved.

If the work has been constructed on land belonging to the employer and its removal would cause excessive damage, the employer may not exercise the right to withdraw from the contract.

c. Liability of the employer

Article 476 – If the defectiveness of the work has arisen from instructions given by the employer, despite an express warning by the contractor, or is attributable to the employer for any other reason, the employer may not exercise the rights arising from the defectiveness of the work.

d. Acceptance of the work

Article 477 – After express or implied acceptance of the work, the contractor is released from all liability; however, his or her liability continues for defects which he or she intentionally concealed and which could not be noticed upon a proper examination.

If the employer neglects to examine the work and to give notice, he or she shall be deemed to have accepted the work.

If a defect in the work comes to light subsequently, the employer is obliged to notify the contractor of the situation without delay; if the employer fails to do so, he or she shall be deemed to have accepted the work.

e. Limitation

Article 478 – If the contractor has produced a defective work, actions to be brought on that account shall become time-barred, from the date of delivery, upon the expiry of two years in the case of works other than immovable structures; five years in the case of immovable structures; and, where the contractor is guilty of gross fault, twenty years irrespective of the nature of the defective work.

II. Obligations of the employer

1. Maturity of the price

Article 479 – The employer’s obligation to pay the price becomes due at the time of delivery of the work.

If it has been agreed that the work is to be delivered in parts and the price has been determined according to the parts, the price of each part becomes due at the time of its delivery.

2. Price

a. Lump-sum price

Article 480 – If the price has been fixed as a lump sum, the contractor is obliged to produce the work for that price. The contractor may not claim an increase in the fixed price even if the work has required more labour and expense than anticipated.

However, if circumstances which could not have been foreseen at the outset, or which could have been foreseen but were not taken into account by the parties, prevent or render extremely difficult the performance of the work for the lump-sum price fixed by the parties, the contractor has the right to request the judge to adapt the contract to the new circumstances or, where this is not possible or cannot be expected of the other party, to withdraw from the contract. In cases required by the rules of good faith, the contractor may only exercise the right of termination.

The employer is obliged to pay the full fixed price even if the work has required less labour and expense than anticipated.

b. Price according to value

Article 481 – If the price of the work has not been fixed in advance or has been fixed only approximately, the price shall be determined having regard to the value of the work at the place and time at which it was performed and to the contractor’s expenses.

C. Termination of the contract

I. Exceeding the approximate price

Article 482 – If it becomes apparent that the price initially fixed approximately will be exceeded excessively without fault on the part of the employer, the employer may withdraw from the contract either before or after completion of the work.

If the work is being constructed on the employer’s land, the employer may claim an appropriate reduction of the price or, if the work has not yet been completed, may terminate the contract by stopping the contractor from continuing the work and paying an equitable price for the completed part.

II. Destruction of the work

Article 483 – If the work is destroyed by an unforeseen event before delivery, the contractor may not claim payment of the remuneration for the work done or of his or her expenses, unless the employer is in default in taking delivery of the work. In this case, the loss of the materials shall be borne by the party who provided them.

Where the work is destroyed owing to a defect in the materials supplied or the land designated by the employer, or owing to its having been performed in accordance with the employer’s instructions, the contractor may, if he or she gave timely notice of the possible adverse consequences, claim payment of the value of the work done and of the expenses not included in that value. If the employer is at fault, the contractor also has the right to claim compensation for his or her loss.

III. Termination against compensation

Article 484 – The employer may terminate the contract before completion of the work, on condition that he or she pays for the part already performed and compensates the contractor for all of his or her loss.

IV. Impossibility of performance due to the employer

Article 485 – If completion of the work becomes impossible owing to an unforeseen event relating to the employer, the contractor may claim the value of the work done and the expenses not included in that value.

If the employer is at fault in bringing about the impossibility of performance, the contractor also has the right to claim compensation.

V. Death or loss of capacity of the contractor

Article 486 – A contract concluded in view of the personal qualities of the contractor shall terminate automatically upon his or her death or upon his or her losing, without fault, the capacity to complete the work. In this case, if the employer is able to make use of the completed part of the work, he or she is obliged to accept it and to pay for it.

CHAPTER EIGHT

Publishing Contract

A. Definition

Article 487 – A publishing contract is a contract whereby the author of an intellectual and artistic work, or his or her successor, undertakes to entrust that work to a publisher for publication, and the publisher undertakes to reproduce and publish it.

B. Form

Article 488 – The validity of a publishing contract is subject to its being made in writing.

C. Provisions

I. Transfer of the right to have the work published and liability

Article 489 – By the publishing contract, the rights of the author pass to the publisher to the extent and for the duration required for the performance of the contract.

The party causing publication shall be liable to the publisher for not having, at the time of conclusion of the contract, the right to have the work published and, if the work is protected, also for not having the copyright.

If all or part of the work has been entrusted to another publisher for publication or has been published with the knowledge of the party causing publication, the party causing publication is obliged to notify the other party thereof before the publishing contract is concluded.

II. Right of disposal of the party causing publication

Article 490 – The party causing publication may not dispose of all or part of the work to the detriment of the publisher unless the term agreed in the contract has expired or, where no term has been fixed, the customary period for the agreed print run to be exhausted has elapsed.

Short pieces appearing in periodicals may at any time also be published elsewhere by the party causing publication.

The party causing publication may not have his or her own contributions to a collective work, or long pieces appearing in journals, republished until three months have elapsed from the completion of publication.

III. Determination of the number of editions and the print run

Article 491 – If the number of editions is not specified in the contract, the publisher has the right to produce only one edition.

The parties are obliged to agree on the duration of the contract or the print run.

In cases where the contract authorises the publisher to produce a certain number of editions or all new editions, if the publisher neglects to produce a new edition when the print run of the work has been exhausted, the party causing publication shall grant the publisher an appropriate time limit for the new edition. If the publisher does not produce the edition within the time limit granted, the party causing publication may withdraw from the contract.

IV. Reproduction and distribution

Article 492 – The publisher is obliged to reproduce the work in an appropriate manner without any abridgement, addition or alteration; furthermore, the publisher is obliged to carry out the promotion and distribution necessary to increase sales and to take all measures in this respect.

The publisher shall determine the sale price, provided that this does not impede the sale of the work.

V. Corrections and improvements

Article 493 – Provided that the interests of the publisher are not impaired and his or her liability is not increased, the author may make corrections and improvements to the work, while his or her successors may only update it. Expenses which such corrections and improvements require but which were not provided for in the contract shall be borne by the party causing publication.

The publisher may not produce or reproduce a new edition without giving the author the opportunity to improve his or her work, or the successors the opportunity to update it.

VI. Joint printing and separate publication

Article 494 – The right to publish separately several works of one author does not authorise the publisher to print them together.

Likewise, the right to publish together all the works of an author, or only one category of them, does not give the publisher the right to print and distribute each of them separately.

VII. Right of translation

Article 495 – The passing of the right of translation to the publisher is subject to its being expressly stated in the contract.

VIII. Right to claim a fee

1. Determination of the fee

Article 496 – Unless otherwise agreed in the contract, the party causing publication may claim payment of a fee.

In cases where a fee is payable, if the amount to be paid is not specified, the fee shall be determined by the judge.

If the publisher has the right to produce more than one edition, the fee and other conditions agreed for the first edition shall be deemed to have been accepted as applying to subsequent editions as well.

2. Time of payment of the fee, sales accounts and right to free copies

Article 497 – The fee shall be paid, if the work is to be published as a whole, in full, and, if it is to be published in parts such as volumes, fascicles or signatures, for each part after it has been printed and made ready for sale.

If the parties have made the fee dependent on the volume of sales, the publisher is obliged to keep and draw up sales accounts and to prepare supporting documents in accordance with commercial custom.

Unless otherwise agreed, the party causing publication has the right to receive, free of charge, the number of copies of the work which are to be given in accordance with commercial custom.

D. Termination

I. Destruction of the work

Article 498 – Even if the work is destroyed by an unforeseen circumstance after its delivery to the publisher, the publisher is obliged to pay the fee.

If the author has another copy of the work, he or she must give that copy to the publisher; if there is no other copy but the work can be recreated with little effort, the author is obliged to recreate and deliver the work. In both cases, the author may claim appropriate remuneration.

II. Destruction of printed copies

Article 499 – If all or part of the completed print run of the work is destroyed by an unforeseen circumstance before being offered for sale, the publisher may reprint the destroyed quantity at his or her own expense without paying any additional fee to the party causing publication.

If the publisher can replace the destroyed copies with new ones without excessive expense, he or she is obliged to do so.

III. Termination for personal reasons

Article 500 – If the author dies or loses the capacity to complete the work before completing it, or if completion of the work becomes impossible without his or her fault, the contract shall terminate automatically. However, if performance of all or part of the contract is found to be possible and equitable, the judge may decide that the contractual relationship shall continue and that the amendments necessary for this purpose shall be made.

If the publisher becomes bankrupt, the party causing publication may give the work to another publisher; however, if security has been provided for the performance of the obligation not yet due at the time of bankruptcy, the party causing publication may not give the work to another publisher.

E. Publishing contract on commission

Article 501 – If one or more persons undertake to produce a work according to a plan determined by the publisher, they are entitled only to the remuneration agreed in the contract.

In this case, the economic rights forming the subject matter of the contract shall belong to the publisher.

CHAPTER NINE

Mandate Relationships

SECTION ONE

Contract of Mandate

A. Definition

Article 502 – A contract of mandate is a contract whereby the agent undertakes to conduct a business or carry out a transaction of the principal.

The provisions on mandate shall also apply, to the extent that they are compatible with their nature, to contracts for the performance of services which are not regulated in this Code.

The agent is entitled to remuneration if this is provided for by contract or by commercial custom.

B. Formation

Article 503 – If the person to whom the conduct of a business is offered holds an official capacity for conducting such business, or if the performance of such business forms part of his or her profession, or if he or she has announced that he or she will accept such business, a contract of mandate shall be deemed to have been concluded unless he or she immediately rejects the offer.

C. Provisions

I. Scope of the mandate

Article 504 – If the scope of the mandate is not expressly specified in the contract, it shall be determined according to the nature of the business to be conducted.

The mandate includes, in particular, the authority to carry out the legal transactions necessary for conducting the business undertaken by the agent.

Unless specially authorised, the agent may not bring an action, make a settlement, resort to arbitration, apply for bankruptcy, postponement of bankruptcy or composition, assume obligations under bills of exchange, make a donation, become a surety, transfer an immovable property or encumber it with a right.

II. Obligations of the agent

1. Performance in accordance with instructions

Article 505 – The agent is obliged to comply with the express instructions of the principal. However, where it is not possible to obtain the principal’s permission and it is clear that the principal would have given permission had he or she known of the situation, the agent may deviate from the instructions.

In other cases, if the agent deviates from the instructions, he or she shall not have performed the obligation under the mandate, even if he or she has conducted the business, unless he or she makes good the loss arising therefrom.

2. Personal performance, loyalty and care

a. In general

Article 506 – The agent is obliged to perform the obligation under the mandate personally. However, in cases where the agent has been so authorised or where circumstances so require or commercial custom so permits, the agent may have the business performed by another person.

The agent is obliged to conduct the business and services he or she has undertaken loyally and with care, having regard to the legitimate interests of the principal.

In determining the agent’s liability arising from the duty of care, the conduct which a prudent agent undertaking business and services in a similar field would be expected to observe shall be taken as the basis.

b. Where the business is performed by a third party

Article 507 – Where the agent, exceeding his or her authority, has the business performed by another person, he or she shall be liable for that person’s acts as if he or she had performed them himself or herself.

If the agent is authorised to delegate the mandate to another person, he or she is obliged only to exercise the necessary care in selecting that person and in giving instructions.

In both cases, the principal may assert directly against the person whom the agent has put in his or her place the rights which the agent has against that person.

3. Rendering of accounts

Article 508 – The agent is obliged, at the principal’s request, to render account of the business he or she has conducted and to hand over to the principal whatever he or she has received in connection with the mandate.

The agent is also obliged to pay interest on money which he or she has delayed in handing over to the principal.

4. Passing of acquired rights to the principal

Article 509 – Claims against third parties arising from business conducted by the agent in his or her own name and for the account of the principal shall pass automatically to the principal at the moment when the principal has performed all of his or her obligations towards the agent.

In the event of the agent’s bankruptcy, the principal may also assert against the bankruptcy estate that such claim has passed to him or her.

The principal may request that movable property acquired by the agent in his or her own name and for the account of the principal be separated from the bankruptcy estate and delivered to the principal. The bankruptcy estate shall also benefit from the right of retention held by the agent.

III. Obligations of the principal

Article 510 – The principal is obliged to reimburse, together with interest, the expenses incurred and advances made by the agent for the proper performance of the mandate and to release the agent from the obligations he or she has assumed.

The agent may claim from the principal compensation for the loss he or she has suffered by reason of the performance of the mandate. However, the principal may be released from this liability by proving that he or she was not at fault.

IV. Liability of joint principals and joint agents

Article 511 – Persons who have jointly given a mandate to a person are jointly and severally liable towards the agent.

Persons who have jointly undertaken a mandate are jointly and severally liable for the performance of the mandate and, unless they have the right to delegate their authority to others, may bind the principal only through acts and transactions which they carry out jointly.

D. Termination

I. Grounds

1. Unilateral termination

Article 512 – The principal and the agent may at any time terminate the contract unilaterally. However, the party who terminates the contract at an inopportune time is obliged to compensate the other party for the loss arising therefrom.

2. Death, loss of capacity and bankruptcy

Article 513 – Unless otherwise apparent from the contract or the nature of the business, the contract shall terminate automatically upon the death, loss of capacity or bankruptcy of the agent or the principal. This provision shall also apply, where one of the parties is a legal entity, upon the termination of that legal personality.

If the termination of the mandate endangers the interests of the principal, the agent or his or her heir or representative is obliged to continue performing the mandate until the principal or his or her heir or representative is in a position to conduct the business himself or herself.

II. Effects

Article 514 – The principal or his or her heirs shall be liable for business conducted by the agent before learning of the termination of the contract as if the contract were still in force.

SECTION TWO

Letter of Credit and Credit Order

A. Letter of credit

Article 515 – A letter of credit is a document containing the mandate of the sender of the letter to the addressee to give money and similar things, with or without the specification of an upper limit, in the amount requested by a specified person who is to benefit from the letter of credit. A letter of credit is subject to the provisions on the contract of mandate and on assignment orders.

In a letter of credit issued without the specification of an upper limit, if the person who is to benefit from the letter makes an excessive request which is clearly not in keeping with the relationship between the persons concerned with the letter, the addressee is obliged to notify the sender of the situation and to postpone payment until a reply is received.

A mandate given by a letter of credit shall be valid only if it has been accepted by the addressee for a specified amount.

B. Credit order

I. Definition and form

Article 516 – If a person has received and accepted an order to open or renew credit, in his or her own name and for his or her own account, for a third party under the responsibility of the person giving the credit order, the person giving the order shall be liable like a surety for the credit debt, unless the person to whom the credit order was given exceeds his or her mandate. However, the person giving the order shall not be liable unless the credit order is in writing.

II. Incapacity of the beneficiary of the credit order

Article 517 – The person giving the credit order may not be released from liability towards the person to whom the credit order was given by pleading the incapacity of the beneficiary of the credit order.

III. Granting of extension by the person to whom the credit order was given

Article 518 – If the person to whom the credit order was given grants, of his or her own accord, an extension of time to the beneficiary of the credit order, or neglects to proceed against the beneficiary of the credit order although instructed to do so, the person giving the credit order shall be released from liability.

IV. Relationship between the parties

Article 519 – The provisions governing the relationship between the surety and the principal debtor shall apply to the relationship between the person giving the credit order and the beneficiary of the credit order.

SECTION THREE

Brokerage Contract

A. Definition and form

Article 520 – A brokerage contract is a contract whereby the broker undertakes to provide the opportunity for the conclusion of a contract between parties or to act as intermediary in its conclusion, and becomes entitled to remuneration if that contract is concluded.

As a rule, the provisions on mandate shall apply to the brokerage contract.

A brokerage contract relating to immovable property shall not be valid unless it is made in writing.

B. Remuneration

I. Time of entitlement

Article 521 – The broker becomes entitled to remuneration only if a contract is concluded as a result of his or her activity.

If the contract concluded as a result of the broker’s activity is subject to a condition precedent, the remuneration shall be paid upon fulfilment of the condition.

If it has been agreed in the brokerage contract that the expenses to be incurred by the broker shall be reimbursed to him or her, the expenses shall be reimbursed even if the broker’s activity has not resulted in the conclusion of the contract.

II. Determination of remuneration

Article 522 – If the remuneration has not been determined, it shall be paid according to the tariff or, where there is no tariff, according to commercial custom.

III. Forfeiture of the broker’s rights

Article 523 – If the broker, in breach of the obligation he or she has undertaken, acts in the interest of the other party or, contrary to the rules of good faith, obtains a promise of remuneration from the other party, he or she forfeits his or her rights to remuneration and to reimbursement of the expenses he or she has incurred.

IV. Marriage brokerage

Article 524 – No action may be brought and no enforcement proceedings may be initiated in respect of remuneration arising from marriage brokerage.

V. Reduction of remuneration

Article 525 – If excessive remuneration has been agreed in the contract, it may be reduced equitably by the judge upon the request of the debtor.

CHAPTER TEN

Agency without Authority (Negotiorum Gestio)

A. Rights and obligations of the agent without authority

I. Conduct of the business

Article 526 – A person who conducts business for the account of another without a mandate is obliged to conduct that business in accordance with the interests and the presumed intention of the principal.

II. Liability

Article 527 – The agent without authority is liable for any negligence. However, if the agent conducted the business in order to avert loss or the danger of loss facing the principal, his or her liability shall be assessed more leniently.

If the agent conducted the business despite the principal’s express or implied prohibition, and the principal’s prohibition was not contrary to law or morality, he or she shall also be liable for accidental events. However, the agent is released from liability if he or she proves that the loss would have occurred as a result of the accidental event even if he or she had not conducted the business.

III. Incapacity of the agent without authority

Article 528 – If the agent lacks the capacity to contract, he or she shall be liable for the transaction he or she has carried out only to the extent of his or her enrichment or to the extent of the enrichment he or she has parted with in bad faith.

More extensive liability arising from torts is reserved.

B. Rights and obligations of the principal

I. Where the business is conducted in the interest of the principal

Article 529 – Where the business is conducted in his or her interest, the principal is obliged to reimburse the agent, together with interest, for all expenses which were necessary and useful in the circumstances, to perform the obligations undertaken by the agent by reason of the business conducted and to compensate the loss to be assessed by the judge. This provision shall also apply to an agent who exercised the necessary care in conducting the business, even if the intended result was not achieved.

If the agent is unable to recover the expenses he or she has incurred, he or she has the right of separation and removal in accordance with the provisions on unjust enrichment.

II. Where the business is conducted in the interest of the agent

Article 530 – The principal has the right to appropriate the benefits arising from the conduct of the business, even if it was not conducted in his or her interest; however, he or she is obliged to reimburse the agent’s expenses and to release the agent from the obligations he or she has assumed only to the extent of his or her enrichment.

III. Where the business is ratified by the principal

Article 531 – If the principal has ratified the business conducted, the provisions on mandate shall apply.

CHAPTER ELEVEN

Contract of Commission Agency

A. Commission agency for purchase or sale

I. Definition

Article 532 – Commission agency for purchase or sale is a contract whereby the commission agent undertakes, in return for remuneration, to purchase or sell negotiable instruments and movables in his or her own name and for the account of the principal.

Without prejudice to the provisions of this Chapter, the provisions on mandate shall apply to contracts of commission agency.

II. Obligations of the commission agent

1. Duty to notify and to insure

Article 533 – The commission agent is obliged to inform the principal about the business he or she has conducted and, in particular, to notify the principal immediately that his or her instructions have been carried out.

Unless instructed by the principal, the commission agent is not obliged to insure the things forming the subject matter of the contract.

2. Duty of care

Article 534 – If goods sent to the commission agent for sale are evidently defective, the commission agent is obliged to do what is necessary to protect the principal’s rights against the carrier, to have the damage ascertained, to take the goods into safekeeping as far as possible and to inform the principal of the situation immediately; otherwise, he or she shall be liable for loss arising from any negligence.

If goods sent for sale are liable to deteriorate within a short time, the commission agent is obliged to sell the goods, on condition that he or she immediately informs the principal.

3. Price fixed by the principal

Article 535 – A commission agent who sells goods below the price fixed by the principal is obliged to make good the difference between the fixed price and the sale price, unless he or she proves that, had he or she not sold the goods, the principal would have suffered greater loss and that the circumstances did not permit obtaining new instructions. In addition, if he or she is at fault, the commission agent shall also be liable for other losses suffered by the principal as a result of his or her acting contrary to instructions.

A commission agent who buys goods below or sells goods above the price fixed by the principal may not retain the difference arising from such transactions.

4. Sale on credit and payment without taking delivery

Article 536 – If the commission agent sells goods on credit or pays the price of goods without taking delivery of them, without the principal’s permission, he or she must bear the loss arising therefrom. However, unless the principal has prohibited it, the commission agent may also sell goods on credit in accordance with the commercial custom of the place of sale.

5. Guarantee of the commission agent

Article 537 – Except where he or she sells goods on credit without authority, the commission agent shall not be liable for non-payment by, or non-performance of other obligations by, the debtors with whom he or she has transacted. However, the commission agent shall be liable if he or she has expressly given a guarantee or if the commercial custom of the place where he or she is located so requires.

A commission agent who gives a guarantee has the right to claim additional remuneration on that account.

III. Rights of the commission agent

1. Sums paid and expenses incurred

Article 538 – The commission agent may claim, together with interest, all expenses incurred and sums paid by him or her for the benefit of the principal.

The commission agent may charge storage and carriage costs to the account of the principal, but may not so charge the wages of his or her own employees.

2. Commission fee

a. Right to claim

Article 539 – The commission agent may claim payment of his or her remuneration upon carrying out the business entrusted to him or her, and may also claim it where the business is not carried out for a reason attributable to the principal.

Where the business cannot be carried out for other reasons, the commission agent may only claim remuneration for his or her labour, to be determined according to local custom.

b. Forfeiture

Article 540 – If the commission agent acts towards the principal contrary to the rules of good faith, and in particular if he or she reports to the principal a price higher than that at which he or she purchased or lower than that at which he or she sold, he or she forfeits the right to remuneration.

Where the price is shown as different from the price actually obtained, the principal has the right to treat the commission agent as the buyer or seller of the goods at the price actually obtained.

3. Right of retention

Article 541 – The commission agent has a right of retention over the price of goods he or she has sold and over goods he or she has purchased.

4. Sale of goods by public auction

Article 542 – Where goods entrusted to the commission agent cannot be sold, or the sale order is revoked, and the principal is excessively late in taking back the goods or in disposing of them otherwise, the commission agent may, upon obtaining a decision from the court of the place where the goods are located, have the goods sold by public auction. However, if the goods are listed on an exchange or have a market price, or if their value is small in relation to the costs to be incurred, the judge may also decide that the sale be made in another way.

If neither the principal nor his or her representative is present at the place where the goods are located, the decision on the sale may also be given without hearing the principal.

Except where the goods are rapidly losing value, the court must notify the principal of the place and time of the auction.

5. Self-dealing by the commission agent

a. Price and remuneration

Article 543 – A commission agent authorised to sell or buy bills of exchange or other negotiable instruments or commercial goods which are listed on an exchange or have a market price may, unless instructed otherwise by the principal, sell his or her own goods in place of the goods he or she is to purchase, or buy for himself or herself the goods he or she is to sell. In these cases, the values at the moment at which the commission agent enters into the transaction with himself or herself shall be taken as the basis; even in these cases, the commission agent has the right to claim the remuneration and expenses customary in commission business.

The commission agent is obliged to notify the principal on the same day that such a transaction has been carried out.

In other cases, the provisions on sale shall apply.

b. Presumption of self-dealing

Article 544 – In cases where the commission agent may himself or herself act directly as buyer or seller, if he or she notifies the principal that the mandate has been carried out without naming the other party to the contract, he or she shall be deemed to have entered into the transaction with himself or herself.

c. Lapse of the right of self-dealing

Article 545 – The commission agent’s right to enter into the transaction with himself or herself lapses at the moment the news that the principal has revoked the mandate reaches the commission agent. However, this provision shall not apply if the commission agent dispatched the notification that the transaction had been carried out before that news reached him or her.

B. Other commission business

Article 546 – Commission business concerning movables to be manufactured from materials to be provided by the principal shall be subject to the provisions on commission agency for purchase and sale, even if the goods are not fungible things.

The provisions of this Chapter shall also apply to a commission agent for purchase and sale who undertakes, in return for remuneration, in his or her own name and for the account of the principal, business which does not constitute commission agency for purchase and sale, and to a merchant who does not engage in commission business as a profession but undertakes it occasionally.

The special provisions on forwarding (carriage) commission agency are reserved.

CHAPTER TWELVE

Procurists, Commercial Representatives and Other Merchant’s Assistants

A. Procurist

I. Definition and conferral of authority

Article 547 – A procurist is a person whom the owner of the enterprise has authorised, expressly or impliedly, to manage the commercial enterprise and to represent him or her, under the trade name and with the power of procuration, in transactions relating to the enterprise.

The owner of the enterprise is obliged to have the conferral of the power of procuration registered in the trade registry; however, the liability of the owner of the commercial enterprise for the acts of the procurist does not depend on registration having been made.

II. Scope of the power of representation

Article 548 – As against third parties acting in good faith, the procurist shall be deemed authorised to assume obligations under bills of exchange in the name of the owner of the enterprise and to carry out in his or her name all kinds of transactions falling within the object of the enterprise.

Unless expressly authorised, the procurist may not transfer immovable property or encumber it with a right.

III. Restriction of the power of representation

Article 549 – The power of representation may be restricted to the business of a branch.

The power of representation may also be restricted on condition that several persons sign jointly. In this case, the signature of one of the representatives without the participation of the others shall not bind the owner of the enterprise.

The above restrictions on the power of representation shall not have effect against third parties acting in good faith unless registered in the trade registry.

Other restrictions on the power of representation may not be asserted against third parties acting in good faith, even if they have been registered.

IV. Termination of the power of representation

Article 550 – The termination of the power of representation shall be registered even if its conferral was not registered in the trade registry.

As long as the termination of the power of representation has not been registered in the trade registry and announced, that power shall remain valid as regards third parties acting in good faith.

B. Commercial representative

Article 551 – A commercial representative is a person whom the owner of a commercial enterprise, without conferring on him or her the power of procuration, has authorised to manage the enterprise or to carry out certain business of the enterprise.

This authority covers all transactions customary in the enterprise. However, unless expressly authorised, the commercial representative may not borrow money or the like, assume obligations under bills of exchange, bring an action or conduct an action already brought.

C. Other merchant’s assistants

Article 552 – Unless notice to the contrary has been given in writing within the commercial enterprise, in a place where customers can easily see it and in a form they can easily read, the officers or employees of commercial enterprises engaged in wholesale, semi-wholesale or retail sales are authorised to carry out the following transactions:

1. To carry out all sales transactions customary in the commercial enterprise.

2. To sign invoices relating to the transactions for which they are authorised.

3. To make, on behalf of the owner of the enterprise, warnings or other declarations relating to the performance of obligations arising from the customary transactions of the commercial enterprise or to their non-performance or improper performance; and to accept, on behalf of the commercial enterprise, warnings or other declarations of this nature, in particular notices of defects relating to goods delivered in the course of customary transactions.

Unless they have been authorised in writing, the officers or employees of commercial enterprises engaged in wholesale, semi-wholesale or retail sales may not demand and collect sale prices outside the enterprise or, where cashiers have been appointed, within the enterprise. In cases where they are authorised to collect sale prices, these persons are also authorised to settle invoices or to issue receipts.

D. Prohibition of competition

Article 553 – Procurists, commercial representatives or other merchant’s assistants who manage all the business of an enterprise or who are in the service of the owner of the enterprise may not, without the permission of the owner of the enterprise, directly or indirectly carry out, for their own account or for the account of a third party, business of the kind carried out by the enterprise, nor may they have such transactions carried out by third parties for their own account.

If they act contrary to this, the owner of the enterprise may, without prejudice to the rights arising from the legal relationship between them, claim compensation for the loss suffered or, instead, demand that the business carried out by the procurist, commercial representative or other merchant’s assistant for his or her own account, or caused by him or her to be carried out by third parties, be deemed to have been carried out for the account of the owner of the enterprise, and that the remuneration received on account of such business be handed over or the claims arising from such business be assigned.

E. Termination of the authority of procurists, commercial representatives and other merchant’s assistants

Article 554 – The owner of the enterprise may at any time revoke the authority of procurists, commercial representatives and other merchant’s assistants, without prejudice to the rights arising from the contracts of service, mandate, partnership and similar contracts between them.

The loss of capacity to act or the death of the owner of the enterprise shall not terminate the authority of procurists, commercial representatives and other merchant’s assistants.

CHAPTER THIRTEEN

Assignment Order

A. Definition

Article 555 – An assignment order is a legal transaction whereby the assignor authorises the drawee to deliver, for the account of the assignor, money, negotiable instruments or other fungible things to the payee, and authorises the payee to accept them in his or her own name.

B. Provisions

I. Relationship between the assignor and the payee

Article 556 – If the assignment order is made for the purpose of performing an obligation owed by the assignor to the payee, that obligation shall be extinguished only upon performance by the drawee.

A payee who has accepted the assignment order and who, having applied to the drawee, has not been able to obtain his or her claim within the time limit specified in the assignment order may again assert that claim against the assignor.

If a payee who is a creditor does not wish to accept the assignment order, he or she is obliged to notify the assignor, who is the debtor, of the situation without delay; if he or she fails to do so, he or she shall be obliged to compensate the loss arising therefrom.

II. Obligation of the drawee

Article 557 – If the drawee notifies the payee that he or she accepts the assignment order without reservation, he or she becomes obliged to perform and may assert against the payee only those defences arising from the relationship between them or from the content of the assignment order; he or she may not assert defences arising from the relationship between the assignor and himself or herself.

If the drawee is indebted to the assignor, he or she is obliged to perform the obligation to the payee, provided that performance to the payee does not impose a greater burden than performance to the assignor. In this case, unless otherwise agreed between the drawee and the assignor, the drawee need not declare to the payee, before performance, that he or she accepts the assignment order.

III. Notification in case of non-performance

Article 558 – If the drawee refuses to perform despite the payee’s request, or declares in advance that he or she will not perform the subject of the assignment order, the payee is obliged to notify the assignor of the situation without delay; if he or she fails to do so, he or she shall be liable for the loss which the assignor suffers as a result.

C. Revocation

Article 559 – The assignor may at any time revoke the authority he or she has given to the payee. However, he or she may not revoke an authority given in the interest of the payee, in particular for the purpose of enabling the payee to obtain his or her claim.

The assignor may revoke the authority given to the drawee as long as the drawee has not declared to the payee that he or she accepts the assignment order.

In the event of the assignor’s bankruptcy, an assignment order which has not yet been accepted shall terminate automatically.

D. Assignment order relating to negotiable instruments

Article 560 – The provisions of this Chapter shall apply to written assignment orders made for the purpose of payment to the bearer of a claim embodied in a negotiable instrument. In this case, every holder shall be deemed to be the payee as against the drawee. On the other hand, the rights specific to the relationship between the assignor and the payee shall arise only between the transferor and the transferee of the claim.

The special provisions on cheques and on assignment orders similar to bills of exchange are reserved.

CHAPTER FOURTEEN

Contracts of Deposit

A. Ordinary contract of deposit

I. Definition

Article 561 – A contract of deposit is a contract whereby the depositary undertakes to keep safely in a secure place a movable which the depositor has entrusted to him or her.

The depositary may claim remuneration if this has been expressly provided for or if the circumstances and conditions so require.

II. Obligations of the depositor

Article 562 – The depositor is obliged to pay all expenses necessitated by the performance of the contract.

Unless the depositor proves that it did not arise from his or her fault, the depositor is obliged to compensate the depositary for losses arising from the deposit.

III. Obligations of the depositary

1. Prohibition of use

Article 563 – The depositary may not use the deposited thing without the permission of the depositor.

If the depositary acts contrary to this prohibition, he or she is obliged to pay the depositor an appropriate fee for its use and shall also be liable for losses arising from accidental events, unless he or she proves that the loss would have occurred even if he or she had not used the thing.

2. Return

a. In general

Article 564 – Even if a term has been fixed in the contract of deposit, the depositary is obliged to return the deposited thing together with all its accretions upon the request of the depositor, which the depositor may make at any time. However, the depositor is obliged to pay the expenses incurred by the depositary in reliance on the fixed term.

b. Special cases

Article 565 – The depositary may not return the deposited thing before the expiry of the fixed term. However, the depositary may return it before the expiry of the fixed term as well if, owing to unforeseeable circumstances, the continuation of the contract becomes dangerous for the deposited thing or detrimental to the depositary.

If no term has been fixed, the depositary may return the deposited thing at any time.

If several persons deposit a thing, the depositary may not be released from liability by returning the deposited thing to one of them, unless there is a provision to the contrary in the contract or all of them consent.

c. Place of return

Article 566 – The deposited thing shall be returned at the place where it was to be kept, at the expense and risk of the depositor.

3. Liability of depositaries

Article 567 – Persons who have jointly received a thing for safekeeping are jointly and severally liable.

4. Claims of third parties

Article 568 – Even if a third party claims a right in rem over the deposited thing, the depositary is obliged to return it to the depositor unless the deposited thing has been attached or an action for recovery of property has been brought against the depositary.

In the event of attachment or the bringing of an action for recovery of property, the depositary is obliged to notify the depositor of the situation immediately.

IV. Sequestration (deposit with a trusted person)

Article 569 – Where several persons, in order to protect their rights, deposit a thing whose legal status is disputed or uncertain with a trusted person, that person may not return it to any one of them except with the consent of all the depositors or by decision of the judge.

B. Deposit of fungible things

Article 570 – Where it has been expressly or tacitly agreed that the depositary is to return the money deposited with him or her not in specie but in an equivalent amount, the benefit and risk of that money pass to the depositary.

The deposit of money unsealed and open shall be deemed a tacit agreement.

The depositary may not dispose of other deposited fungible goods or negotiable instruments unless expressly authorised to do so by the depositor.

C. Deposit with a warehouse keeper

I. Issue of warehouse documents

Article 571 – A warehouse keeper who publicly announces that he or she accepts commercial goods for storage may request the competent authority for permission to issue documents representing the stored goods.

II. Warehouse keeper’s duty of safekeeping

Article 572 – The warehouse keeper is obliged to keep the goods deposited with him or her with the same care as a commission agent and, if a change occurs in the goods which requires further measures to be taken, to notify the depositor of the situation as far as possible.

The warehouse keeper is obliged to permit the depositor to inspect the condition of the goods and to take samples during customary business hours, and to take the necessary protective measures at any time.

III. Commingling of deposited things

Article 573 – Unless expressly authorised, the warehouse keeper may not commingle fungible things of the same kind and quality.

Each of the depositors may claim a share, proportionate to his or her right, in such things commingled on the basis of an authorisation.

In this case, the warehouse keeper may separate the share of each of the depositors without the need for the depositors to be present together.

IV. Rights of the warehouse keeper

Article 574 – The warehouse keeper may claim the agreed or customary storage fee and all expenses not arising from the storage itself, such as maintenance, carriage and customs expenses.

These expenses shall be paid immediately; the storage fee shall be paid every three months and, in any event, upon the withdrawal of all or part of the goods.

The warehouse keeper has a right of retention over the goods for his or her claims for as long as he or she is in possession of the goods or has the power to dispose of them by means of any document representing the goods.

V. Return of the goods

Article 575 – The warehouse keeper is obliged to return the commercial goods as in the case of a general contract of deposit. However, even in cases where the depositary is entitled to return them before the expiry of the term for reasons which could not have been foreseen in the contract, the warehouse keeper is obliged to keep the goods until the end of the agreed term.

D. Deposit with operators of lodging establishments, garages, car parks and similar places

I. Liability of operators of lodging establishments

1. Conditions and scope

Article 576 – Operators of places such as hotels, motels, guesthouses and holiday villages are liable for the destruction or damage of, or theft of, property brought by guests. However, the operators are released from this liability by proving that the damage arose from fault attributable to the guest himself or herself or to a person visiting the guest or accompanying or in the service of the guest, from force majeure or from the nature of the property.

Unless fault is attributable to the operators or their employees, this liability may not exceed, for each guest, three times the daily accommodation charge.

2. Valuables

Article 577 – Where valuables or fairly considerable sums of money or negotiable instruments have not been deposited with the operator for safekeeping, the operator is liable only in the event of fault on his or her part or on the part of his or her employees.

Where the operator has accepted them for safekeeping or has refused to accept them, he or she is liable for the full value of the property.

With regard to property, money and similar things which the guest must keep with him or her, the rule of liability concerning the guest’s other property shall apply.

3. Extinction of liability

Article 578 – If the guest does not notify the operator of the damage as soon as he or she becomes aware of it, he or she loses the right to claim.

The operator cannot escape liability even if he or she announces in any manner that he or she does not assume such liability or that he or she makes liability subject to a condition not provided for in this Code.

II. Liability of operators of garages, car parks and similar places

Article 579 – Operators of garages, car parks and similar places are liable for the destruction or damage of, or theft of, animals, horse-drawn carriages, their harness and similar items, and motor vehicles and their accessories deposited with them or accepted by their employees. However, the operators are released from this liability by proving that the damage arose from fault attributable to the depositor or his or her visitor or to a person accompanying or in the service of the depositor, from force majeure or from the nature of the property.

However, unless fault is attributable to them or their employees, the liability of operators of garages, car parks and similar places may not exceed, for each deposited item, ten times the daily storage fee charged.

The operator cannot escape liability even if he or she announces in any manner that he or she does not assume such liability or that he or she makes liability subject to a condition not provided for in this Code.

III. Right of retention

Article 580 – Operators have a right of retention over property or animals deposited with them or placed in lodging establishments, garages, car parks and similar places, in order to secure their fees or their claims arising from storage expenses.

The provisions concerning the lessor’s right of retention shall apply here by analogy.

CHAPTER FIFTEEN

Contract of Suretyship

A. Definition

Article 581 – A contract of suretyship is a contract by which the surety undertakes towards the creditor to be personally liable for the consequences of the debtor’s failure to perform the debt.

B. Conditions

I. Principal debt

Article 582 – A contract of suretyship may be concluded for an existing and valid debt. However, a contract of suretyship may also be concluded for a future or conditional debt, to take effect when that debt arises or the condition is fulfilled.

A person who gives a personal guarantee for a debt for which the debtor is not liable by reason of error or incapacity is liable in accordance with the statutory provisions on suretyship if, at the time of assuming the obligation, he or she knew of the defect vitiating the contract. The same rule applies to a person who stands surety for a debt which is time-barred as regards the debtor.

Unless otherwise provided by law, the surety may not waive in advance the rights granted to him or her in this chapter.

II. Form

Article 583 – A contract of suretyship is not valid unless it is made in writing and states the maximum amount for which the surety will be liable and the date of the suretyship. It is mandatory that the surety state in his or her own handwriting in the contract of suretyship the maximum amount for which he or she is liable, the date of the suretyship and, in the case of joint and several suretyship, that he or she assumes the obligation in that capacity or by any expression to that effect.

The granting of special authority to stand surety on one’s behalf and a promise to stand surety made to the other party or to a third party are subject to the same requirements of form. The parties may, in compliance with the written form, agree to limit the liability of the surety to a specific amount of the debt.

Subsequent amendments to the contract of suretyship which increase the liability of the surety have no effect unless the form prescribed for suretyship is complied with.

III. Consent of the spouse

Article 584 – Unless there is a decision of separation given by a court or a statutory right to live separately has arisen, one of the spouses may stand surety only with the written consent of the other; this consent must be given before or, at the latest, at the time of the conclusion of the contract.

The consent of the spouse is not required for subsequent amendments to the contract of suretyship which do not result in an increase in the amount for which the surety will be liable, in the conversion of ordinary suretyship into joint and several suretyship, or in a significant reduction of the securities in favour of the surety.

(Added paragraph: 28/3/2013-6455/77 art.) The consent of the spouse is not required for suretyships to be given in relation to the enterprise or company by the owner of a commercial enterprise registered in the trade registry or by a partner or manager of a commercial company, for suretyships to be given by tradesmen or craftsmen registered in the register of tradesmen and craftsmen in relation to their professional activities, for suretyships to be given for loans to be used within the scope of Law No. 5570 of 27/12/2006 on the Granting of Interest-Supported Loans by Banks with Public Capital, or for suretyships to be given for loans to be granted to cooperative members by agricultural credit cooperatives, agricultural sales cooperatives and tradesmen’s and craftsmen’s credit and surety cooperatives and by public institutions and organisations.

C. Content

I. According to type

1. Ordinary suretyship

Article 585 – In ordinary suretyship, the creditor may not pursue the surety unless he or she has had recourse to the debtor; however, he or she may have recourse directly to the surety in the following cases:

1. Where a definitive certificate of insolvency has been obtained as a result of enforcement proceedings brought against the debtor.

2. Where enforcement proceedings against the debtor in Türkiye have become impossible or significantly more difficult.

3. Where the bankruptcy of the debtor has been adjudged.

4. Where the debtor has been granted a moratorium for composition (concordat).

Where the claim has also been secured by a pledge before or at the time of the suretyship, the surety in ordinary suretyship may demand that the claim first be satisfied out of the object of the pledge. However, this provision does not apply where the bankruptcy of the debtor has been adjudged or a decision has been given granting him or her a moratorium for composition.

Where the surety has stood surety only for the covering of a shortfall, recourse may be had directly to the surety where the enforcement proceedings brought against the debtor have resulted in a definitive certificate of insolvency, where enforcement proceedings against the debtor in Türkiye have become impossible, or where the composition has become final. It may be agreed in the contract that, in these cases, the creditor must first have recourse to the principal debtor.

2. Joint and several suretyship

Article 586 – Where the surety has agreed to assume the obligation in the capacity of joint and several surety or by any expression to that effect, the creditor may pursue the surety without pursuing the debtor or realising an immovable pledge. However, for this purpose the debtor must be in default of performance and a demand must have remained without result, or the debtor must be manifestly insolvent.

Where the claim is secured by a pledge of movables requiring delivery or by a pledge of a claim, recourse may not be had to the surety before the pledge is realised. However, recourse may be had to the surety even before the realisation of the pledge where it has been determined in advance by the judge that the claim cannot be fully satisfied through realisation of the pledge, or where the debtor has gone bankrupt or has been granted a moratorium for composition.

3. Co-suretyship

Article 587 – Where several persons have together stood surety for the same debt, each of them is liable as an ordinary surety for his or her own share and as a surety of the surety for the shares of the others.

Each of the sureties who have assumed the obligation as joint and several sureties together with the debtor or among themselves is liable for the entire debt. However, a surety may refuse to pay more than his or her own share unless enforcement proceedings have been initiated against all the sureties who are jointly and severally liable with him or her, previously or at the same time, and who can be pursued in Türkiye. A surety may also exercise this right where the other sureties have paid their own shares or have provided real security. Without prejudice to agreements to the contrary, the surety who has paid the debt has a right of recourse against the other sureties to the extent that they have not previously paid their own shares. This right may also be exercised before recourse against the debtor.

Where the creditor knew or ought to have known that the surety stood surety on the assumption that other persons have also stood or will stand surety for the same claim, the surety is released from the suretyship obligation if this assumption subsequently fails to materialise, or if one of the sureties is released from the suretyship obligation by the creditor, or if his or her suretyship is declared null and void.

Each of the persons who have stood surety for the same debt independently of one another is liable for the entire suretyship obligation. However, unless otherwise agreed, the surety who pays the debt has a right of recourse against the others in proportion to their shares of the total amount of suretyship.

4. Surety of the surety and surety for recourse

Article 588 – The surety of the surety, who gives security to the creditor for the obligation of the surety, is liable together with the surety as an ordinary surety.

The surety for recourse is the surety who gives security for the surety’s claim of recourse against the debtor.

II. Common provisions

1. Relationship between the surety and the creditor

a. Scope of liability

Article 589 – The surety is in all cases liable up to the maximum amount stated in the contract of suretyship.

Unless otherwise agreed in the contract, the surety is liable, within the limit of the stated maximum amount, for the following:

1. The principal debt and the statutory consequences of the debtor’s fault or default.

2. The costs of the enforcement proceedings and actions brought against the debtor, provided that the creditor has notified the surety at a suitable time in advance so that the surety could have prevented them by paying the debt, and, where applicable, the costs incurred by the delivery of pledges to the surety and by the transfer of pledge rights.

3. Contractual interest accrued for one year and for the current year and, where applicable, the interest accrued for one year and for the current year on principal lent against bonds.

Unless expressly agreed in the contract, the surety is liable only for the debts of the debtor arising after the conclusion of the contract of suretyship.

Agreements providing that the surety will be liable for the damage caused by the principal debt relationship becoming null and void and for a contractual penalty are absolutely null and void.

b. Pursuit of the surety

Article 590 – Even if the principal debt has become due earlier by reason of the debtor’s bankruptcy, enforcement proceedings may not be taken against the surety before the fixed maturity date.

In all types of suretyship, the surety may, against provision of real security, request the judge to order the stay of enforcement proceedings directed against him or her until the existing pledges have been realised and a definitive certificate of insolvency has been obtained as a result of the enforcement proceedings brought against the debtor, or until a decision on composition (concordat) is given.

Where the principal debt becomes due upon a prior notice with a time limit given by the creditor or the debtor, that time limit begins to run, as regards the suretyship obligation, on the date on which notice is given to the surety.

Where payment of the debt by a debtor domiciled in a foreign country has become impossible or has been restricted pursuant to the legal provisions of that foreign country, for reasons such as prohibitions relating to foreign exchange transactions or transfers, a surety domiciled in Türkiye may object to the enforcement proceedings on that ground.

c. Defences

Article 591 – The surety has the right, and is also obliged, to raise against the creditor all the defences available to the principal debtor or his or her heirs that do not arise from the insolvency of the principal debtor. The case of knowingly standing surety for a debt for which the debtor is not liable by reason of error or lack of capacity to contract, or by reason of the debt being time-barred, is excluded from this provision.

Even if the principal debtor has waived a defence available to him or her, the surety may nevertheless raise that defence against the creditor.

If the surety makes payment without knowing of the existence of defences available to the principal debtor, he or she has a right of recourse. On the other hand, if the principal debtor proves that the surety knew or ought to have known of these defences, the surety loses the right of recourse to the extent that he or she would have been released from payment had they been raised.

In a suretyship for a debt arising from gaming or betting, the surety may raise the defences available to the principal debtor even if he or she knew of this nature of the debt.

d. Exercise of care, delivery of pledges and debt instruments

Article 592 – Where the creditor, to the detriment of the surety, diminishes the pledge rights, the security and the rights of priority which existed at the time of the suretyship or which he or she subsequently obtained from the principal debtor as special security for the claim, the liability of the surety is reduced by a corresponding amount, unless the creditor proves that the damage is smaller. The right of the surety to claim the return of any amount paid in excess is reserved.

In the case of a suretyship for employees, if the creditor neglects the supervision over the employees which he or she is obliged to exercise or fails to exercise the care that can be expected of him or her, and the debt has arisen for that reason or has increased to an extent that it would not have reached had he or she exercised that care, he or she may not claim that debt or the increased part of the debt from the surety.

The creditor is obliged to deliver to the surety who pays the debt the debt instruments which may serve the surety in exercising his or her rights, and to provide the necessary information. The creditor is also obliged to deliver to the surety the pledges and other securities which existed at the time of the suretyship or which were subsequently provided by the principal debtor for the claim, or to carry out the formalities necessary for their transfer. The pledge rights and rights of retention held by the creditor by reason of his or her other claims are reserved to the extent that they rank ahead of the rights of the surety.

If the creditor, without just cause, fails to fulfil his or her obligations or, through gross fault, parts with existing documents or pledges or other securities for which he or she is responsible, the surety is released from his or her obligation. In this case, the surety may claim the return of what he or she has paid and compensation for any additional damage.

e. Demanding acceptance of payment

Article 593 – Where the debt has become due, even if by reason of the debtor’s bankruptcy, the surety may at any time demand that the creditor accept the payment he or she is to make. Where several persons have stood surety for a debt, the creditor is obliged to accept a partial payment to be made by one of the sureties, provided that it is not less than the share falling to the surety offering it.

If the creditor refuses to accept payment without just cause, the surety is released from his or her obligation; in the case of joint and several co-suretyship, the liability of the sureties is reduced by the amount of the share falling to them.

With the consent of the creditor, the surety may also pay the principal debt before it becomes due. However, in this case the surety may not exercise his or her right of recourse against the principal debtor before the debt becomes due.

f. Notification, filing of the claim in bankruptcy and composition

Article 594 – If the principal debtor is six months in arrears in the payment of the principal or of the interest for a half-yearly period, or in the payment of instalments of principal stipulated to be made from year to year, the creditor must notify the surety of the situation. Upon request, the creditor is obliged at any time to inform the surety of the extent of the principal debt.

Where the bankruptcy of the principal debtor has been adjudged or the debtor has requested a composition (concordat), the creditor is obliged to file his or her claim and to do what is necessary for the protection of his or her rights. The creditor must notify the surety of the situation as soon as he or she learns that the debtor has gone bankrupt or that the debtor has been granted a moratorium for composition.

If the creditor fails to fulfil one of the requirements provided for in the above paragraphs, he or she loses his or her rights against the surety to the extent of the damage suffered by the surety as a result.

2. Relationship between the surety and the debtor

a. Right to demand security and release from the debt

Article 595 – The surety may demand that the principal debtor provide security and, where the debt has become due, that he or she be released from the debt, in the following cases:

1. Where the principal debtor has acted contrary to the obligations he or she assumed towards the surety, in particular contrary to the promise to release the surety from the debt within a certain period.

2. Where the principal debtor is in default, or enforcement proceedings have become significantly more difficult because he or she has transferred his or her domicile to another country.

3. Where the risk to the surety has increased significantly compared with the date on which the suretyship was given, as a result of the deterioration of the principal debtor’s financial situation, the depreciation of the securities or the fault of the debtor.

b. Surety’s right of recourse

Article 596 – The surety is subrogated to the rights of the creditor to the extent that he or she has performed to the creditor. The surety may exercise these rights when the principal debt becomes due.

Unless otherwise agreed, the surety is subrogated, among the pledge rights and other securities provided for the same claim, only to those which existed at the time of the suretyship or which were subsequently given by the principal debtor himself or herself specifically for this claim. A surety who has partially performed to the creditor is subrogated only to that part of the pledge right corresponding to his or her performance. The creditor’s remaining claim over the object of the pledge ranks ahead of the surety’s pledge right.

Claims and defences arising from the legal relationship between the surety and the principal debtor are reserved.

Where the pledge securing a claim is realised or the debt is paid by the owner who gave the pledge, the owner may exercise a right of recourse against the surety only if there is such an agreement between the surety and himself or herself or if the pledge was subsequently given by a third party.

The limitation period concerning the surety’s right of recourse begins to run at the moment the surety performs to the creditor.

Where the surety makes payment for a debt which does not give rise to a right of action or which does not bind the principal debtor by reason of error or incapacity, he or she has no right of recourse against the principal debtor. However, if the surety has assumed liability for a time-barred principal debt in the capacity of agent of the debtor, the principal debtor is liable to him or her in accordance with the provisions on the contract of mandate.

c. Surety’s burden of notification

Article 597 – The surety who pays the debt in whole or in part is obliged to notify the debtor of the situation.

If the surety fails to give this notification and the debtor, who does not know or is not required to know of the payment, also performs to the creditor, the surety loses his or her right of recourse.

The surety’s right of action against the creditor arising from unjust enrichment is reserved.

D. Termination

I. By operation of law

Article 598 – Whatever the reason, upon the extinction of the principal debt the surety is also released from his or her obligation.

Where the capacities of debtor and surety are united in the same person, the special benefits arising from the suretyship for the creditor are reserved.

Any suretyship given by a natural person lapses automatically upon the expiry of ten years from the conclusion of the contract relating to it.

Even if the suretyship has been given for a period of more than ten years, the surety may be pursued only until the expiry of the ten-year period, unless the suretyship has been extended or a new suretyship has been given.

The term of the suretyship may be extended for a new period of a maximum of ten years by a written declaration of the surety in compliance with the form of the contract of suretyship, provided that this is made at the earliest one year before the termination of the suretyship.

II. Withdrawal from the suretyship

Article 599 – In a suretyship for a future debt, where the financial situation of the debtor before the debt arises has deteriorated significantly after the conclusion of the contract of suretyship, or where it emerges that his or her financial situation is much worse than the surety assumed in good faith at the time of the suretyship, the surety may withdraw from the contract of suretyship at any time, as long as the debt has not arisen, by giving written notice to the creditor.

The surety is obliged to compensate the damage suffered by the creditor as a result of relying on the suretyship.

III. In a suretyship for a fixed term

Article 600 – In a suretyship for a fixed term, the surety is released from his or her obligation at the end of the term.

IV. In a suretyship without a fixed term

Article 601 – In a suretyship without a fixed term, the surety may, when the principal debt becomes due, at any time in the case of ordinary suretyship and, in the case of joint and several suretyship, in the cases provided for by law, demand that the creditor exercise his or her rights of action and enforcement against the debtor within one month, initiate enforcement proceedings by way of realisation of the pledge if any, and continue the proceedings without interruption.

Where the debt is to become due as a result of a notice to be given by the creditor to the debtor, the surety may, one year after the date of conclusion of the contract of suretyship, demand that the creditor give this notice and, once the debt has thus become due, exercise his or her rights of enforcement and action in accordance with the provisions of the above paragraph.

If the creditor fails to comply with these demands of the surety, the surety is released from his or her obligation.

V. In a suretyship for employees

Article 602 – In a suretyship for employees without a fixed term, the surety may, every three years, give notice of termination of the contract with effect from the end of the following year.

E. Scope of application

Article 603 – The provisions concerning the form of suretyship, the capacity to stand surety and the consent of the spouse also apply to other contracts concluded by natural persons under a different name relating to the giving of a personal guarantee.

CHAPTER SIXTEEN

Gaming and Betting

A. Unenforceability of the claim

Article 604 – No action may be brought and no enforcement proceedings may be taken in respect of a claim arising from gaming and betting.

The same provision applies to advances and loans knowingly given for gaming or betting, and to forward sales of goods traded on the stock exchange, foreign currencies and negotiable instruments made on the basis of price differences, where they have the character of gaming and betting.

B. Issue of debt instruments and voluntary payment

Article 605 – Even if an ordinary debt instrument or a bill of exchange signed by a person who has engaged in gaming or betting has been transferred to a third party, no one may bring an action or take enforcement proceedings on the basis thereof. The rights conferred by negotiable instruments on third parties in good faith are reserved.

Payments made voluntarily for a gaming or betting debt may not be recovered. However, if the proper conduct of the gaming or betting has been prevented by an unforeseen event or by an act of the other party, or if the other party has introduced fraud into the gaming or betting, the payment made voluntarily may be recovered.

C. Lotteries and other games of chance

Article 606 – Unless their organisation has been authorised by law or by the competent authorities, no action may be brought and no enforcement proceedings may be taken in respect of claims arising from lotteries and other games of chance.

In cases where authorisation has not been granted, the provisions on gaming shall also apply to lotteries and other games of chance.

Lotteries and other games of chance organised in foreign countries in accordance with their own rules do not enjoy legal protection unless the sale of their tickets in Türkiye has been authorised by the competent authorities.

CHAPTER SEVENTEEN

Contracts of Life Annuity and Care until Death

SECTION ONE

Contract of Life Annuity

A. Definition

Article 607 – A contract of life annuity is a contract by which the annuity debtor undertakes to make specified periodic payments to the annuity creditor for the lifetime of one of them or of a third party.

Unless there is an express provision to the contrary, the contract shall be deemed to have been concluded for the lifetime of the annuity creditor.

An annuity established for the lifetime of the annuity debtor or of a third party passes, unless otherwise agreed, to the heirs of the annuity creditor.

B. Form

Article 608 – A contract of life annuity is not valid unless it is made in writing.

C. Rights of the annuity creditor

I. Exercise of the right

Article 609 – Unless otherwise agreed in the contract, the life annuity shall be paid every six months and in advance.

Even if the person on whose lifetime the duration of the annuity depends dies before the end of the period for which payment in advance is provided, the entire annuity for that period shall be deemed owed by the annuity debtor.

If the annuity debtor goes bankrupt, the annuity creditor acquires the right to file in the bankruptcy estate a sum equal to the capital that would have to be paid to the relevant social security institution in order to obtain the periodic annuity for which the annuity debtor is liable.

II. Transferability

Article 610 – Unless otherwise agreed by contract, the annuity creditor may transfer his or her rights to another person.

SECTION TWO

Contract of Care until Death

A. Definition

Article 611 – A contract of care until death is a contract by which the care debtor undertakes to look after and care for the care creditor until his or her death, and the care creditor undertakes the obligation to transfer to the care debtor an estate or certain assets.

Where the care debtor has been appointed heir by the care creditor, the provisions on the contract of inheritance apply to the contract of care until death.

B. Form

Article 612 – A contract of care until death, even if it does not contain an appointment of an heir, is not valid unless it is made in the form of a contract of inheritance.

Where the contract has been concluded by a care institution recognised by the State in compliance with the conditions determined by the competent authorities, the written form is sufficient for its validity.

C. Security

Article 613 – A care creditor who has transferred an immovable to the care debtor has, in order to secure his or her rights, a statutory mortgage right over that immovable in the same way as a seller.

D. Subject matter

Article 614 – Upon the conclusion of the contract, the care creditor becomes part of the family community of the care debtor. The care debtor is obliged to perform for the care creditor the performances required by equity, having regard to the value of the property received and the social standing previously enjoyed by the care creditor.

The care debtor is obliged in particular to provide the care creditor with suitable food and accommodation, to care for him or her with the necessary diligence in the event of illness and to have him or her medically treated.

The scope and performance of the care obligation of institutions established for the purpose of caring until death for the persons they accept are determined by general regulations drawn up by them and approved by the competent authorities. These regulations shall be deemed to form part of the content of the contract.

E. Annulment and abatement

Article 615 – Where, as a result of the contract of care until death, the care creditor loses the ability to fulfil his or her obligations towards the persons to whom he or she owes maintenance under the law, those persons who are thereby deprived may request the annulment of the contract.

Instead of annulling the contract, the judge may order the care debtor to pay maintenance to the persons to whom the care creditor owes maintenance, to be set off against the performances to be rendered by the care debtor.

The rights of the heirs to bring an action for abatement and of the creditors to bring an action for annulment are reserved.

F. Termination

I. Termination by notice

Article 616 – Where there is a significant disproportion between the performances of the parties and the party receiving more cannot prove that there was an intention to make a gift to him or her, the other party may terminate the contract at any time by giving six months’ notice. In determining this disproportion, the difference between the capital value corresponding to the value of what was given to the care debtor and the annuity to be established by the relevant social security institution shall be taken as the basis.

The performances rendered up to the moment of termination of the contract shall be assessed together with principal and interest and, following a settlement of accounts, shall be returned to the party which emerges as the creditor.

II. Termination without notice

Article 617 – Where the continuation of the contract has become intolerable by reason of a breach of the obligations arising from the contract, or where other important reasons render the continuation of the contract impossible or excessively difficult, each of the parties may terminate the contract without notice. Where the contract is terminated on one of these grounds, the party at fault shall return what he or she has received and is obliged to pay the party not at fault appropriate compensation for the damage suffered as a result.

The judge may find the termination of the contract without notice justified or, upon the request of one of the parties or of his or her own motion, may bring to an end their living together in the family community and establish a life annuity for the care creditor.

III. Death of the care debtor

Article 618 – If the care debtor dies, the care creditor may request the termination of the contract within one year. In this case, the care creditor may claim from the heirs of the care debtor payment of a sum equal to the amount he or she could claim from the bankruptcy estate in the event of the care debtor’s bankruptcy.

G. Non-transferability, claim in the event of bankruptcy and attachment

Article 619 – The care creditor may not transfer his or her right to another person.

In the event of the bankruptcy of the care debtor, the care creditor acquires the right to file as a claim in the bankruptcy estate a sum equal to the capital value that would have to be paid to the relevant social security institution in order to obtain the periodic annuity which the debtor is obliged to pay.

In order to satisfy this claim, the care creditor may participate in an attachment being carried out by third parties against the debtor.

CHAPTER EIGHTEEN

Contract of Simple Partnership

A. Definition

Article 620 – A contract of simple partnership is a contract by which two or more persons undertake to combine their labour and property in order to achieve a common purpose.

Where a partnership does not have the distinguishing characteristics of the partnerships regulated by law, it shall be deemed a simple partnership subject to the provisions of this chapter.

B. Relationship between the partners

I. Contribution

Article 621 – Each partner is obliged to make a contribution to the partnership in the form of money, claims or other property, or labour.

Unless otherwise agreed in the contract, the contributions must be of the importance and nature required by the purpose of the partnership and equal to one another.

Where a partner’s contribution consists of granting the use of a thing, the provisions of the contract of lease, and where it consists of the ownership of a thing, the provisions of the contract of sale, concerning risk and liability for defects and for eviction, apply by analogy.

II. Profit and loss

1. Sharing of profit

Article 622 – The partners are obliged to share among themselves all profits which by their nature belong to the partnership.

2. Participation in profit and loss

Article 623 – Unless otherwise agreed in the contract, each partner’s share in the profit and loss is equal, irrespective of the value and nature of his or her contribution.

Where the contract determines only the partners’ share in either the profit or the loss, that determination also applies to the share in the other.

An agreement that a partner is to participate only in the profit without participating in the loss is valid only for a partner who has contributed only his or her labour.

III. Decisions of the partnership

Article 624 – Decisions of the partnership are taken unanimously by all the partners.

Where the contract provides that decisions are to be taken by majority vote, the majority is determined according to the number of partners.

IV. Management of the partnership

Article 625 – Unless management has been entrusted by the contract or by a decision exclusively to one or more partners or to a third party, all the partners have the right to manage the partnership.

Where the partnership is managed by all or several of the partners, each of them may act without the participation of the others; however, each partner authorised to manage the partnership may prevent a transaction from being carried out by objecting to it before its completion.

The unanimity of all the partners is required for the appointment of a general authorised representative for the partnership and for the conduct of the extraordinary affairs of the partnership. However, in cases where delay would be harmful, each of the managing partners is authorised in this respect.

V. Liability between the partners

1. Prohibition of competition

Article 626 – The partners may not, for their own benefit or for the benefit of third parties, carry out transactions which would obstruct or harm the purpose of the partnership.

2. Expenses incurred and transactions carried out by the partners

Article 627 – The other partners are liable to a partner for the expenses he or she has incurred or the debts he or she has assumed for the affairs of the partnership; the other partners are obliged to compensate the damage suffered by this partner directly as a result of the management of affairs and the damage arising as a result of the risks inherent in the management of the partnership.

A partner who has advanced money to the partnership may claim interest from the day on which it was advanced.

A partner who has expended labour on the affairs of the partnership without being obliged to do so may claim payment of a consideration required by equity.

3. Duty of care

Article 628 – Each partner is obliged to exercise in the affairs of the partnership the same diligence and care as in his or her own affairs.

Each partner is obliged to compensate the others for the damage he or she has caused through his or her own fault, without the right to set it off against the benefits he or she has procured for the partnership in other transactions.

A partner who conducts the affairs of the partnership for remuneration is liable in accordance with the provisions on mandate.

VI. Withdrawal and restriction of the power of management

Article 629 – The power of management granted to one of the partners by the partnership contract may not be withdrawn or restricted by the other partners without just cause.

Even if the partnership contract contains a provision that the power may not be withdrawn, each of the other partners may withdraw the power of management if there is just cause.

Just cause exists in particular where the managing partner has grossly neglected his or her duties or has lost the ability necessary for good management.

VII. Relationship between managing partners and other partners

1. In general

Article 630 – Unless otherwise provided in this chapter of the Code or in the partnership contract, the relations between the managing partners and the other partners are subject to the provisions on the contract of mandate.

Where a partner who has no power to manage the partnership conducts the affairs of the partnership, or where a partner having this power exceeds his or her authority, the provisions on agency without authority apply.

The managing partners are obliged to render account at least once a year and to pay the partners their shares of the profits. An agreement extending the accounting period is absolutely null and void. The same rule applies where the person managing the partnership is not one of the partners.

2. Inspection of the partnership’s affairs

Article 631 – Even without a power of management, each partner has the right to obtain information on the conduct of the partnership’s affairs, to inspect its books and records, to take copies of them and to prepare a summary of its financial situation.

Agreements to the contrary are absolutely null and void.

VIII. Changes between the partners and in the structure of the partnership

1. Admission of a new partner and sub-participation

Article 632 – The admission of a new partner to the partnership is subject to the consent of all the partners.

Where one of the partners unilaterally makes a third party a participant in his or her share in the partnership or transfers his or her share to that party, the third party does not acquire the status of partner.

2. Withdrawal and expulsion from the partnership

a. In general

Article 633 – Where the contract contains a provision that the partnership is to continue with the other partners in the event that a partner gives notice of termination, is placed under guardianship, goes bankrupt, has his or her share in the liquidation realised by way of compulsory enforcement, or dies, then upon the occurrence of one of these events that partner or his or her representative, or the heir of the deceased partner, may withdraw from the partnership or may be expelled from the partnership by a written notice to be given by the other partners.

b. Liquidation of the partnership share

Article 634 – Where a partner withdraws or is expelled from the partnership, his or her share passes automatically to the other partners in proportion to their shares.

The other partners are obliged to return to the partner who has withdrawn or been expelled the property whose use he or she left to the partnership, and also to release him or her from joint and several liability arising from the due debts of the partnership and to pay him or her the liquidation share that would have had to be paid had the partnership been liquidated on the date on which his or her status as partner ended. For debts of the partnership which have not yet become due, the other partners may, instead of releasing the partner who has withdrawn or been expelled from the debt, provide him or her with security.

The liquidation share of the partner who has withdrawn or been expelled shall be calculated, as at the date on which his or her status as partner ended, by a person who is an expert in financial matters. If the parties cannot agree on the expert, this person shall be appointed by the judge.

c. Insufficiency of assets

Article 635 – Where, on the date on which the status of partner ends, the assets of the partnership are insufficient to cover its debts, the partner who has withdrawn or been expelled is obliged to pay to the other partners the amount of the debt falling to his or her share, within the framework of the rules on participation in losses.

d. Uncompleted transactions

Article 636 – The partner who has withdrawn or been expelled participates in the profit or loss arising from transactions not yet concluded during the period in which he or she was a partner.

A person whose status as partner has ended may claim, as at the end of that financial year, the share of profit, if any, falling to him or her from the partnership by reason of completed transactions, and the necessary information concerning continuing transactions.

C. Relationship of the partners with third parties

I. Representation

Article 637 – A partner who enters into a transaction with a third party in his or her own name and for the account of the partnership becomes personally the creditor and debtor of that third party.

Where one of the partners enters into a transaction with a third party in the name of the partnership or of all the partners, the other partners become creditors or debtors of that third party only in accordance with the provisions on representation.

A partner who has been entrusted with management is presumed to have the power to represent the partnership or all the partners vis-à-vis third parties. However, the authority of a managing partner with power of representation to carry out important acts of disposal must have been granted unanimously by all the partners and this must be expressly stated in the instrument of authority.

II. Consequences of representation

Article 638 – Things, claims and real rights acquired for the partnership or transferred to the partnership belong jointly to all the partners within the framework of the partnership contract.

Unless otherwise provided in the partnership contract, the creditors of a partner may exercise their rights only against that partner’s share in the liquidation.

The partners are, unless otherwise agreed, jointly and severally liable towards a third party for the debts which they have assumed together or through a representative within the framework of the partnership relationship.

D. Dissolution of the partnership

I. Grounds for dissolution

1. In general

Article 639 – The partnership is dissolved in the following cases:

1. Upon the achievement of the purpose provided for in the partnership contract or upon its achievement becoming impossible.

2. Upon the death of one of the partners, unless the contract contains a provision on the continuation of the partnership with the heirs.

3. Upon a partner being placed under guardianship, going bankrupt or having his or her share in the liquidation realised by way of compulsory enforcement, unless the contract contains a provision that the partnership is to continue.

4. Upon a unanimous decision of all the partners.

5. Upon the expiry of the term agreed for the partnership.

6. Upon a partner giving notice of termination, where the right to give notice of termination has been reserved in the partnership contract or where the partnership has been established for an indefinite period or for the lifetime of one of the partners.

7. Where there are just causes, at any time and without any further condition, by court decision upon a request for termination.

2. Partnership for an indefinite period

Article 640 – Where the partnership has been established for an indefinite period or to last for the lifetime of one of the partners, each of the partners may give notice of termination six months in advance.

Notice of termination may not be given contrary to the rules of good faith and in particular at an inappropriate time. Notice of termination takes effect only at the end of the financial year.

If, after the expiry of the term provided for in the contract, the partnership is continued by the tacit intention of the partners, it becomes a partnership for an indefinite period.

II. Effect of dissolution on the management of the partnership

Article 641 – Where the partnership is dissolved otherwise than by notice of termination, a partner’s power to manage the affairs of the partnership continues in his or her favour until the time at which he or she learned of the dissolution or would have learned of it had he or she exercised the care required by the circumstances.

Where the partnership is dissolved by the death of one of the partners, the heir of the deceased partner is obliged to notify the other partners of the situation immediately. The heir shall continue, in accordance with the rules of good faith, the transactions previously conducted by the deceased partner until the necessary measures have been taken. The other partners shall likewise continue temporarily to conduct the affairs of the partnership in the same manner.

III. Liquidation

1. Treatment of the contribution

Article 642 – A partner who has contributed the ownership of a thing as his or her contribution may not, in the liquidation to be carried out upon the dissolution of the partnership, take back that thing as it is; however, he or she may claim whatever value was placed on his or her contribution.

If this value has not been determined, the return shall be made on the basis of the value of the thing at the time it was contributed.

2. Sharing of profit and loss

Article 643 – If anything remains after the debts of the partnership have been paid and the advances made by each of the partners to the partnership, the expenses incurred by them for the partnership and the contributions they made have been returned, this profit shall be shared among the partners.

If the assets of the partnership remaining after the payment of the debts, expenses and advances are insufficient for the return of the contributions made by the partners, the loss shall be shared among the partners.

3. Liquidation procedure

Article 644 – Upon the dissolution of the partnership, the liquidation shall be carried out jointly by all the partners, including the non-managing partners. However, where the partnership contract provides for certain transactions to be carried out by one of the partners in his or her own name and for the account of the partnership, that partner is obliged, even after the dissolution of the partnership, to carry out those transactions alone and to render account to the others.

The partners may appoint a liquidator to conduct the liquidation affairs. If they fail to agree on this matter, each of the partners may request that the liquidator be appointed by the judge.

The remuneration to be paid to the liquidator shall, in the absence of a provision on this matter in the contract or of a decision taken unanimously by the partners, be determined by the judge having regard to the labour required by the liquidation and the income of the partnership assets, and shall be covered from the partnership assets or, where this is not possible, by the partners jointly and severally.

Disputes which may arise concerning the liquidation procedure or the share to be distributed to each partner as a result of the liquidation shall be resolved by the judge upon the request of the persons concerned.

IV. Liability towards third parties

Article 645 – The dissolution of the partnership does not alter the obligations towards third parties.

Relationship with the Turkish Civil Code

Article 646 – This Code constitutes the Fifth Book of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 of 22/11/2001 and is its complement.

Law repealed

Article 647 – The Code of Obligations No. 818 of 22/4/1926 is repealed.

Provisional Article 1 – (Added: 8/6/2022-7409/4 art.)

With regard to residential leases, agreements concerning the rent to be applied in rental periods renewed between the date of entry into force of this article and 1/7/2023 (inclusive) are valid provided that the rent does not exceed twenty-five per cent of the rent for the previous rental year. Where the rate of change according to the twelve-month averages of the consumer price index for the previous rental year remains below twenty-five per cent, the rate of change applies. This rule also applies to lease contracts with a term of more than one year. Contracts made so as to exceed these rates are invalid as regards the excess amount. The provision of this paragraph also applies to decisions to be given by the judge pursuant to the second paragraph of Article 344.

Provisional Article 2 – (Added: 14/7/2023-7456/23 art.)

With regard to residential leases, agreements concerning the rent to be applied in rental periods renewed between 2/7/2023 and 1/7/2024 (these dates inclusive) are valid provided that the rent does not exceed twenty-five per cent of the rent for the previous rental year. Where the rate of change according to the twelve-month averages of the consumer price index for the previous rental year remains below twenty-five per cent, the rate of change applies. This rule also applies to lease contracts with a term of more than one year. Contracts made so as to exceed these rates are invalid as regards the excess amount. The provision of this paragraph also applies to decisions to be given by the judge pursuant to the second paragraph of Article 344.

Entry into force

Article 648 – This Code enters into force on 1 July 2012.

Execution

Article 649 – The provisions of this Code shall be executed by the Council of Ministers.

PROVISIONS THAT COULD NOT BE INCORPORATED INTO LAW NO. 6098

1- Provision of Law No. 6217 of 31/3/2011:

Provisional Article 2 – (Amended: 4/7/2012-6353/53 art.)

In leases of business premises where the lessee is a person regarded as a merchant under the Turkish Commercial Code or a legal entity of private or public law, Articles 323, 325, 331, 340, 342, 343, 344, 346 and 354 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 of 11/1/2011 shall not be applied for a period of 8 years from 1/7/2012. In this case, with regard to the matters specified in these articles, the provisions of the lease contract shall be applied in accordance with the principle of freedom of contract. In cases for which the lease contract contains no provision, the provisions of the repealed Code of Obligations shall apply.

LIST SHOWING THE DATES OF ENTRY INTO FORCE OF LEGISLATION AMENDING OR SUPPLEMENTING LAW NO. 6098 OR OF CONSTITUTIONAL COURT DECISIONS

Number of the Amending Law / Decree-Law or of the Annulling Constitutional Court DecisionAmended or Annulled Articles of Law No. 6098Date of Entry into Force
6111151/7/2012
6217Provision not incorporated14/4/2011
6353Provision not incorporated12/7/2012
645558411/4/2013
KHK/700256, 407On the date on which the President took the oath and assumed office following the elections for the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye and the Presidency held together on 24/6/2018 (9/7/2018)
7161344On its date of publication, with effect from 1/1/2019
7409Provisional Article 111/6/2022
7456Provisional Article 215/7/2023
75895531/7/2026

FOOTNOTES

1. By Article 190 of Decree-Law No. 700 of 2/7/2018, the phrase “Council of Ministers” in this paragraph was amended to read “President of the Republic”. ↩

2. This article shall not be applied for a period of 8 years from 1/7/2012. In this case, with respect to the matters specified in these articles, the provisions of the lease contract shall be applied in leases by virtue of freedom of contract. Where the lease contract contains no provision, the provisions of the repealed Code of Obligations shall apply. ↩

3. By Article 56 of Law No. 7161 of 17/1/2019, the phrases “increase in the producer price index” in the first and second paragraphs of this article were amended to read “change according to the twelve-month averages of the consumer price index”. ↩

4. By Article 56 of Law No. 7161 of 17/1/2019, the phrase “increase in the producer price index” in the third paragraph of this article was amended to read “change according to the twelve-month averages of the consumer price index”, and the phrase “provided that the provisions of the Law on the Protection of the Value of the Turkish Currency No. 1567 of 20/2/1930 are reserved,” was added to the fourth paragraph of the article after the phrase “has been agreed,”. ↩

5. By Article 190 of Decree-Law No. 700 of 2/7/2018, the phrase “the Ministry of Labour and Social Security, the Ministry of Finance and the Minister of State responsible for the Undersecretariat of Treasury jointly” in this paragraph was amended to read “the Presidency of the Republic”. ↩

Baris Erkan Celebi is an English-speaking Turkish lawyer who exclusively represents foreign investors in Turkey. His law firm in Turkey specializes in providing international investors in Turkey with reliable legal counsel and personalized business solutions.

Contact Form

Baris Erkan Celebi is an English-speaking Turkish lawyer who exclusively represents foreign investors in Turkey. His law firm in Turkey specializes in providing international investors in Turkey with reliable legal counsel and personalized business solutions.

First & Last Name

antalya law firm office